Amigos Tortilla Bar Mexican Restaurant

Amigos Tortilla Bar Mexican Restaurant

Mexican Restaurant, Taco Place, and Vegetarian / Vegan Restaurant$$$$
Key West
Save
Share
8.1/10
184
ratings
  • Kelsey
    "Square tacos are amazing!"(4 Tips)
    Tina v.
    "Square tortillas are adorable and beyond delicious."(2 Tips)
    Kristin C.
    "They also have amazing hot sauce rack also."(2 Tips)
    Megan C.
    "amazing burritos & great for people watching!"(10 Tips)
74 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • tacos
  • burritos
  • hot sauce rack
  • people watching
  • nachos
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • paul m.
    paul mentaMarch 13, 2011
    Order the tacos or burritos and try one of our 36 hot sauces , we cook naturally so it gives you the options to finish the taste you like with no preservatives.....Our homemade ghost pepper sauce it t
  • Celia P.
    Really tasty fajitas and welcoming staff! Don't forget to draw your feedback before you leave... ;)
  • Suddenly S.
    Suddenly SophiaSeptember 2, 2012
    You BETTER get the BIG burrito with chicken!! Make sure you also order a side of chips and guac! DON'T forget to sprinkle the Key Lime hot sauce on EVERYTHING! :]
  • Kelly D.
    Kelly DolanAugust 8, 2011
    This has very friendly staff, delicious food and the setup overlooking the street is entertaining. Hands down wins over Old Town Mexican Cafe on Duval. Thumbs up Amigos.
  • Mark H.
    Mark HendrixAugust 22, 2015
    This place surprised us all and was sooo good! We all commented on the various meats we had I. Our dishes...so tender and savory!
  • Michal D.
    Michal DudwalApril 30, 2013
    nachos with cheese and squared tacos with chicken redefined my taste on mexican food. this was delicious! and fresh cillantro - perfect! thank you guys
  • Norm T.
    Norm ThomasSeptember 7, 2012
    It is very hard to find really good mexican food. Look no further; this is THE place. But, on the other hand, if you like very hot, burning sauce, bring your own or go to Peppers of Key West.
  • Vanessa H.
    Vanessa H.January 9, 2011
    The fish tacos with Mango-Chili sauce are amazing,as are the Lobster Tacos. Freshly made tortillas on site and great people watching. Cheap too!
  • Jordan G.
    Jordan GrosecloseNovember 20, 2014
    Was pretty pleased with the chorizo potatoes burrito bowl. Say that five times fast! They also have a gluten-free friendly menu.
  • Scott D.
    Scott DubhGhaillAugust 8, 2012
    Ask for Andrea and get the Chicken or Local Fish Burrito...You'll have the Best Service and Best Food! This place is AWESOME!
  • Kate P.
    Kate PersonMay 19, 2011
    This place used to be the iguana cafe.. My fav place on the island! Now a mexican restaurant.. Food is fantastic and does my old buddy well! Fabulous food!!!
  • Beth v.
    Beth von BehrenMay 6, 2013
    Loved my taco salad, but wished I had ordered the Mexican version of Coca Cola, rather than a margarita, which was good but nothing special. Suggest you sit at counter, facing out, and people watch.
  • John J.
    John JaworskiMay 9, 2011
    Make sure you get a seat at the street side bar.. Klerk place for people watching.... And there is always a lot to watch in Key West!
  • Jon D.
    Jon DaMove'January 4, 2012
    Gr8 tacos, over a dozen hot sauces, beer and sidewalk bar seats 4 ppl watching. I like this place and will b back....
  • Joe W.
    Joe WinnNovember 8, 2014
    Fresh square tortillas! A table full of their own hot sauces! Tasty fillings with labeled vegetarian/vegan items.
  • Maggie M.
    Maggie MorehouseMay 19, 2012
    Def the best Mexican on the island!! If you like the hot sauces stop at Peppers of Key West!!! For free hot sauce tastings!!
  • George
    GeorgeAugust 24, 2011
    Nice place but wasnt keen on fajitas, not amigos fault just used to ones at home. Worth a try if you like traditional fajitas and stuff :)
  • Sarp E.
    Sarp ErkayaJanuary 5
    Great Mexican spot (which is a rare find in KW) with friendly service and delicious tacos. 🇲🇽
  • Kyo V.
    Kyo VermeulenFebruary 2, 2011
    Awesome tunes, great natural food and really cool owners. They also own Cuban coffee queen, another must.
  • Haley F.
    Haley FeldhausNovember 16, 2011
    The carnitas taco plate was delicious! The nachos were awesome. Don't waste four bucks on the funnel cake fries.
