$3 drafts lobster roll is awesome tiny out of the way, worth it!
Lobster roll is tasty and true to New England style. Probably best to come here for lunch to get the best seafood and service.
Love the place. Fresh beer, delicious steam clams and lobster sandwich
the most amazing breakfast. The Lobster Benedict is to die for. The blueberry pancakes are foodgasmic, careful though...the blueberries are so juicy they'll squirt and make you squirt.
This should be a required stop when visiting Key West. Ate here a couple of times this week. Lobster benedict, yellowtail snapper, key lime pie, mimosas, mojitos and banana heaven were all fantastic.!
The lobster eggs Benedict is a must try. Ask for Greg! He is the greatest, happiest server ever.
Awesome food and service! Oysters, stone crab, fish were all excellent. Tables by the water provided great view :)
Try the Oysters - Large oysters. Great horseradish. Yummy.
Best place in Key West for excellent, reasonably priced oysters!
Buffalo shrimp, diablo mussels (ask for extra bread for the sauce) so good!
The keylime oysters and crab stuffed lobster the best ever! Must try
Conch Fritters, Steamed Clams, Calamari, It's All Good!!!!
Excellent lobster pasta and lobster bisque !!!
Lobster bisque is definitely what all the reviews say...AMAZING!! Rebecca was a great server! Still not my fav place on the island, but the lobster bisque ties for first!
Great seafood : try the Maine lobster !!
Order the Lobster Combo! Definitely worth it for Lobster & Shrimps (best shrimps in the Keys!)
Good crab sandwich and homemade potato chips! The key lime pie was delicious!!
Lobster bisque was good... the shrimp were fabulous and the happy hr prices r amazing!! Will b back to try $3 bloody marys fr 8-11am!!:-)
we had crab cakes, bwwf wellington, shrimp and everything was yummy yummy yummy
Must try the stone crabs & florida gold shrimp. Great atmoshere and right near the water.
Excellent food! Try the Salmon Sandwich & Crab Cake Sandwich!! Fresh Fish!!!
Go for lunch. Have a lobster roll! So yummi!
The crab cake sandwich was incredible!!
The lamb and lobster bisque is great
Great lobster roll! Take the arugula salad with it..super!
Nice ferry ride to Sunset Key! Ask for an outdoor table! the crab & lobster cake app is amazing! the salmon & scallop dinners were delish! The high $$$ is worth every bite!! Go for it!!
Fish tacos and crab cake Caesar salad are incredible. Don't forget the brownie creme brûlée!
Order the lobster with truffle butter for an appetizer and the shrimp and grits for your entree. Then thank me :-)
Fried truffles, octopus, maine lobster pie and fish du jour (daily special).
Diablo lobster roll is the absolute best lobster roll anywhere on the island!
Diablo lobster roll is delicious and the staff is super friendly.
I highly recommend the Lobster Shack. In our party of 4 one of us had the traditional, one had the key lime, one hand the bacon & one had the grilled cheese lobster rolls Ahhhhmazing! 😍😋
Great lobster tempura
Really good bread and lobster tempura half price appetizers 3 to 6:30 and drinks
Peel and eat fresh shrimp, garlic bread and the clam chowder were Amazing !!
Lobster Gnocchi is the best = )
The crab cake, from someone who eats a lot of crab cakes, was spectacular. All delicious chunks of crab, held together with wisps of delicious crunch.
The crab cakes are to die for. No filler...all big pieces of crab and shrimp.
3 words....Crab cake benedict...nuff said :-)
The eggs Benedict at $13.99 are overpriced, spend the extra $2 for Crab Cakes Benedict
The Crab Cake BLT is delicious!
Everything about this place is great. We got the cheese and crab dip as an app-- delicious. We split the crab roll for a main dish. Ah-mazing! Free parking in the back!
Really enjoyed the crab sandwich!
Poboys (oyster) are delicious. Had 2 for the price of 1 draft beer. Good service
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA