Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Pizza Place and American Restaurant$$$$
Woodbury
Save
Share
8.9/10
88
ratings
  • Eric
    "Get a Blue Moon with the meatball and ricotta pizza."(2 Tips)
    lauren
    "Blue moon on tap!"(2 Tips)
    Valerie D.
    "Don't forget to check in here for free sample of their unique wings"(10 Tips)
    Jenn S.
    "Great Ricotta with Meatball pizza BUT the crusts"(2 Tips)
41 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • chicken wings
  • blue moon
  • big screen TVs
  • great value
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Anna O.
    Anna Osias StellmanOctober 1, 2014
    My first time eating here and my family & I had lunch. I had the personal pepperoni pizza and it was delicious!! I was worried about the pizza being thin, but it was perfect.
  • Jason M.
    Jason MolinetJanuary 11, 2012
    The wings are a must. And they come to the table fast, which is almost as impressive as the big char flavor with every bite. No messy sauces make these wings stand out.
  • NY Islanders
    NY IslandersOctober 20, 2011
    Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza always proves to be a great venue for our #IslesMeetup viewing parties. Helpful staff, big screen TVs and fantastic food.
  • Katrina P.
    Katrina PoulosDecember 31, 2012
    Great pizza. Slow service and not the friendliest. Also they might want to invest in a soda machine, the bottles aren't cutting it. I'm thinking take out would be the best option here.
  • Natalie T.
    Natalie TheresaJanuary 23, 2013
    Salads rock, meatballs are unbelievable, cauliflower pizza is a favorite of mine! Italian coal fired wings are epic!
  • NY Islanders
    NY IslandersJanuary 7, 2013
    If you haven't tried the Cauliflower Pizza, you haven't lived. Matt Moulson loves it, so will you!
  • Ethan W.
    Ethan WieselthierAugust 25, 2013
    If you unlock the special offer for a wings sample make sure you show the waiter before you order cause if you show after you already order wings they won't give you the sample.
  • Andy C.
    Andy ChapmanDecember 21, 2016
    One of the best pizza places around. Drive up service for takeout is 💯
  • Valerie D.
    Valerie DJanuary 19, 2013
    Don't forget to check in here for free sample of their unique wings
  • Hector
    HectorFebruary 3, 2016
    Thin, crispy delicious pizza. Sit at the bar.
  • Explore L.
    Explore Long IslandFebruary 20, 2013
    Our readers voted Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza into the "Readers' Pizza Hall of Fame" for Long Island! Read more
  • Meredith A.
    Meredith AAugust 9, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    This is the same Anthony's from Florida, also owner of Runway 84. Amazing food! Anthony is a LI native, welcome back!
  • lauren
    laurenSeptember 1, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Blue moon on tap! But I prefer their martinis. Delish :). Great addition to Syosset.
  • Meredith A.
    Meredith AAugust 9, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    If it's the same recipe as the one in Ft Lauderdale, you MUST try the wings!
  • Jenn S.
    Jenn SantiagoFebruary 5, 2016
    Great Ricotta with Meatball pizza BUT the crusts are not always edible.
  • Meredith A.
    Meredith ASeptember 17, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    From FL to NY, Anthony (a NY naive) is now moving into the NJ/Delaware area...watch out mom & pop pizza places!
  • Eric
    EricAugust 9, 2011
    Get a Blue Moon with the meatball and ricotta pizza. Both are great!
  • Dylan F.
    Dylan FarellaSeptember 24, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Great night: Meatball and ricotta pie, wings, wine.
  • Laurent P.
    Laurent PasqualiJune 5, 2013
    Very Nice food here ! Pizza are awsome.
  • Meredith A.
    Meredith AJanuary 14, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Tip: The mayor seems to be here during closed hours...better beef up that security Anthony! :)
  • Rich B.
    Rich BrazzanoSeptember 3, 2011
    BEST NEW PIZZA IN WOODBURY, THERE GONNA BE POPING UP IN EVERY TOWN .....
  • Tom M.
    Tom MeierOctober 28, 2013
    Go hungry and walk right up to place your order then sit.
  • Pattie G.
    Pattie GOctober 10, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    The meatball and ricotta pizza!!! Mama Mia!!!! Wow.
  • Justin T.
    Justin TasolidesAugust 23, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Gotta get that meatball pizza. Or that Paul and young Ron.
  • Melissa
    MelissaAugust 9, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the Anthonys salad it's so delish
  • Tom M.
    Tom MeierOctober 28, 2013
    The food was super, just walk up and place your order.
  • Mike🇺🇸 B.
    Mike🇺🇸 BarbeischApril 30, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    The pizza is the best!!!!
  • Robyn F.
    Robyn FreedmanSeptember 4, 2011
    Order the pizza lite crust, taste better
  • Valerie D.
    Valerie DJanuary 19, 2013
    PERONI ON TAP HERE! That deserves an extra star
  • Marc A.
    Marc ArnbergAugust 10, 2011
    Meatball and Riccotta pizza, awesome!
  • Jesse M.
    Jesse McGeeAugust 23, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Actually I'm having a Pomegranate Martini ; )
  • Mike🇺🇸 B.
    Mike🇺🇸 BarbeischApril 30, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza, yum!!!!!
  • Ryan O.
    Ryan O'ShaughnessyJuly 17, 2012
    Great WINGS!!!
  • Todd B.
    Todd BBQOctober 27, 2013
    This place sucks the nasty staff keeps you waiting and disrespects you when honoring you time for waiting. I would go to Phil's down the block.
  • Dani K.
    Dani KassJanuary 12, 2012
    The pizza is pretty gross. Not worth it when you're in a town with so many good pizza places.
  • Rosa F.
    Rosa FanizzaNovember 27, 2013
    Best pizza around!!!
  • James M.
    James MurrayNovember 2, 2014
    Grilled clams
  • Zach J.
    Zach JohnstonOctober 15, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Best wings ever
  • Jesse M.
    Jesse McGeeAugust 23, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Blue-ue Moon : )
  • Craig M.
    Craig MarkellAugust 22, 2011
    Watch out for gassy 13 year olds.
  • Rachel L.
    Rachel LSeptember 15, 2014
    Get the coal fired wings or eggplant pizza.
34 Photos

Related Searches

  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury
  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury photos
  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury location
  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury address
  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury
  • anthony's coal fired pizza woodbury
  • anthonys coal fired pizza woodbury
  • anthonys pizza woodbury

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF