St. Elmo Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

1. St. Elmo Steak House

9.3
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 182 tips and reviews

James D.James DeGraffenreidt: Classic steak house ambience featuring wood panelling and friendly noise level. Good spirits list, especially rye and bourbon whiskies. Steaks, salads and desserts were very good. Large portions.

Luz Z.Luz ZS: The bone-in cowboy ribeye it's just perfectly delicious!! :9

Terri S.Terri Sigai: Absolutely everything is Devine. Steaks perfect, shrimp cocktail is amazing and a must have. Extensive wine list.

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

2. Harry & Izzy's

9.2
153 S Illinois St (at W Georgia St in Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 97 tips and reviews

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Can't complain with St. Elmo's shrimp cocktail, fabulous steaks, and the place for prime people watching.

Bryan S.Bryan Spriggs: Izzy style New York strip and Tuscan pasta are both fantastic, and Cedric ( our waiter ) was phenomenal

Kari B.Kari Butcher: Steaks are great and definitely try the slab of cheese cake!! And ask for Cedric great server :-)

The Capital Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

3. The Capital Grille

9.3
40 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 37 tips and reviews

Joe V.Joe Vasquez: Don't forget to try the steak rubs to enhance your steak. The Kona and Porcini rubs are great on any steak.

Chris G.Chris Goulet: Try the Steak (Delmonico) - Killer. #ET12

CharityCharity: The sea bass was amazing and the steak tartare was unique but delicious. Outstanding service !

Ruth's Chris Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

4. Ruth's Chris Steak House

8.5
45 S Illinois St (Circle Centre Mall), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 25 tips and reviews

Joe B.Joe Blackburn: Order your steak Oscar style with extra butter. Request Christina T. or Tammy for your servers...

Tela P.Tela Perkins: Absolutely the best steakhouse in the city .....wow!!! Worth the money!

Joshua M.Joshua Moore: The sweet potatoes are the best! My steak was only so-so

Sahm's Place is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

5. Sahm's Place

8.6
2411 E 65th St (at N Keystone Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Glendale · 38 tips and reviews

Nikolai S.Nikolai S.: Seconding the amazing steak sandwich!

Steve S.Steve Smiley: Steak sandwich and sour cream coffee cake are awesome.

Mel A.Mel Allen: Awesome menu. Don't miss the shrimp cigars and steak sandwich!

Harry & Izzy's is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

6. Harry & Izzy's

8.7
4050 E 82nd St (Dean Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Castleton · 50 tips and reviews

Kelly T.Kelly Taylor-Foster: Best Steak ever put in my mouth! Best Staff !

Nicholas L.Nicholas Lloyd: Great steak

Kasey M.Kasey May: Steak and wonderful atmosphere

Texas Roadhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

7. Texas Roadhouse

7.8
1405 N Shadeland Ave (at E. 14th St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · East Gate · 30 tips and reviews

Bro Jeff W.Bro Jeff Wolfe: If you like Ribs and Chix and your Spouse likes Sirloin and Ribeye, the get the ribeye and Chix dinner and Sirloin and Ribs Dinner, then swap when you get home - works great!!!

David L.David Leszcynski: Great food for great prices. Love getting mushrooms and onions on my steak.

Mario R.Mario Ramon: These biscuits are $$

Weber Grill Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

8. Weber Grill Restaurant

8.3
110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 88 tips and reviews

Steve DickersonSteve Dickerson: Try the seafood gumbo tonight and a NY Strip!

Samantha V.Samantha VanWye: Great ribs and steak!

Kelvin W.Kelvin Webb: One of the best steaks you'll ever taste. All meat is cooked on an open weber grill!!!

Ruth's Chris Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

9. Ruth's Chris Steakhouse

8.9
2727 E 86th St (Keystone & W 86th), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Nora - Far Northside · 6 tips and reviews

Bryan R.Bryan Richardson: Steak and Shrimp

Nieka D.Nieka D.: Petite Ribeye is to die for!

Cory B.Cory Brown: It's gonna cost you but it's worth it. Don't hold back and get a ribeye w/ the bone in, start off w/ lobster bisque, and finish the meal off with a slice of carrot cake, made right in the restaurant

Mesh is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

10. Mesh

8.7
725 Massachusetts Ave (N Park), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Chatham Arch · 54 tips and reviews

Stacy H.Stacy Hoehle: Get the steak with the fried onions on top. Awesome!

Sara M.Sara Moore: Horrible horrible service and terrible food...whatever you do don't order a steak they can't cook them properly.

Erika B.Erika Brask: The filet is one of the best steaks I have ever eaten. If you order it, you won't be disappointed.

Ale Emporium is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

11. Ale Emporium

9.1
8617 Allisonville Rd (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
Sports Bar · Castleton · 98 tips and reviews

Katie A.Katie Anderson: Tuesday steak special: salad, soup, baked potato, and bacon wrapped filet for $6.95! And all bottles are 20% off on Tuesday!

Jeff W.Jeff Woodward: Tuesday steak diner special Read more.

Brooke K.Brooke Killey: Steak dinner for $6.95 & 20% off bottles Tuesday nights.

Ruth's Chris Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

12. Ruth's Chris Steak House

8.2
9445 Threel Rd (96th Street & Keystone), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Keystone at The Crossing · 22 tips and reviews

Douglas K.Douglas Karr: Cowboy ribeye is an amazing steak. Read more.

S M.S M: Best steak, lamb chops you name it! Loved the lobster voodoo on the side! Creme brûlée with berries was the perfect end to a perfect meal!!!

Paula G.Paula G.: I decided to make a review after my 3rd visit in this place. I really want to recommend their steak.

LongHorn Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

13. LongHorn Steakhouse

7.7
5840 W 86th St (Zionsville Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Park 100 · 13 tips and reviews

Samantha J.Samantha Jones: The steaks here are WAY better than Outback, hands down

Morgan W.Morgan Wilson: New York strip steak. Perfection..

Morgan W.Morgan Wilson: Cesar Salad is garbage. Hardly any dressing. Get the New York Strip steak its deliciousss

Bynum's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

14. Bynum's Steakhouse

8.3
3850 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · 14 tips and reviews

Mick W.Mick Welling: All the steaks are good. NY STRIP is my favorite, but they are known for their Prime Rib. Bone-In, it's huge.

Brian H.Brian Ho: Bone-in ribeye is amazing!

Shayne d.Shayne dye: Steak, Prime Rib Salad, French Onion soup

Chris's Ice Cream and Mexican Food is one of The 15 Best Places for a Steak in Indianapolis.

15. Chris's Ice Cream and Mexican Food

8.2
1357 E 86th Street (86th and Westfield Blvd.), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Nora - Far Northside · 12 tips and reviews

Jasmine W.Jasmine Woodruff: BEST STEAK BURRITO I'VE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!!! decor is not great, but it's clean and hands down the best authentic mexican in the city. The ice cream is homemade and great too. He keeps the flatscree

Holly G.Holly Garrett: First time here today - SO GLAD we took a chance on this place! The steak tacos are second to none!

April G.April Gregory: ICE CREAM and REAL MEXICAN TACOS at the same place? Hidden right in front of our eyes! Steak tacos & enchiladas all the way. The ice cream is so good too. No frills. Just real.