2. Puttanesca Trattoria
8.6
1207 Avenida Fernandez Juncos, San Juan, San Juan
Italian Restaurant · 92 tips and reviews
Miguel Ayala: Best New York Style Pizza in PR!
Leila: An order of cheese sticks is HUGE and very tasty. Try the BBQ chicken pizza!! The Riccota gives it a nice touch! Total NYC lovers paradaise. Our new favorite place
Sxnny N. Cervera: Everyone was right! Exceptional pizza, just like NY! Great service, ask for Peter!
3. Melanzana
8.9
650 Ave Ponce De Leon (Ave. Mirarmar), San Juan, San Juan
Italian Restaurant · San Juan · 48 tips and reviews
Bianca Ruiz Granado: Amazing food! Rich aromatic flavors, try the spice crusted tuna filet or the osobuco risotto. The pizza's are also amazing, best tomato sauce I've had in a while.
Carlos Rodriguez-Diaz: Good food. Try the pizzas and the chocolate and banana bread pudding.
Lisa R: Everything is good here! The saffron risotto, the gnocchi, the veal, napolitana pizza style, the very perfectly stocked bar... This place is amazing and just keeps getting better!
Waleska Díaz-Santiago: The Best Pizza around ask for the Miss Italia...great service and ambiance...Cool place!
Yamilette Arana: Great pizza... Try the one with ricotta
Pierina Rodriguez: For starters try the fritatta, is filled with pasta, very good! Great pizza, try Margherita pizza or the prosciutto. You have to try goat cheese cheesecake with dulce de leche. We have to come back 😋
11. Faccio Pizza
8.5
Tropical 47 Ave. Esmeralda Urb. Muñoz Rivera, Guaynabo, Guaynabo Municipio
Italian Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews
María De los López: Order the carbonara pizza!
Sixto Medina: I always get my pizza with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and sausage!!! With a beer of course.
Lisa R: The whole wheat thin crust is great.
12. Juan Pan Pizza
8.2
1117 Ave. Piñero, Puerto Nuevo, San Juan
Argentinian Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews
Dayna: The service it's good and so it's the pizza and the crepe really good too
Pedro Gelabert: Great artisan pizza!
Lisa R: The place has uses every color in the spectrum for its decor. In spite of this the Pizza Siciliana (thin crust, "white sauce") and the sangria with an add shot of vodka are really, really good.
14. Serafina
7.7
1077 Ashford Avenue (At La Concha Hotel), San Juan, San Juan
Italian Restaurant · Condado · 44 tips and reviews
Foodiespr: Good buttery house #Sauvignonblanc for their #seafood #pastas, nice thin crust #pizzas and excellent #desserts, Tempranillo red #wine beautiful
Foodiespr: Pizza's are great here with San Juan Mayor
Loni French: Pizzas made onsite in brick oven are wonderful! 🍕
15. Bistro Pizza
8.5
ija del Caribe 500, Edificio El Centro 1, Hato Rey, San Juan, San Juan
Pizzeria · 14 tips and reviews
Jahdai Cintron: Great pizza. Plates are in the back for the buffet. Salad, soup, rice, meat, pasta and pizza make a yummy buffet.
Kenly H.: Amazing pizza, fresh & good quality ingredients, fair prices and an awesome Strawberry Dessert Pizza.
M Ignacio: Best cantimpalo pizza ever!