Blue Heaven is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

1. Blue Heaven

9.3
729 Thomas St (at Petronia St), Key West, FL
Breakfast Spot · 363 tips and reviews

HeatherHeather: lobster omlette was the best thing i have ever eatten! in my opinion the best restaurant in key west.......Home made bread, relaxing enviroment and friendly wait staff!

Becky B.Becky Brown: Love the shrimp omelet with goat cheese!

Marcel P.Marcel P.: amazing place. lobster benedict is delicious, blueberry pancakes taste like heaven, omelettes are awesome and the staff is fun and super friendly

D.J.'s Clam Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

2. D.J.'s Clam Shack

8.9
629 Duval St (at Angela St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 59 tips and reviews

Fran G.Fran Garcia: $3 drafts lobster roll is awesome tiny out of the way, worth it!

Tobias N.Tobias Negele: Probably the best shrimp taco I ever had. You have to go there! Order the sweet potato fries and ask for the special sauce. Absolutely amazing.

Gajtana S.Gajtana Simonovska: Excellent service, cozy patio space, and good food. Lobster 7/10, onion rings and sweet potato fries 8/10, and large hot dog 9/10. Hidden gem on Duval.

Conch Republic Seafood Company is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

3. Conch Republic Seafood Company

8.5
631 Greene St (at Elizabeth St.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 191 tips and reviews

NataliaNatalia: Excellent! Oysters, lobster, shrimps, calamari - everything was delicious! The only restaurant in the area, which was completely fool during the lunch time.

Kayley M.Kayley McDowell: Great seafood! Loved the fish tanks!

Steffi R.Steffi Raimann: happy hour, seafood and place are great!!

Half Shell Raw Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

4. Half Shell Raw Bar

8.2
231 Margaret St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 93 tips and reviews

Ern P.Ern Pui: Awesome food and service! Oysters, stone crab, fish were all excellent. Tables by the water provided great view :)

tessa l.tessa lowe: If it's happy hour be sure to order plenty of apps and drinks. Onion rings, oysters & coconut shrimp were all great.

Rivzzz 💋Rivzzz 💋: Get the steamed combo thing. Dolphin fish, scallops, lobster tail. Bomb. And red potatoes.

Garbo's Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

5. Garbo's Grill

9.1
409 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Food Truck · 68 tips and reviews

Leo n.Leo nard: Fish taco = greatness. Get it!

Jan M.Jan Morris: This place was fantastic. I loved the spicy yum yum shrimp tacos and the Korean BBQ pork burrito was equally as fantastic I can only say I am sure we will be back here many times.

JillJill: BEST fish tacos!!! The fish is so fresh & great flavors! Relaxed atmosphere ~ just order your food from Garbos food truck then walk over to Grunts bar & get your cold beverage & grab an outdoor seat

BO's Fish Wagon is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

6. BO's Fish Wagon

8.8
801 Caroline St (at William St.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 54 tips and reviews

Zeb C.Zeb Cheshire: Conch sandwich is better than any in the Bahamas. Any blackened fish sandwich is also amazing!

CaseyCasey: Sat at the bar area, Great people watching (Pretty entertaining in key west)! Grilled mahi (catch of the day) was spot on, slaw was delish, and conch fritters were killer. Get the key limeade!!!!

Cassandra T.Cassandra Toppino: Best fish sandwich and conch fritters in town

Schooner Wharf Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

7. Schooner Wharf Bar

8.6
202 William St, Key West, FL
Bar · 124 tips and reviews

Michael P.Michael Platt: Fish Taco is excellent!!! It is a must get!

Elizabeth H.Elizabeth Hussey: Fish tacos amazing. I mean amazingly delicious. View from the roof is nice. I will definitely be back.

Andrew R.Andrew R: Rum runner with a shot or Meyers and fish tacos will do you right

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

8. The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

8.8
1100 Packer St (Virginia St.), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

GulfscapesGulfscapes: Tonight pan-seared hogfish w/ banana salsa, grilled black grouper w/ lime butter sauce, seafood marinara in a gremolatta tossed penne pasta, black bean soup, lobster mac & cheese

CamillaCamilla: Great place, friendly serving, lovely food(especially surf'n'turf and lobster macaroni and cheese)- not a touriattrap as many places on Key West

Andy R.Andy Riesenberg: great place, great service. Not your cookie cutter tourist restaurant. Sit outside. The appetizer trio (shrimp, ceviche, and lobster Mac n cheese) was my fav.

