Strathmore Bagels is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

1. Strathmore Bagels

7.9
1879 Lakeland Ave, Ronkonkoma, NY
Bagel Shop · 17 tips and reviews

Bill N.Bill Nofi: Great bagels!

William Z.William Zezelic: Great bagels and salads!!

John M.John M: Not as good as the Mt Sinai location unfortunately.. Still they've got a good groove going here, coffee is okay, bagels are good and sandwiches are okay.

B & B Bagels is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

2. B & B Bagels

7.2
4641 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia, NY
Bagel Shop · 8 tips and reviews

Seth B.Seth Berman: Ok the bagels are great but the service is the worst. Leave plenty of time and check your order

Cassie F.Cassie Farrell: Just went here for the first time and it was probably the most pleasant experience I've had at a bagel store

Robert E.Robert Elrose: Great bagels, egg sandwiches and specialty spreads, sad part is all this is overshadowed by the poor attitude of some of the staff & all around slow service. 20+ minutes for an egg sandwich is crazy!

Dunkin' is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

3. Dunkin'

7.7
4541 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia, NY
Donut Shop · 5 tips and reviews

Frank S.Frank Sforza: Everything bagel with cream cheese and black coffee

Leena H.Leena Hnetinka: Friendly Staff & Fast service, I ordered coffee and cheese burger :-)

Angela L.Angela Luongo: This Dunkin Donuts has the friendliest staff of all. Love those guys!

Pioneer Market is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

4. Pioneer Market

7.6
21 Broadway, Fair Harbor, NY
Grocery Store · 5 tips and reviews

Ariel H.Ariel Hyat: This may be the most expensive grocery store on earth but you are on Fire Island so life is grand ( oh get there early fur bagels which are wonderful )

Jack A.Jack Agnes: Just very friendly and have everything you need

Peter S.Peter Schmidt: check out our web page - http://pioneermarket.net/

Holbrook Bagel Bakery is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

5. Holbrook Bagel Bakery

7.5
1073 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Bagel Shop · 4 tips and reviews

Kenneth L.Kenneth Lind: Bagels, pastry, coffee

Valerie N.Valerie Nicole: Best egg sandwiches in holbrook

Lucy C.Lucy Cee: Fresh challah for Rosh Hashanah.

Atlantis Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

6. Atlantis Diner

7.6
Montauk Highway (Route 231), Babylon, NY
Diner · 25 tips and reviews

Vincent D.Vincent DeAngelis: Friendly, and a pleasure to visit for a quick meal, weather just a bagel or a healthy meal.

RichRich: Best Diner in the area. My family and I eat here at least once a week.

The Mexican .The Mexican 👧: I'm drunk, food is good

Panera Bread is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

7. Panera Bread

7.8
1701 Sunrise Hwy Unit A16, Bay Shore, NY
Bakery · 14 tips and reviews

Marcus P.Marcus Pierre: Chai is great! However, you may need a bathroom close by part of the day. Worth it!

Wilfred T.Wilfred TR: The BearClaw is sinfully good

Erik K.Erik Kortright: Bread bowl chicken noodle soup is awesome

Bagel Buzz is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

8. Bagel Buzz

7.5
498 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
Bagel Shop · 2 tips and reviews

Dayana H.Dayana Hering: It's one of the places in west Islip that make the best egg sandwiches!!!

Nora M.Nora Morris: The egg sandwiches are AMAZING. The line is usually to the door but it's sooooo worth the wait!

O-Co-Nee East Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

9. O-Co-Nee East Diner

8.3
749 Main St (Islip Ave.), Islip, NY
Diner · 51 tips and reviews

Vincent D.Vincent DeAngelis: Great informal and friendly place to eat. Always busy and food always top notch.

Evan P.Evan Peoples: BEST DINER ON LONG ISLAND

Tommy G.Tommy Guns: The guy throws cookies at you

Bagels Delox (Hot Bagels!) is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

10. Bagels Delox (Hot Bagels!)

7.1
372 N Main St, Sayville, NY
Bagel Shop · 5 tips and reviews

Michael Z.Michael Z: Expect a long line, but it moves quick. Cash only, but they have an ATM

Haley M.Haley Mckinnon: Now has eggs on sundays!

ReiRei: Great service! But too bad it's cash only

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

11. The Cheesecake Factory

8.2
1701 Sunrise Hwy Westfield South Shore, Bay Shore, NY
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Arnold M.Arnold Marmol: Everything we had was really good ,the nachos is excellent and big

Daniel W.Daniel W: White bean chili and that white raspberry cheesecake. Yes!

john r.john rossiello: Food was right on point as usual but it's the first time I dined in house and I hope tonight's service isn't indicative of the overall staff. They somehow forgot about us and brought wrong entree.

Sakura Sushi is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

12. Sakura Sushi

7.8
580 Veterans Hwy, Hauppauge, NY
Sushi Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Kevin R.Kevin Ran: People are SO nice, food is great. Got the crazy tuna and I loved it. Definitely worth a shot!

Trevor M.Trevor Mohr: The Hauppauge Roll is amazing!

Joe D.Joe DLR: Best food and service in Hauppague

Terrace bagel and bakery shoppe is one of The 13 Best Places for Bagels in Islip.

13. Terrace bagel and bakery shoppe

7.1
876 Connetquot Ave, Islip Terrace, NY
Bagel Shop · 3 tips and reviews

Nicolle M.Nicolle Mroczek: Love the people there. Frank is awesome such a joker

Hugo H.Hugo H: Always double check your order. For some reason they can't get it right. But when they do it's good food.

Lissy A.Lissy Abreu: Great food