Tea & Sympathy is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

1. Tea & Sympathy

7.7
108 Greenwich Ave (btwn 12th & 13th St), New York, NY
Tea Room · West Village · 136 tips and reviews

Eugene Y.Eugene Yim: The toffee pudding w/ custard is AMAZING!

Kym P.Kym P.: Get the chicken salad finger sandwich, sticky toffee pudding, or seville orange iced tea. All lovely.

Stella W.Stella Wiki: Best sticky toffee pudding!!!

Jones Wood Foundry is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

2. Jones Wood Foundry

8.3
401 E 76th St (btwn York & 1st Ave.), New York, NY
English Restaurant · Upper East Side · 156 tips and reviews

Maribel L.Maribel Lara: Spotted egg, salted cod & mash, pork pie, haddock & chips, beef & kidney pie, sticky toffee pudding and the list goes on

Neilson A.Neilson Abeel: On the expensive side but completely worth it if you love British food and beer. On my last visit I had Fullers London Porter, a great pub curry and sticky toffee pudding. Very friendly service too.

sue q.sue q: Cozy neighborhood British gastropub. Recommend: scotch egg, fish and chips with mushy peas, pot pies and sticky toffee pudding. Great beer selection.

Crown Shy is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

3. Crown Shy

9.3
70 Pine St, New York, NY
Restaurant · Financial District · 54 tips and reviews

Jaclyn R.Jaclyn R: All around amazing food and service. 1789 cocktail and toffee cake CANT be missed. Recommend sharing as much as possible

Susan L.Susan Lai: Gruyère fritters, bread & short ribs were amazing. Short ribs were expensive for what you got though. Delicious toffee pudding!

Dane B.Dane B: Everything was excellent, but there are a few must-orders: gruyere fritters, roasted short rib (could've fooled me that it was an A5 wagyu steak), & sticky toffee pudding (simply spectacular).

Quality Meats is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

4. Quality Meats

9.0
57 W 58th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Midtown East · 317 tips and reviews

Hnnssy25Hnnssy25: Try the Sticky toffee cake with fig ice cream

Hazel D.Hazel Doyle: Never mind the tender juicy steaks and the excellent service you need to go for the sticky toffee pudding with vanilla ice-cream.

Omar E.Omar Elddin: Creamed Spinach, cheese gnocchi, sticky toffee, burnt marshmallow ice-cream are all to die for.

Blue Smoke is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

5. Blue Smoke

7.7
255 Vesey St (btwn West & North End Ave), New York, NY
BBQ Joint · Battery Park City · 120 tips and reviews

Hilary W.Hilary Walker: Don't forget to order the fry bread with a side of toffee sauce!!

Lisa Q.Lisa Quispe: Try the fried bread side dish with the chipotle butter, its amazing. Secret: ask for the Toffee sauce as well...best of savory and sweet!

Giao R.Giao R.: super kid-friendly. They bring out a piggie cookie to decorate then bake it! We love the fry bread (ESP the toffee sauce!) and the KC ribs were awesome! Also get the creamed spinach & Mac n cheese

Hawksmoor NYC is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

6. Hawksmoor NYC

8.4
109 East 22nd Street (Park Avenue), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Gramercy Park · 11 tips and reviews

Amy G.Amy Griffin: OMG! What's not good?? The steak was perfectly cooked. sticky toffee pudding and lemon bomb were both worth indulging in. One of the best meals ever, great atmosphere and service. Jerry was wonderful!

AditAdit: Sticky toffee pudding!

Mollie K.Mollie Kaufman: gorgeous atmosphere! loved the charcoal roasted scallops, reuben nuggets, filet, and the lemon dessert was so unique and delicious. can’t wait to return

Orwasher's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

7. Orwasher's Bakery

8.8
308 E 78th St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper East Side · 87 tips and reviews

Julie N.Julie N: Salted toffee oatmeal cookie! Amazing!

Theresa G.Theresa Geiger: Salted Toffee Oatmeal Cookies are amazing.

Laura N.Laura Niz: Excellent bread, scones and pain au chocolate. Even their coffee is excellent and not a lot of bakeries do coffee well. Five stars!

