5 O'Clock Club

American Restaurant$$$$
  • Ranked #2 for American restaurants in Pewaukee
  • Karen B.
    "Great fish fry and the best French fries and service!"(5 Tips)
    Linn E.
    "chicken dinner on the Tuesday/Thursday"(3 Tips)
20 Tips and reviews
  • fish fry
  • french fries
  • lively
  • great value
  • oysters
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Linn E.
    Linn ElliottSeptember 24, 2017
    Friendly, reasonable "old school" supper club. We had the chicken dinner on the Tuesday/Thursday special and it was great - moist, tender meat in a crispy, flavorful coating.
  • Michael M.
    Michael MensingaSeptember 1, 2010
    Try the fishfry, it's fantastic! They don't take reservations and there is often a wait so plan to have a drink or three at the bar first. It's well worth it!
  • Bob P.
    Bob POctober 12, 2013
    Went on a Friday at about 5:45 pm had about an hour and a half wait. But the fish fry was excellent. Will return.
  • Nichol D.
    Nichol D.May 18, 2013
    The calamari is delicious. And if you get the oysters in season, very good.
  • Brandon J.
    Brandon JanasikAugust 15, 2013
    Great food, great environment, great value. Definitely going again!
  • Cynthia B.
    Cynthia BrunoMarch 24, 2014
    Good home cookin style. The specials are the best. Chicken meh...
  • Karen B.
    Karen B.February 16, 2016
    Great fish fry and the best French fries and service!
  • Krista-Lee
    Krista-LeeMay 30, 2014
    Thursday fish fry - for those weeks when Friday just doesn't work out.
  • Taylor B.
    Taylor BaumgartJune 24, 2016
    Great fried mushrooms! Bloodies aren't bad either!!
  • Brian B.
    Brian BezansonOctober 23, 2011
    I'm a little underwhelmed. The French Onion soup was warm, not hot and lacking flavor. My rare to medium rare steak was medium to well and lacking flavor. Saved by onions and mushrooms. Disappointed.
  • Stacey C.
    Stacey Clay-HammelNovember 9, 2012
    Salmon is delicious and exceptional presentation!
  • Ashley P.
    Ashley PetryDecember 28, 2012
    The wait says it all. This is a local favorite.
  • Cynthia B.
    Cynthia BrunoFebruary 7, 2014
    Excellent food and wonderful atmoshete
  • Nick W.
    Nick WierzbaJune 28, 2016
    The chicken is amazing
  • Heidi
    HeidiMay 4, 2013
    Beat bloody Mary's!
  • Alyssa D.
    Alyssa DraegerMarch 12, 2011
    The fish fry was awful. Rye bread was tasteless, the slaw and tartar sauce was already on the table, no potato pancakes.. in a word? Gross. I've had better fish frys at dive bars.
  • Jason T.
    Jason TJune 28, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Great atmosphere!
  • Scotty S.
    Scotty SniadachJuly 20, 2013
    Awesome fish fry
  • Colin P.
    Colin PetersMay 31, 2012
    Little cluck...nuff said
  • Parker C.
    Parker ChaseMarch 24, 2012
    This place sucks.
36 Photos