1. Luke's Lobster
8.9
26 S William St (btwn Beaver St & Mill Ln), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Financial District · 143 tips and reviews
Jamie Etkind: Order the Taste of Maine: perfectly portioned for one person, you get to sample the shrimp roll, crab roll, and lobster roll...and be transported to Maine
Erica Virtue: Great lobster roll. Love that it's served with butter and seasoning, rather than in a mayonnaise-based sauce!
Barry Hott: Great lobster roll and super quick. Feeling adventurous? Go for the Taste of Maine. Sharing with a friend? Go for Noah's Ark
2. Luke's Lobster
8.8
242 E 81st St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Yorkville · 141 tips and reviews
Noelle: love the taste of Maine, lobster, shrimp and crab roll, all so fresh!
Sondra C: Lobster roll and bread bowl are amazing
Marcy Richardson: Try the Lobster Roll (Sandwich) - Seriously tasty. Very generous with the lobster for $15
3. Mary's Fish Camp
8.5
64 Charles St (at W 4th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · West Village · 140 tips and reviews
Jason Heller: Get the lobster roll - if you haven't figured that out yet! But also, fried oysters and clams (steamers) are awesome. Best homemade tartar sauce on earth!
Inge Van Hecke: I LOVE this place, nice vibe, fun crowd, great lobster roll, super fresh fish
Bobby Dacron: Lobster roll, bouillabaisse , mahi mahi , skate ribs ....actually the whole feckin menu
4. Burger & Lobster
8.5
39 W 19th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Flatiron District · 287 tips and reviews
Michael Dempsey: Everything is $20. Lobster roll is great, 1.5 pound lobster is best value.
Jenny Ung: I've only tried the lobster platter and the lobster roll, and the roll wins, hands down. Perfect buttery roll, not too much sauce, big chunks of lobster - it's perfection.
Nandi Anderson: Burger, Lobster, or Lobster Roll. And a salad and fries. The food comes out QUICK! And it's delicious!
7. Mermaid Oyster Bar
8.9
79 Macdougal St (btwn Bleecker & W Houston St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 269 tips and reviews
Stephen Merrill: Lobster roll and lobster fra diavolo simple and tasty. Great space for summer evenings, and terrific, friendly service.
Vincent Crossley: Awesome (and large) lobster roll, great staff!
Missy K: Try the lobster bisque, order any oyster on the menu and the mermaid lobster roll is amazing!
9. Grand Banks
9.0
Pier 25 (at N Moore St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Tribeca, New York, NY · 144 tips and reviews
Ryan Haigh: West Coast oysters, Old Bay chips, ceviche and lobster roll were all incredible.
Francine Li: The best lobster roll in the city
Oz Lubling: A great place for a date. The drinks are fantastic. The oysters and lobster roll are top notch. The view isn't bad either 👍🏻
10. Blue Ribbon Sushi
9.2
119 Sullivan St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY
Sushi Restaurant · SoHo · 294 tips and reviews
Hannah Yang: possibly my overall fave sushi spot in the city. i always get the honoo (spicy crab gunkan & spicy scallop roll - *INHALE*) n make whoever i'm w/get the sashimi deluxe platter. ;D
Danielle Snyder: Love their salad, spicy tuna roll, spicy crab (w/o shiso), & blue crab california. Ginger ice cream is heaven. Green tea is excellent. Best sushi in NYC hands down.
Sam Pezzullo: Even with a great selection to choose from I still stick to the spicy blue crab roll and house salad with watercress, avocado, carrots, and ginger dressing, can't beat it!
11. BONDST
8.6
6 Bond St (btwn Broadway & Lafayette St), New York, NY
Sushi Restaurant · NoHo · 221 tips and reviews
Rebecca Matt: Spicy Tuna Rolls are fantastic. Also the restaurant week menu right noe is phenom
Sam Pezzullo: Some of the best Asian food I've had in NYC. Try the big eye tuna tartare, red snapper ceviche tacos, sesame shrimp roll, and softshell crab roll. Accompany with the jalapeño margarita. Life changing.
Michael G.: You must order the tuna tarts. They are insanely good. Also recommend the scallop roll, the oysters (special), and the crispy rice with tuna.
NYC Brunch Babes: Lobster roll and fish tacos! Delicious!! Can't wait to go back!
Kelly: Great fish tacos and lobster rolls, and nice rosé sangria. Cruise is timed just right so you don't feel trapped at sea. Def recommend!
ZenFoodster: No wait on wkday. Svc, drinks, & food were good. Lobster rolls, Medium shrimp & Jonah crab claws are fresh & must-try's! Oysters-Malpeque & Wellfleet-only ok. Free Hudson River 1/3-loop boat ride.
14. Pier I Cafe
8.7
W 70th St (at Riverside Blvd), New York, NY
Café · Lincoln Square · 179 tips and reviews
Jocelyn Kolkin: Get the lobster roll, it's a great roll and comes with fries!
Sativa Verte: Dog friendly place to stop for a bite; don't forget to get ur pooch a hot dog! Also u eat lobster roll meal yum yum!
Toby Crabtree: lobster roll, sangria, and a view of the hudson