The Smith is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

8. The Smith

8.8
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 364 tips and reviews

Hunter M.Hunter Mandel: Fried green beans, Burrata, all the steaks are legit, specials are always great, sticky toffee pudding must have

Wejdan ✨Wejdan ✨: When in the smith always leave room for sticky toffee pudding, always!

Amy M.Amy Mixa: The prime burger and the toffee bread pudding are amazing!

Freemans is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

9. Freemans

8.9
1 Freeman Aly (at Rivington St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Lower East Side · 569 tips and reviews

Jay P.Jay Putera: Stout Sticky Toffee Cake with Whipped Cream from Freeman's, Priceless

Rosanna C.Rosanna Casper: Filet over the lamb, trout is amazing and for dessert the toffee is to die for

Mimi W.Mimi W: Get the pork loin and toffee cake. Life changing.

Melt Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

10. Melt Bakery

7.8
132 Orchard St (btwn Delancey & Rivington), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Lower East Side · 61 tips and reviews

Halstead PropertyHalstead Property: You’ll say anything but ‘ba humbug’ to the Fezziwig - 2 of their famous sticky toffee “meltcakes” wrapped around hot buttered rum ice cream, so decadent and rich even Scrooge would be pleased.

S. F.S. Fan: There are usually 8 classic and 4 seasonal flavors at a time. Get the new flavor #FEZZIWIG made of Sticky Toffee Meltcakes & Butter Rum Ice Cream. So good!

NetsirkNetsirk: If you love red velvet, they sell a perfectly made red velvet sandwich here! The rum chocolate is delicious as well. Small place to pick up an afternoon dessert downtown.

Eclair Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

11. Eclair Bakery

8.7
305 E 53rd St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Sutton Place · 46 tips and reviews

Michael G.Michael Garod: The eclairs are 90% creme just like they should be! The choco toffee tart crust is great: gooey, crunchy and chocolatey.

SusumuSusumu: A little bakery in Sutton Place. They have many unique éclairs. I had a Black Currant éclair. It's a perfect place to indulge yourself in great desserts.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: A small bakery with some excellent pastries. Don't miss the fresh croissants.

The Shakespeare is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

12. The Shakespeare

7.4
24 E 39th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave), New York, NY
Gastropub · Murray Hill · 71 tips and reviews

JYOTI S.JYOTI SINGH: Sticky toffee pudding was amazing. Soft, warm, and just the right way to end a meal here!

Carmen N.Carmen N: Enjoyed the focaccia and the salmon burger. Nice staff too. Oh, and toffee pudding!

Stuart H.Stuart Holt: Burger is top class. Scotch eggs are equally as delicious. Cask ales are a must try

Max Brenner is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

13. Max Brenner

8.6
841 Broadway (btwn E 13th & E 14th St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Greenwich Village · 676 tips and reviews

Dewan T.Dewan Tarek: Ask for a table by the display cases to really enjoy the ambience here. Also, try the hazelnut cream banana toffee crepe

Halstead PropertyHalstead Property: Can you scream chocolate? The classic European chocolate fondue comes with velvety milk and dark chocolate to go with amazing fresh fruit, airy sponge cake, chunky cookies, and sugary toffee sauce.

ItaliThai D.ItaliThai Dee: The fondue is out of this world! You really can’t go wrong with anything on their dessert menu!

West Bank Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

14. West Bank Cafe

7.7
407 W 42nd St (at 9th Ave.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 36 tips and reviews

Anne S.Anne Saulovich: Wow! You must try the Butterscotch Toffee Parfait - but I recommend you split it!!

Brent W.Brent Watkins: Heirloom Tomato Tartare ~ scrumptious!

Peter H.Peter Hurley: Truffle Mac n cheese is totally addictive!

Corkbuzz is one of The 15 Best Places for Toffee in New York City.

15. Corkbuzz

8.6
13 E 13th St (btwn 5th Ave & University Pl), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Greenwich Village · 130 tips and reviews

Mary Elise ChavezMary Elise Chavez: Great escape in Union Sq; A+ wine selection, burrata & NY Strip are tastebud heaven. Toffee chocolate cake is the perfect finish. Kind staff, great service. Good for large groups, farm tables in back

Christine T.Christine Tabone: duck and such a cool wine list - stunning!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: One of our favorite wine bars in New York, with an ever-changing dinner menu, wine classes, and an event space.