Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

1. Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito

8.4
641 Virginia Ave (Virginia at College), Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Fletcher Place · 29 tips and reviews

Margie W.Margie Wilson: Nice place! tortas are incredible! Love it!

Paul C.Paul Cruz: I am originally from Southern California, and I find most of the Mexican food in the Mid-West to be very bland and unappealing. It's great to find a place with real authentic tortas in Indianapolis!

Dana P.Dana Parker: Try the Penelope Cruz, lots of tasty queso fresco, a well cooked egg, and a great torta

Bakersfield Mass Ave is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

2. Bakersfield Mass Ave

8.9
334 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 107 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: The queso is sooo good! I had a torta and loved it, as well. The tortas are huge!

Matthew S.Matthew Sadler: You can't miss with the mole tacos and short rib torta. The chicken chorizo tostada was not as impressive and the guacamole was bland. Overall it was a good meal, just stick with their popular items.

Ken S.Ken S: The tacos are great as are the tortas!!

The Tamale Place is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

3. The Tamale Place

8.8
5226 Rockville Rd (Lynhurst), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 88 tips and reviews

Megan J.Megan Jackson: The girl bashing on this place is an idiot with no taste buds. This place is the BEST place to go to in the Indy area for authentic Mexican tamales and tortas.

ReggieReggie: Try a spicy chicken chipotle torta. You won't regret it!

Kevin J.Kevin Jones: Authentic delicious good value. The chipotle chicken tamale was amazing. Get the combo they give you a ton of food

Taqueria Guanajuato is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

4. Taqueria Guanajuato

8.3
3110 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Grocery Store · 14 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: A huge selection in the grocery store with great prices on produce and a massive spice/chile section. The restaurant inside the grocery store has amazing burritos, tortas and tacos.

LeMar B.LeMar Batie: Get the sandwich with chicken and steak. It has bean guacamole tomato lettuce hot sauce cheese and mayo.

Allan S.Allan Summers: The food is FIRE! A "best kept secret" if you will. You can't beat $4 burritos that are better than Qdoba AND Chipotle!

Guanajuato is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

5. Guanajuato

8.4
5210 W Pike Plaza Rd (at Lafayette Bl), Indianapolis, IN
Grocery Store · 20 tips and reviews

Ashton K.Ashton Kleemann: Cubano torta or marinated steak tacos and chase it down with horchata

Justis G.Justis Gipson: Some of the best tacos on the westside! And great service.

KatherineKatherine: Probably the largest Mexican grocery store in Indianapolis.

The Legend Irvington Cafe is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

6. The Legend Irvington Cafe

5614 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Irvington · 37 tips and reviews

Christopher C.Christopher Commons: Get the Tomato Basil soup and the Feta Cheese Torta appetizer. Dip the cheesy bread in the soup and enjoy!!!

Justine J.Justine Jordan: Order the Feta Cheese Torte appetizer! Delicious!

Karina O.Karina Oertel: Shrimp Cocktail comparable to St. Elmo's!

Carniceria Guanajuato is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

7. Carniceria Guanajuato

8.2
1269 Oliver Ave (South St), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · West Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews

ChristinaChristina: Want to try the torta Milanese

ReshaeReshae: Justin Beiber piñatas sold here, seriously though this place is great!

Thomas H.Thomas Hailey: I love pineapple water!!!

La Bamba is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

8. La Bamba

8.4
3820 Lafayette Rd (at 38th St), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

QZ S.QZ Smith: Excellent food! Burrito as big as your head!

Mark A.Mark Apple: Burritos as big as your mama's ass.

Serra Z.Serra Zander: Get the toung! It's amazing!

Los Rancheros is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

9. Los Rancheros

7.1
7437 Pendleton Pike (at Pendleton Way), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

RaignRaign: This place offers wonderful food and perfect margaritas!

Brad W.Brad Wingfield: Queso is bad ass as is Texas fajitas. Hmmmm

Erin B.Erin Barnett Nichols: Get the tacos al pastor!!

Ambrosia is one of The 11 Best Places for Tortas in Indianapolis.

10. Ambrosia

7.4
915 E Westfield Blvd (at Guilford Av), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 15 tips and reviews

Johnny W.Johnny Wright: Pollo al Chantagiana all day everyday. Best chicken dish in the Midwest.

Johnny W.Johnny Wright: Pollo alla chiantigiana is my personal favorite. If you enjoy sundried tomatoes get this dish!

William W.William Waldren: Tiramisu rocks!!