Fish tacos hit the spot on NYE
Try the gator roll wrap. No, it doesn't contain alligator.
Friendly service, huge beer list and they even have a few ciders. I had the tuna sandwich and it was amazing
First time here for me. I heard that I had to try a pork tenderloin sandwich while I was in Indy and this place has the best. It did not disappoint. Great beer selection as well.
Love the style, food, and service here. Fish and chips are amazing. My boyfriend always gets the pork tenderloin and its a beast! Never had a bad experience here. Large, good draught list.
Great times, good food and drink.
Grab a few tasty beers here Saturday night (they have a great, large selection!) then come back Sunday morning for brunch!
The fire coat this place some of its rustic charm, but the new interior is full of light, and the food is just as good as ever
Great beer selection. Cool bar space. Large outdoor patio. Very tasty food. Chicken gator roll is awesome.
Lunch special is usually a good choice. Ask for Shannon, she is a great server!
Best black bean soup in the City. Great outside seating, too.
Pork tenderloin "hanger over" is great!
Not sure why someone left a tip about beers for the ladies. All the women I know enjoy a wide variety of good beer.
Open mic night on Tuesdays are great!
Tuesdays = $3.50 pints!
Grilled pork tenderloin is great
The Gator Roll Wrap is wonderful! Reasonably priced and great service. It's a must if you're at Butler.
Best potato casserole EVER - have the brunch it is a must
Fantastic live Irish folk music with Hogeye Navvy on Saturday nights
Garry's Grimey Grog, perfect drink for a cold day!
Great little brunch menu. Much less crowded than other brunch spots in the 'hood. Mimosas too!
Good crab cakes & salad. Corned beef was on the dry side.
The new salad with grilled tuna is delicious, but be sure to request it rare with dressing in the side.
Legitimately feel bad for those who think their tenderloin is good cause they're missing out on a truly good one. Breading was thin and flaking off. Not disgusting but subpar for being made in house.
New decor is great... 60 tap beers! Crowded on Fri & Sat nights so prepare to wait, but you can walk right in and sit down at other times.
Very good for all in our party
Don't bother. Bad service.
Always go to the bar to see D
Try the Chicken Marsala! It's amazing!!
Amazing beer selection!
After the renovation, they now have a pretty awesome array of 60 beers on tap, including a few the ladies will likely enjoy like pumpkin or banana bread ales.
Great place! Its huge inside! Bigger bar with more beers on tap! Will definitely be back!
Reaxed atmosphere with great food.
Jazz and Pint Night on Tuesdays with the best barkeeper around! All pints just $3 and music starts at 6pm, no cover charge.
Pork tenderloin sandwich, Epic.
If you order the fried pork tenderloin, prepare to be amazed. It's delicious and ginormous.
Tuesday night jazz and pints are superb. Soups and the cobbler also keep me coming back.
Eggs Chesapeake are yummy.
Hogeye Navvy on Saturday nights, Navvy Irregulars on Wed., Standard(ish) Jazz Trio on Tues. Great food & music!
If you don't try the tenderloin you're crazy! Best in Indiana
Maggie would kill for the shepherds pie whenever they serve it. "it's as if grandma were still alive"
Come for the great food, stay for Hogeye Navvy!
Tex Mex salad for sure. Good draft selection.
Bangers and Mash are fantastic!