Benji's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

1. Benji's Deli

9.0
4156 N Oakland Ave (btwn Olive & Wood), Milwaukee, WI
Deli · 47 tips and reviews

Jessica J.Jessica Jacobs: Banana wallet pancakes, the Hear-O--Israel, a reuben, or super hoppel poppel - order any one of these things and you can't go wrong!

Cooper W.Cooper W.: Awesome Reuben. Don't get the potato pancakes $6.75 for a side....

Chris S.Chris Sherman: Best Reuben I've had! And I've had many!

McBob's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

2. McBob's

8.4
4919 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Sandwich Spot · Washington Heights · 106 tips and reviews

Christopher T.Christopher Totsky: Try the Reuben... It's awesome!

Jen V.Jen V: The reuben is the best I've ever had. Meat that melts in your mouth.

LangstonLangston: My vote for best Reubens in the city.

Jake's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

3. Jake's Deli

8.1
1634 W North Ave (17th St), Milwaukee, WI
Deli · 25 tips and reviews

Nick L.Nick Lyons: The best corned beef/ reuben you'll ever have in your life. End of discussion. See how it's meant to be done.

Ryan W.Ryan Woodington: Try the Reuben

BroidyBroidy: I grew up in NYC and I can say this place has legit Jewish style deli food. Can't go wrong with the Reuben or anything pastrami or corned beef based.

O'Lydias is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

4. O'Lydias

8.3
338 S 1st St (Florida St), Milwaukee, WI
Beer Garden · 54 tips and reviews

MaggsboppMaggsbopp: Reuben rolls. Eat em.

Dori Z.Dori Z: Wed all u can eat pasta $6 and get the reuben rolls

Gail F.Gail Fiebrink: Reuben w/ fries, so awful. so greasy couldn't eat. Huge disappointment. reuben rolls bad too. NOT WORTH $31! .Top 10 list, NOT!.

Highlands Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

5. Highlands Cafe

8.0
1413 N 60th St, Milwaukee, WI
Café · 28 tips and reviews

GregGreg: The chicken avocado and reuben sandwiches were awesome!

Travis P.Travis Peartree: Reuben was great.

John G.John Gehrke: All bakery from Simma's. Try the scone's with a latte. Can't go wrong!

McGinn's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

6. McGinn's

7.4
5901 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI
Pub · Bluemound Heights · 24 tips and reviews

Chris S.Chris Sherman: The Reuben Sandwich is the best!

Ryan S.Ryan Scherff: Brewers fan lair. Reuben is delicious! Doesn't cost to park in their lot. Food is filling. "Free" shuttle ride is actually free with purchase of food or drink. Recommended for Brewers games.

Heather C.Heather Churchill: Irish nachos are amazing and huge

Barnacle Bud's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

7. Barnacle Bud's

7.2
1955 S Hilbert St (at Stewart), Milwaukee, WI
Seafood Restaurant · Bay View · 59 tips and reviews

Kevin P.Kevin Plazak: Get the Grouper Reuben, but make sure you dip it!

Rock S.Rock Smith: Get a seat outside, service is as laid back as everything else about the place. Great oysters, Grouper Reuben is my go-to favorite, but never had a bad meal.

Mark B.Mark Brouch: Perfect for sitting outside if the weather is nice. Tough to find, but worth the adventure!

Soup Otzie's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

8. Soup Otzie's

8.3
3950 S Howell Ave (E Van Beck Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Soup Spot · Tippecanoe · 22 tips and reviews

Linnea E.Linnea Esberg: Best soup ever had celery and apple and cream of Reuben today num

JenniferJennifer: Black bear here and sauerkraut and pork soup is very good! Cash or check only but all soups are with fresh ingredients hard to find!

Aga A.Aga Artka: They only take cash. Or check with ID.

Aliota's Pub & Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

9. Aliota's Pub & Grill

8.2
261 E Hampton Rd (btwn Santa Monica & Anita), Milwaukee, WI
Pub · 13 tips and reviews

Kari R.Kari R: The Reuben is truly delicious!

Jimi Schutte A.Jimi Schutte American Blues: I've been to Aliota's Pub & Grill more than a couple of times. Always great fun, friends, food... and sometimes live music music. I would recommend a visit. You'll be glad you did!

Sinisa B.Sinisa Brcinovic: I've been here a few times now and it's always great food and service! John owner/mngr was very nice- talks to his patrons. He asked us how we were doing and thanked us for coming. We are coming back!

McKiernan's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

10. McKiernan's

7.8
Milwaukee, WI
Bar · Burnham Park · 15 tips and reviews

Stacy S.Stacy Schmeling: Awesome reuben rolls!

RichardRichard: Eat the wings on wednesday with a fine shot of whiskey! Don't you dare forget about taco Tuesday. Tip your hat to the chief.

Evelyn K.Evelyn Kaquatosh: Highly recommend the bloody mary bar on Sundays!

Comet Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

11. Comet Cafe

8.7
1947 N Farwell Ave (at E Irving Pl), Milwaukee, WI
Café · Lower East Side · 220 tips and reviews

Eric J.Eric Johnson: Their veggie Reuben compared to Beans & Barley's is like upgrading to HD color from black & white.

Stephanie S.Stephanie Sansoucie: If you're vegan, I highly recommend both the Seitan Philly & the Reuben. Yum and yum!

TammyTammy: vegan ribs, meatloaf sandwich, bloody mary. all TDF.

Amelia's is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

12. Amelia's

8.1
724 E Layton Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Karaoke Bar · Town of Lake · 42 tips and reviews

Terissa S.Terissa Streicher: Love the reuben

Dr. BergeronDr. Bergeron: all the sandwiches here are awesome. Get the philly cheesesteak pizza. It's a winner!

Christin "X1" L.Christin "X1" L: Parking sucks

Mader's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

13. Mader's Restaurant

8.2
1037 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI
German Restaurant · Kilbourn Town · 39 tips and reviews

Rebecca M.Rebecca M: Reuben rolls, ftw. Don't sit in the side alcoves in main dining rm unless u want to share yr convo with everyone.

Kevin A.Kevin Anderson: Great lunch from start to finish. Pretzel bread to start. Excellent service. Great range of dishes from traditional German to an option or two for vegetarians.

Late Night M.Late Night Marquette: Marquette students get 10% discount off entire food purchase. You have to show your MUID!

Beans & Barley is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

14. Beans & Barley

9.1
1901 E North Ave (at E Kenilworth Pl), Milwaukee, WI
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Lower East Side · 90 tips and reviews

Karren J.Karren Jeske: Try the tempeh Reuben. We’ve been ordering and loving it for more than 30 years!

Zak S.Zak Suhar: Love this restaurant. So many great vegetarian options too!

Jason R.Jason Reichel: Come early and don't be afraid to wait on weekends. It's worth it.

Riverwest Co-Op and Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Milwaukee.

15. Riverwest Co-Op and Cafe

9.1
733 E Clarke St (N Fratney St), Milwaukee, WI
Café · Riverwest · 22 tips and reviews

Stephanie S.Stephanie Sura: They put chicago soy dairy vegan teese on everything! Love!

Toast M.Toast Milwaukee: Leave a tip!!!

Jenn H.Jenn Harris: Delicious brunch items, many vegan options and local produce. Highly recommend. Read more.