Mrs. Mac's Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

1. Mrs. Mac's Kitchen

8.8
99336 Overseas Hwy (mm 99.4 South US Hwy. 1), Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 162 tips and reviews

Melissa R.Melissa Richardson: steamed mussels appetizer was amazing, best mussels we'd ever had. the key lime pie was also fantastic.

Jose H.Jose Herrera: Hog fish was awesome. Best key lime pie ever

Giancarlo Yardy S.Giancarlo Yardy Simpson: Best Key lime pie...and I don't even like key lime lol... Il only eat it here. Great food.

Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

2. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory

8.9
92220 Overseas Hwy Mike 92 (Harbourview Drive), Tavernier, FL
Bakery · 17 tips and reviews

DoriDori: The key lime pie is the best! Great place to eat and relax with your family! Sooo friendly!

Lori G.Lori Grzenia: Key lime pie is outstanding!

Diego R.Diego Reynoso: Best key lime pie around

The Fish House is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

3. The Fish House

8.9
102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 108 tips and reviews

Ashley B.Ashley Baeseman: Lobster bisque, oysters, broiled combo, key lime pie... All fabulous. If u get more than 1 piece of key lime pie just get a whole pie (it's three dollars more than 2 pieces).

Dan M.Dan Murphy: Great place to pick up FRESH seafood and/or a Key Lime Pie as you exit the keys. And the food's pretty good too!

AshleyAshley: Great place! Staff was so friendly and nice. Food was ALL delicious. Fish dip and key lime pie should be a must!

Mrs. Mac's II is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

4. Mrs. Mac's II

8.7
99020 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Restaurant · 26 tips and reviews

ElishaElisha: Try the Key Lime Pie!

Brad L.Brad Lovell: Best key lime pie anywhere in the Keys!

Patrick B.Patrick B: Key lime pie; the sautéed seafood combo; hogfish- all worth the hype

Key Largo Chocolates and Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

5. Key Largo Chocolates and Ice Cream

8.9
100470 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Dessert Shop · 15 tips and reviews

Sherry K.Sherry Kopp Gehl: Frozen key lime pie on a stick dipped in dark chocolate!! :)

FranFran: Frozen key lime pie on a stick is to die for! Perfect mix of tart & sweet!!!!

FLAfamilyguruFLAfamilyguru: Frozen key lime pie on a stick is five stars!

Key Lime Products is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

6. Key Lime Products

8.4
95200 Overseas Hwy (Btwn Snapper Ln and Lobster Ln), Key Largo, FL
Gift Store · 15 tips and reviews

Bryan R.Bryan Reeves: Get the fish sandwich (it's fried). Def try the chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick!

Jade P.Jade Precious: Best key lime pie in the keys! Not too sweet and jut sour enough.

*Sabrina*Sabrina: From pirate flags, to key lime pies to guys carving swamp wood with chainsaws, this is a great place to stop. Try their award winning key lime products!!

Ballyhoo's is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

7. Ballyhoo's

7.5
97860 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 32 tips and reviews

Jeanette B.Jeanette Brender: Great cracked conch and the BEST Key Lime Pie!

Mauricio W.Mauricio Wencelblat: Best Key Lime pie, amazing service.

Amber S.Amber Smith: The key lime pie is to die for its the best around !!

Hobo's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

8. Hobo's Cafe

8.2
101691 Overseas Hwy ((MM 101)), Key Largo, FL
Café · 57 tips and reviews

DavidDavid: Very friendly service. Have the cool refreshing slice key lime pie.

Chelsea C.Chelsea Chiodo: Best key lime pie ever!!!!

Ali M.Ali Mountain: The quesadillas are amazing! And the key lime pie... SO good

Sundowners is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

9. Sundowners

8.5
103900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 69 tips and reviews

Elizabeth M.Elizabeth Melo: Sit outside on a beautiful day and definitely try their key lime pie.

Paula F.Paula Freire: Nice view, friendly staff. Good Key Lime Pie. And that's it!

Joelle P.Joelle Parfrey: Key lime pie was scrumptious!!!

Key Largo Conch House is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

10. Key Largo Conch House

7.8
100211 Overseas Hwy (Holiday Blvd.), Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · MM 100 oceanside · 74 tips and reviews

Larry B.Larry Burton: Great Key Lime Pie

AaronAaron: This place is awesome. Great food. Crab cakes for an appetizer. For the main entree, I definitely recommend the crab cake stuffed Mahi topped with with Lobster bisque. For dessert, get key lime pie.

Girish L.Girish Lalla: Great low key spot. As mentioned conch fritters and lobster bisque are great. House made key lime pie rocks!

Bayside Grille is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

11. Bayside Grille

8.0
99540 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 44 tips and reviews

J L.J L V: Could be the best key lime pie I have ever had.

Sam O.Sam Olivares: Great place to watch the sunset. Make sure to try the key lime pie.

Mohammad R.Mohammad Roman: Everything we hade was average including the service. Would not come back. Key lime pie was also just average..

Shipwrecks Bar & Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

12. Shipwrecks Bar & Grill

8.1
45 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo, FL
Bar · 27 tips and reviews

AnnetteAnnette: Stopped for a couple of hours BC of a wreck and traffic was backed up. Key Lime pie is awesome and very friendly service. Topped off with a flower from the waitress for Mother's Day

Rose A.Rose A: My partner and I ordered the jalapeño poppers, crab cake sandwich, blackened Mahi Mahi and the key lime pie. Everything was delicious and have great price performance. Highly recommend!

Eileen M.Eileen Marie: Great local establishment. We brought our own fish; the blackened preparation was amazing; ditto on the grilled & the sautéed preparations. I will not be responsible if you order the peanut butter pie

Key Largo Fisheries is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

13. Key Largo Fisheries

9.0
1313 Ocean Bay Dr Ste B, Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 34 tips and reviews

Chaise C.Chaise Candie: Great lobster BLT and Key Lime Pie. If you're headed back to Miami stop in to pick up some fresh fish off the dock to take home.

Jen R.Jen Rickmann: You will love anything you order! Lobster sliders and conch salad are my favorites.

Julie J.Julie Jacob: Great place for lunch or early dinner. Loved the lobster blt and dolphin Cuban. Very casual, so no need to get fancy.

Lazy Lobster is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

14. Lazy Lobster

9.0
102770 Overseas Highway MM 102 (Canal St), Key Largo, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

FLAfamilyguruFLAfamilyguru: Good key lime pie!

Angie O.Angie Osmanski: We had the surf & turf. Get the Lobster thermador for turf! Don’t leave without the key lime pie! The service was terrific!! house wine was a good selection. Tiki decor and atmosphere was perfect!

RCRC: This lobster tarragon was great! Also the thermador was excellent. Salads are fresh and the specials are an added bonus.

Buzzard's Roost is one of The 15 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Key Largo.

15. Buzzard's Roost

8.1
21 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo, FL
American Restaurant · 32 tips and reviews

Mark P.Mark Patzke: The Key lime pie and Coconut cake were outstanding!!

Cindy R.Cindy R-C: Great food and a beautiful view. This is favorite place all year around!

Rick M.Rick Martínez: It's hard to go wrong here. Lobster Reuben, oysters, and peel-and-eat shrimp are all so excellent.