    Upvoted Jul 7
  • Kristin C.
    Kristin ClarkJune 22, 2012
    The BEST corn tortillas (seriously ever)! They also have amazing hot sauce rack also. Incredible!
  • Anne M.
    Anne MajlandFebruary 6, 2015
    They have really good coffee, their latte is wonderfull.. ☕️
  • Marc C.
    Marc CDecember 29, 2014
    Get the Carnitas taco. Pork is seasoned with cinnamon and is one of the best things I've had
    Upvoted Jul 7
  • Danny S.
    Danny SenterDecember 15, 2012
    Not a fan of the Mexican coca cola. Their square tacos (chicken especially) are awesome, I'd highly recommend them.
  • Tina v.
    Tina von KAugust 20, 2014
    Square tortillas are adorable and beyond delicious. Chicken is seasoned superbly.
  • Dion B.
    Dion BarelaJune 17, 2015
    Try both key lime pies: Kermit's and Key West Key Lime Pie Company. My favorite? #kermits
  • Alexia H.
    Alexia HellerMarch 5, 2012
    Carne asada tacos taste like a pot roast taco, didn't like them. Kitchen sink nachos are the bomb!
    Upvoted Jul 7
  • Tom R.
    Tom RebikApril 29, 2011
    This place has some of the best chicken any thing. Our nachos and quesadilla were great
  • Vincent
    VincentJune 30, 2012
    Good music, nice location, the nachos with guacamole and the tacos are amazing!
  • paul m.
    paul mentaSeptember 3, 2011
    Use the hot sauce rack- mild medium or hotGet homemade taco and salsa
  • Turner P.
    Turner P.May 23, 2014
    Great spot to taste TWO local key lime pie slices in one order
  • Elisa R.
    Elisa ReyesSeptember 29, 2013
    DO NOT get a margarita, so bad! Go to Sloppy Joe for the Sloppy Rita, muuuuuuch better quality. But the amigos quesadilla is pretty good (I added shrimp to mine)
  • Kelsey
    KelseyJuly 23, 2013
    Square tacos are amazing! Sit outside for awesome people watching!
  • Shrek
    ShrekJanuary 20, 2014
    Best mexi-food in Key West! The fish tacos are fab!
  • Donna C.
    Good tacos and margaritas...Hit the mark when I was craving Mexican food!
  • Ben B.
    Ben BrownbackJune 16, 2014
    Fish tacos are good . . . portions aren't too large, but food is good and staff is very friendly.
  • Julio C.
    Julio CarbonellSeptember 18, 2011
    Food is very good, although I don't want to imagine being served on a busy day. Food took forever !!!
  • Megan C.
    Megan ConleyNovember 19, 2013
    amazing burritos & great for people watching!
  • Sean B.
    Sean BallesterosMay 12, 2011
    Had the fish tacos. Definitely not impressed. Tortillas may be home made but homemade doesn't exactly equal good.
  • Kate P.
    Kate PersonFebruary 13, 2011
    Gotta check this place out! Best Mexican food I've had maybe ever. Seriously!
  • Karen R.
    Karen RiveraSeptember 28, 2012
    The only good thing about this place is the bar table by th front!!bad service, not so great food, waitress w black hair not so nice and didnt smile, got wrong order...brought food very late!!nogood!
  • Maria J.
    Maria JJuly 28, 2013
    Kid friendly. Drink the Mexican Coca-cola. Square tacos are a must.
  • Maya T.
    Maya TimbsOctober 15, 2014
    Burritos . The hot salsa is the best
  • Rachel
    RachelJuly 3, 2011
    Tortillas are delicious. Chicken was good, fish wasn't all that.
  • FishBusterz R.
    Amigos Tortilla Bar offers delicious Tacos!!!!
  • Jimmy H.
    Jimmy HeffernanNovember 10, 2014
    Get the corn on the cob street style.
  • Michael J.
    Michael JurweiczSeptember 10, 2011
    Burritos are gigantic. Very good.
  • Juan M.
    Juan MenesesJanuary 30, 2013
    Get ready to get your hands dirty in a good way. A delicious burrito!
  • Jillian F.
    Jillian FinkApril 18
    Best tacos in Key West!!
  • Daya
    DayaMarch 24, 2012
    Gluten free beer and gluten free tacos!!!
265 Photos

Related Searches

  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west
  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west photos
  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west location
  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west address
  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west
  • amigos key west
  • amigos tortilla bar key west
  • amigos tortilla bar mexican restaurant key west

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF