Alchemy - Edgartown

American Restaurant and Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Edgartown
Save
Share
8.0/10
58
ratings
  • Ranked #3 for American restaurants in Edgartown
  • Amaya C.
    "back bar upstairs is great if you don't have a res."(6 Tips)
    Caitlin C.
    "Risotto balls from the bar menu are delicious!"(6 Tips)
    Eric F.
    "Try an expresso martini in the upstairs back bar"(3 Tips)
    Roxanne T.
    "Best drink EVER: key lime pie martini"(3 Tips)
27 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • risotto balls
  • upstairs
  • martinis
  • seafood
  • back bar
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Tatyana S.
    Tatyana SharoubimJuly 4, 2013
    Beef tartare and zucchini starters are a for sure. The scallops or tuna entree are incredible. strawberry shortcake was a perfect end to a great meal. Cocktails: pims cup or key lime martini
  • Eben E.
    Eben EliasJuly 3, 2015
    Everything since Craig Decker was replaced with a classically trained chef who has worked at French Laundry among other culinary epicenters. I feel his food is far better than Christian's at Atria.
  • Lisa C.
    Lisa CourtemancheSeptember 1, 2014
    Wild mushroom risotto balls, asparagus & Jonah crab salad, Pimms!. Pan seared tuna, and the most amazing scallops! Great start as well!
  • Travel + Leisure
    Travel + LeisureJune 11, 2013
    At this bi-level restaurant and bar, the steak frites and fried risotto balls don’t distract from the tropical drinks such as tangy mojitos and gin-and-juices.
  • WhatsUpMartha
    WhatsUpMarthaDecember 22, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    Upstairs - back bar - ask for Jay is he's there - the man is going to change your life with service, jokes and well, bring you the potent libations you need. Extra plus is the fireplace in back!
  • Amaya C.
    Amaya C.July 16, 2011
    back bar upstairs is great if you don't have a res. also includes some delish bar menu items like the risotto balls and steamers! louder ambiance but great for a casual dinner
  • Wendy P.
    Wendy Petrik-CarrollOctober 3, 2013
    Truffle risotto balls are a must, short rib with egg also a great app. Great Sancerre : )
  • Jeffrey G.
    Jeffrey GlueckAugust 13, 2014
    Ginger gimlet and the truffled fries with duck confit
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin CostelloMay 30, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Rosemary breaded swordfish was amazing! Also try the clam/sausage appetizer.
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaSeptember 10, 2014
    One word: amazing. Best in Martha's and possibly many other surrounding towns
  • Chris M.
    Chris MorganAugust 23, 2013
    Burger is decent and pork tacos are great. Disagree on risotto balls-thought they were pedestrian and bland.
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin CostelloAugust 25, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Risotto balls from the bar menu are delicious!
  • HungryNative
    HungryNativeJanuary 7, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    In the winter they have an AMAZING pork belly appetizer!!
  • Bill S.
    Bill SchillhammerAugust 19, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the Koi Pond with Don Julio Blanco Tequila.
  • Steve S.
    Steve SebestyenJune 17, 2010
    So they don't warm their bread. Big no-no! Ask to have it warmed; although, you shouldn't have to ask.
  • Mark G.
    Mark GraciaAugust 25, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Risotto balls are delicious
  • Steve S.
    Steve SebestyenJune 17, 2010
    If you've never had mashed potatoes in your salad now's your chance so don't pass it up. Strange but well worth it.
  • Roxanne T.
    Roxanne TehranianAugust 31, 2013
    Best drink EVER: key lime pie martini
  • Orchid L.
    Orchid LiuJune 6, 2010
    It tends to get loud upstairs, so if you need something quiet, sit downstairs
  • Robert
    RobertJune 20, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    Nice vests.
    Upvoted Feb 23
  • Carroll & Vincent R.
    Carroll & Vincent Real EstateJanuary 26, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    Reliable good food here
  • Marnely R.
    Marnely Rodriguez-MurrayMarch 22, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Great places for drinks!
  • Robert
    RobertJuly 25, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    Best cheeseburger. Ever.
  • Steve S.
    Steve SebestyenJune 17, 2010
    Risotto was great, try it and tell them Foursquare sent you.
  • Toby M.
    Toby MetcalfJanuary 22, 2010
    Ask for an upstairs booth when booking dinner. Read more
  • Robin B.
    Robin BreenSeptember 3, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Upstairs bar with Ezra 
  • Eric F.
    Eric FriedmanSeptember 6, 2009
    Try an expresso martini in the upstairs back bar
63 Photos

Related Searches

  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown
  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown photos
  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown location
  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown address
  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown
  • alchemy edgartown
  • alchemy edgartown edgartown
  • alchemy - edgartown edgartown
  • alchmey edgartown

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF