Shrimp cocktail, Lobster Bisque, and a huge hunk o' Prime Rib..
Shrimp Cocktail is amazing and the cocktails are even better. Try the Bloody Mary that is made with St. E's famous cocktail sauce!
Shrimp Cocktail... need I say more!
The Shrimp Cocktail and the Shrimp penny was great. Our server, Sir, was excellent and took real good care of us.
Try their Fried Green Tomatoes... one of my favorites when I am in town!
The St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich is on the Super 46 Sandwiches
Best steak, lamb chops you name it! Loved the lobster voodoo on the side! Creme brûlée with berries was the perfect end to a perfect meal!!!
Cowboy ribeye is an amazing steak. Read more.
If I could make love to the filet here, I would. :)
Great place for steaks, not crowded like others
Really nice ambiance. Super nice liquor selection.
Exceptional job at rendering the fat on well-marbled steaks. Much better wine and liquor list than other steakhouses in downtown.
The sliders, steaks, pizza, smoked pork chops, lamb...
The lunch special is $20, and you get three courses. Not a cheap lunch, but worth every penny.
Great service. Great food. Great times. Get the shrimp cocktail and a pomegranate martini! Thank me later. ; )
Everything is good here but the Prime cuts are the best. You will not be disappointed with your meal.
Beginning October 1,2013 you have to pay $2.00 per person if you bring in your own birthday cake.
John is one of the best servers we've ever had anywhere! They are making the nuts for the salad request only so if you like them remember to ask and you'll get them. Not a bad thing on the menu.
I did enjoy the lobster bisque! Perfectly cooked cluster of lobster in a wonderfully flavored bisque. I will assume it was prepared fresh today.
1/2 price martinis on Thursday! Read more.
Recommend steak, mushrooms, and Gorgonzola butter!
The porterhouse for two, gives you filet and strip, with the sizzling butter, yummy! Martin's presentation was fab. Definitely one of Indys best steaks!
Kelli is the best!
Just amazing
The service and food was excellent. If you are celebrating a special occasion, they give you a crème brulee which was outstanding!
Our specialties are prime aged beef and seafood. Let us know how we can serve you!
Don't forget to order the Eddie's Potatoes! Awesome!
Shrimp are a fun and tasty appetizer even if it is a very tenuous link to their wild west theme. Steaks are always good quality here.
The steaks here are WAY better than Outback, hands down
The Managing Partner at this restaurant is AWESOME!! Chris T. is the best Bartender/Server (in my humble opinion) here!! It's totally worth trying!!
Sierra Chicken is fantastic here. And the blackberry tea
Sierra Chicken is wonderful! Love the tomato basil salsa :)
Ask for Sylvanie. She is a Super Server!
Alex is an awesome server: very attentive, friendly. Steaks are reasonably priced and quite affordable.
Just can't beat the steaks for this price.
The bread and cinnamon butter is fire!
Great food for great prices. Love getting mushrooms and onions on my steak.
If you like Ribs and Chix and your Spouse likes Sirloin and Ribeye, the get the ribeye and Chix dinner and Sirloin and Ribs Dinner, then swap when you get home - works great!!!
These biscuits are $$
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA