Billy's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

1. Billy's Bakery

8.1
184 9th Ave (btw 21st & 22nd St), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · Chelsea · 209 tips and reviews

@JaumePrimero@JaumePrimero: The carrot cake cupcake is lethal. I also like the banana cream pie :)

Jacqueline D.Jacqueline Dechongkit: Get the banana cream pie. Best in the city!

MizuMizu: The banana cream pie from Billy's is now possibly my favorite dessert in the entire world.

Petee's Pie Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

2. Petee's Pie Company

8.8
61 Delancey St (btwn Allen & Eldridge St), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Lower East Side · 112 tips and reviews

Amy C.Amy Chen: This cozy little pie shop is worthy of a dedicated visit. Grab a slice of delicious pie and a beverage of choice. I got the coconut cream pie, but will definitely be back to try the banana cream pie.

Jacob F.Jacob Forster: A tad pricey but worth every penny. Banana cream pie was phenomenal. Even the crust was delicious.

VictorVictor: Banana cream pie is so good

Little Pie Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

3. Little Pie Company

8.8
424 W 43rd St (btwn 9th & 10th Ave), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Hell's Kitchen · 101 tips and reviews

The Nouveau Classical ProjectThe Nouveau Classical Project: The banana cream pie here is absolutely delicious!

Cheryl H.Cheryl Huang: They have the best banana cream pie~

Leonardo U.Leonardo Ueda: Best Cheesecake MY Style and Hot Pot Chicken Pie!

Redeye Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

4. Redeye Grill

7.8
890 7th Ave (at W 56th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 81 tips and reviews

Julie L.Julie Letwat: Banana cream pie!!

Samantha B.Samantha Bailye: The banana cream pie is ridiculously amazing.

Karon W.Karon W: This place is overpriced but the banana cream pie is amazing. Doesn't really make up for paying a fortune for the entree.

Billy's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

5. Billy's Bakery

7.5
75 Franklin St (btwn Church & Broadway), New York, NY
Bakery · Tribeca · 60 tips and reviews

BollareBollare: Currently coveting a Banana Cream Pie! - Alle http://bit.ly/VQNuOk

Serious EatsSerious Eats: The banana cream pie, a fairly generous slice for $4.50, couples all the wonderful elements of banana pudding (minus the Nilla wafers) and tucks them into a extra flaky crust.

Yvonne D.Yvonne Diaz: Banana cake, banana pudding, snickerdoodles are yum

Joe Allen is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

6. Joe Allen

8.0
326 W 46th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 47 tips and reviews

Caroline S.Caroline Sajas: The best banana cream pie ever!!! :)

ᴡ S.ᴡ Soca: Burgers are a MUST. People watching, (especially with the late crowd after shows) is to die for.

Andrew A.Andrew Andrew: After a great show or a flop, get the meatloaf!

The Dutch is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

7. The Dutch

8.5
131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 458 tips and reviews

SerenaSerena: banana cream pie was mind-blowingly good. the wine list is also phenomenal.

Trae F.Trae F: The banana cream pie with chocolate peanut butter ice cream was the perfect ending to a great meal.

Christine L.Christine L: Burgers, fried chicken, waffles. Can't go wrong really.

Mary's Fish Camp is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

8. Mary's Fish Camp

8.5
64 Charles St (at W 4th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Village · 140 tips and reviews

Erica J.Erica Jaffe: Order this and you will not be disappointed: elotes (Mexican corn), beet salad, fish tacos, oysters, deviled eggs, hot fudge sundae and banana cream pie. Come hungry!!!

J A.J A: One of my favourite places in NY! Everything was amazing. The restaurant is really cute, and the staff were so helpful and friendly. We wished we could've ordered more so we could try every dish!

Andrew B.Andrew Berman: 2 words. fish tacos.

Bobwhite Counter is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

9. Bobwhite Counter

8.8
94 Avenue C (btwn E 6th & E 7th St), New York, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · Alphabet City · 293 tips and reviews

AskMenAskMen: Fried chicken dinners, pork chop and chow chow sandwiches, biscuits, collard greens, and banana cream pie -- all in a quaint 17-seater on Avenue C. Read more.

JasonJason: Some of the best food in NYC. I had the chicken sandwich, french fries, biscuit, and the mac and cheese. Can't wait to go back.

DensDens: Best fried chicken in the Alphabet City. I hear the porkchop is off the chain too.

Whole Foods Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

10. Whole Foods Market

8.6
10 Columbus Circle (at W 58th St), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Central Park · 351 tips and reviews

Kisha M.Kisha Mays: Just had the BEST banana cream pie at Whole Foods on my way to a major networking event with the CEO of General Electric and Meetup!

Maya T.Maya Taylor: Love their sushi and lemon pepper tofu. Addicted to the stuff!

Ben L.Ben Lebowitz: Mentally prepare yourself for the lines.

Magnolia Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

11. Magnolia Bakery

8.6
200 Columbus Ave (at W 69th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Lincoln Square · 280 tips and reviews

Daniel C.Daniel Cibener: Banana cream pie. Nuff said.

Sasha B.Sasha Baston: Still the best cupcakes in the city! Most low key relaxing location and smells like heaven!

The New York TimesThe New York Times: Skip the infamous cupcakes at this NYC standby and give the banana pudding a try.

Pasticceria Rocco is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

12. Pasticceria Rocco

8.3
243 Bleecker St (at Leroy St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · West Village · 167 tips and reviews

Sarah H.Sarah Hartley: Banana cream pie was seriously delish!

Mustafa Kemal Y.Mustafa Kemal Yıldızçelik: Lobster tail, napoleon and Cannoli s are delicious 😋

Carrie H.Carrie Hammer: Best cannoli in nY!!

French Roast is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

13. French Roast

7.4
2340 Broadway (at W 85th St), New York, NY
French Restaurant · Upper West Side · 124 tips and reviews

Sarah A.Sarah A: Just drank 3 bottles of wine and ate amazing banana cream pie. Eat gratinee!

Travis B.Travis Ballie: Best omelette here is the Salmon, Spinach, & Goat Cheese Omelette!

nymagnymag: Sponsored Tip: Order San Pellegrino or Acqua Panna water at this 24-hour bistro and a donation will be made to Share Our Strength! Also: try the broccoli gratin. Read more.

Gallaghers Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

14. Gallaghers Steakhouse

9.0
228 W 52nd St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Theater District · 108 tips and reviews

James C.James C: Amazing steak and the service was exceptional. Price is what a really good New York steakhouse is. However it is worth it. Need a reservation.

ThrillistThrillist: All of the steaks are pulled from a gorgeous meat locker where they age their beef in full view, including a killer New York sirloin that's got a great, Earthy-yet-juicy flavor. Read more.

Steve H.Steve Heiner: Good burger, good steak sandwich good Bloody Mary, good service, good times, good day bitches

Magnolia Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Banana Cream Pie in New York City.

15. Magnolia Bakery

8.8
1000 3rd Ave (Inside Bloomingdales), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper East Side · 138 tips and reviews

Zahra A.Zahra A: Banana pudding + ice box (peanut butter & chocolate squares).

BLOC ConciergeBLOC Concierge: Even though Magnolia is known for their cupcakes, you can't pass up the Banana Pudding! TO DIE FOR!!!

MaryMary: I don't even like bananas and I think the banana pudding is amazing. Red velvet is the real winner, though.