A really good New York experience (diner style)
Skip the traditional burgers... the veggie burger w/ 5N sauce and the buffalo chicken sandwich are amazing!
Not again! The only accepted was the bread everything else did not have a taste! At least my stomach was not hurt
Very good burger, and the waiters are very dedicated. A must go.
Overpriced. Avoid at all ¢o$ts
Heavy for dinner, very bad fries, normal usual burger nothing special
Decent simple burger.
Five Napkin burger is the best. Get a side of the rosemary aioli for the fries!
Had a blue cheese burger and it was delicious... :-)
Hamburger is great...the real American experience...good Service...just how incredible is the tip system in USA...cocktails not the best...very small but tasty!!!
The original is amazing. Huge-- I ate it without the bun. Perfectly cooked at med rare.
Good burger and lager beer.
The lamb kofta burger is great with one of the ales but they don't offer the tuscan fries anymore.
Love the classic 5 Napkin Burger and my boyfriend says it's the best veggie burger he's ever had!!
Annoying name, but great food
Excellent burgers. The original is mouth watering and the Bacon Burger is nicely balanced.
Sweet potato fries
Deviled eggs and great bartenders !! Super friendly !!
This time around the service and food were simply bad. The table was not properly set, missing salt, pepper, ketchup, silverware, etc. Have had a better experience at their 45th location.
Great food, great atmosphere! I tried their chicken salad which was pretty good.
Avocado ranch burger tastes really good although bit pricey for a burger
Vegetarians are welcome, too. Order the Veggie, an original recipe made with their 5N sauce.
Appropriately named, you will go through many, many napkins trying to eat these juicy burgers. Order the Original or Bacon Cheddar. Consistently one of the better burgers in NYC.
Burgers are always amazing as well as the shakes. Outstanding veggie burger! For sushi, get the California Rainbow Roll. Always get a side of sweet potato fries.
DO NOT under any circumstances order the potato skins. Utter rip off for 6 minuscule bites at $7.75. WHAAAT????
Sit at the bar
Solid burger joint. Happy hour every night from 10pm to closing at the bar.
The burgers are just great, the drafted american beer are very interesting (for a czech beer lover). The cheese cake is warmly recommended
Salted caramel shake 👍
Service was terrible tonight. Its usually good but multiple tables with the same waitress had trouble waiving her down for things like steak sauce and water. We bonded over being ignored.
Great mahi sandwich!
Happy hour after 10 pm at the bar. $2 sliders and $4 draft.
cheeseburger + sweet potato french fries = very delicious
Get there just by 12 and you'll catch a great table!! Oh!! And get the breakfast burger!!!
Amazing homemade veggie burger, the 5N sauce is delicious!
Bar service is horrible
Eat at the bar if you want the best service!!!
Hamburgers were better last year:(
All new faces, some change for the good (delivery, growlers) some for the bad (service).
The pork taquitos are a great way to start off!
Not the best burger in NY but pretty good. Get the avocado ranch or 5 napkin burger- skip the onion rings. Always go with fries.
Not to be confused with Five Guys, this has great beer and better burgers at a bigger price. Well worth it!
Get the biggest: the Original 5 Napkin Burger - 10 oz. fresh ground beef, gruyere cheese, caramelized onions & rosemary aioli on a soft white roll. Don't forget to add bacon. Medium rare as always!
Great burger, inside out is my FAVORITE <3 drinks r good too!
My Absolute Fave Summer Winter Spring and Fall the Mahi Tacos Ruby Red Martini Is the Penwah Staple!
Cramped and burgers have very little taste.
Best veggie burger ever ❤ but not the best bloody mary.
Mushroom Blue Cheese Burger w/ sweet potato fries are my go to. Just tried the salted caramel shake....YUM!