Alonzo's Oyster Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

9. Alonzo's Oyster Bar

7.8
700 Front St (at Margaret St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 93 tips and reviews

Tracy S.Tracy Shirk Kelley: The Baked Key Lime Oysters were great, as well as the Buffalo Shrimp! Best time to go is happy hour 4p-6p, huge selection of half price apps and drinks!

Jennifer R.Jennifer Russo: The oyster combo plate is great - you can try key lime, buffalo and spinach baked oysters. :-)

Peyton W.Peyton Wade: Conch Fritters, Steamed Clams, Calamari, It's All Good!!!!

Two Friends Patio Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

10. Two Friends Patio Restaurant

8.1
512 Front St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 84 tips and reviews

Theresa P.Theresa Phillips: For $29.99 you get lobster, shrimp, scallops , rice & salad!!! Awesome dinner:)

Tricia B.Tricia Bellamy: Good crab sandwich and homemade potato chips! The key lime pie was delicious!!

Steve S.Steve Schroeder: The best Bloody Mary I have ever had - the spicy, pickled green beans are a very nice touch. I had the Crab Cake Benedict and it was great as well.

A&B Lobster House Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

11. A&B Lobster House Restaurant

8.3
700 Front St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 39 tips and reviews

Nat B.Nat B.: Excellent lobster pasta and lobster bisque !!!

Patrick B.Patrick Buffard: Great seafood : try the Maine lobster !!

David S.David Schwartz: This restaurant sits dockside, which might account for the fresh, awesome seafood. Try the Buffalo Shrimp and everything else on the menu.

Seven Fish is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

12. Seven Fish

8.2
632 Olivia St (at Elizabeth St), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 44 tips and reviews

MonaMona: Signature dishes like curry snapper and grouper with mango chutney is wonderful. Reservation is a must.

AndrewAndrew: Curry snapper is incredible...a must have when visiting Key West.

Ubiratã S.Ubiratã Silva: I just have to say: as a Brazilian, I am used to eating good seafood.But the seafood marinara pasta (beware, it's spicy) is THE BEST seafood pasta I've ever had.And the curry snapper is also awesome.

Eaton Street Seafood Market is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

13. Eaton Street Seafood Market

8.6
801 Eaton St, Key West, FL
Fish Market · 16 tips and reviews

James D.James Davis: Excellent food! Try the Salmon Sandwich & Crab Cake Sandwich!! Fresh Fish!!!

Dwight L.Dwight Leeper: Great place for fresh seafood when you want to eat in. A few specialty items, vegetables and sauces round out the offering. Great place friendly service.

Mary ann K.Mary ann Kavouras: The shrimp salad sandwich on croissant was amazing! Great place to pick up happy hour food to take on a sunset cruise.

Louie's Backyard is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

14. Louie's Backyard

8.7
700 Waddell Ave (at Vernon Ave), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 100 tips and reviews

KaitlinKaitlin: Fish tacos and crab cake Caesar salad are incredible. Don't forget the brownie creme brûlée!

FranFran: Yellowtail Snapper entree was amazing. Must try restaurant in Key West.

Will M.Will Matthews: Pineapple burger and lobster blt were great.

Latitudes Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for a Seafood in Key West.

15. Latitudes Restaurant

8.9
Sunset Key, Sunset Key, FL
American Restaurant · 65 tips and reviews

Kat N.Kat Newbold: Latiudes is amazing and worth every penny! My husband and I had an amazing romantic meal here! The key west shrimp appetizer was amazing as was the perfectly cooked skirt steak!! Yum!

JillJill: Nice ferry ride to Sunset Key! Ask for an outdoor table! the crab & lobster cake app is amazing! the salmon & scallop dinners were delish! The high $$$ is worth every bite!! Go for it!!

Yevgeniya K.Yevgeniya Kats: The mussels and scallops were amazing! Flour less chocolate cake delish