Donna Marie: That was the best ice cream sandwich I have ever experienced. Red velvet cookie with vanilla bean ice cream. YUMMM! I am a sticky mess right now because it melted all over me. Be sure to take extra
NearSay NYC: Always the moving target and a NYC sweet treat must, Coolhaus puts out some seriously awesome ice cream sandwiches. The cookies they use from Ovenly are especially great! Chocolate Chip is the best!
Lauren Schorr: The best ice cream sandwiches you will ever eat!
2. Melt Bakery
7.8
132 Orchard St (btwn Delancey & Rivington), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Lower East Side · 61 tips and reviews
SecondMarket: Get the Elvis and enjoy the amazing peanut butter cookies & banana ice cream sandwich.
Serious Eats: A source for great ice cream sandwiches with fun combinations like chili chocolate and curry coconut.
Harumi U: If you like chipwich, this is definitely the place to have your dessert. Today's special salted peanuts cookie ice cream sandwich was delicious. This is all they have though
3. Smush
7.9
44 Union Sq E (E 17th St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Garment District · 11 tips and reviews
Dan Fischer: His place is unreal! Customizable Ice Cream Sandwiches!! Try the Strawberries on Rye if you like Red Velvet! The French Toast Cookies will change your life!
Warren Wan: Caution: Despite the logo, the desserts do NOT look like adorable penguins with beanies. They just look like delicious, yummy ice cream sandwiches.
Tina Loveland: Everyone at Smush was so friendly and my sandwich was delicious. Definitely got rid of my case of the Mondays!
4. Schmackary's
8.8
362 W 45th St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · 287 tips and reviews
Harumi U: Here you remember that not all cookies are created equal. The more you buy, the cheaper per cookie becomes. If you feel like ice cream, try their ice cream sandwich. You can pick any 2 cookies.
Brittany Goodwyn: They give you a generous serving of ice cream with the ice cream sandwiches. The cookies were well worth the trek from the other side of town. A+++
Kevin: In love with their ice cream sandwich with the funfetti cookies
5. Lure Fishbar
9.0
142 Mercer St (at Prince St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · SoHo · 402 tips and reviews
HuffPost: A definite HuffPost favorite, make sure to order the yellowtail jalapeno roll and ask for the Bash Burger (it's delicious). For dessert, ice cream sandwiches. Read more.
Adam: Ice cream sandwiches are the best
Carissa Vaughn: Everything here is incredibly amazing!!!!! Except for the ice cream sandwiches....don't waste your time on those!!!!
Roshni Patel: Awesome cappuccinos AND ice cream sandwiches for breakfast! Red velvet with cream cheese ice cream is bomb.
Murat Yilmaz: Stumptown at its best! These guys really know how to serve their coffee. Their bagels and pastries are to die for. ... Ice cream sandwiches, affogatos and more!
Kimmie Ohh: They serve Stumptown for drip coffee & espresso. They also use Sweetleaf for drip coffee. They make their own cold brew! They serve Melt Bakery ice cream sandwiches & Blue Marble ice cream cups.
Murat Yilmaz: They serve Stumptown Coffee at its best! Many food options such as bagels, pastries and sandwiches -- anything I've tried was really tasty. And their ice cream sandwiches. ... mmmh!
Caroline Deng: Super cute, cozy cafe with a great dirty chai and ice cream sandwiches. Free wifi and it's good for working since it's in a quiet neighborhood. No outlets though!
Sean Carlson: Owner also runs the Jolly Goat in Hell's Kitchen (W. 47th, between 10th and 11th).
Joonhee Cho: what a great ice cream sandwich :)
Kimmie Ohh: In addition to their delectable ice cream flavors, they serve alcohol here! They have rosé boozy pops & summer spritz slushies. They also have beer & wine.
Lu H: Love that they’ll split a scoop for you, so you can try two flavors without having to buy an enormous amount of ice cream!! Not many places will do this.