1. Benji's Deli
9.0
4156 N Oakland Ave (btwn Olive & Wood), Milwaukee, WI
Deli · 47 tips and reviews
Jessica Jacobs: Banana wallet pancakes, the Hear-O--Israel, a reuben, or super hoppel poppel - order any one of these things and you can't go wrong!
Cooper W.: Awesome Reuben. Don't get the potato pancakes $6.75 for a side....
Chris Sherman: Best Reuben I've had! And I've had many!
7. Barnacle Bud's
7.2
1955 S Hilbert St (at Stewart), Milwaukee, WI
Seafood Restaurant · Bay View · 59 tips and reviews
Kevin Plazak: Get the Grouper Reuben, but make sure you dip it!
Rock Smith: Get a seat outside, service is as laid back as everything else about the place. Great oysters, Grouper Reuben is my go-to favorite, but never had a bad meal.
Mark Brouch: Perfect for sitting outside if the weather is nice. Tough to find, but worth the adventure!
Kari R: The Reuben is truly delicious!
Jimi Schutte American Blues: I've been to Aliota's Pub & Grill more than a couple of times. Always great fun, friends, food... and sometimes live music music. I would recommend a visit. You'll be glad you did!
Sinisa Brcinovic: I've been here a few times now and it's always great food and service! John owner/mngr was very nice- talks to his patrons. He asked us how we were doing and thanked us for coming. We are coming back!
11. Comet Cafe
8.7
1947 N Farwell Ave (at E Irving Pl), Milwaukee, WI
Café · Lower East Side · 220 tips and reviews
Eric Johnson: Their veggie Reuben compared to Beans & Barley's is like upgrading to HD color from black & white.
Stephanie Sansoucie: If you're vegan, I highly recommend both the Seitan Philly & the Reuben. Yum and yum!
Tammy: vegan ribs, meatloaf sandwich, bloody mary. all TDF.
13. Mader's Restaurant
8.2
1037 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI
German Restaurant · Kilbourn Town · 39 tips and reviews
Rebecca M: Reuben rolls, ftw. Don't sit in the side alcoves in main dining rm unless u want to share yr convo with everyone.
Kevin Anderson: Great lunch from start to finish. Pretzel bread to start. Excellent service. Great range of dishes from traditional German to an option or two for vegetarians.
Late Night Marquette: Marquette students get 10% discount off entire food purchase. You have to show your MUID!