Atlantic Fish And Chop House

American Restaurant and Steakhouse$$$$
  • Ranked #7 for American restaurants in Edgartown
  • Greg P.
    "The Dom Perignon and Truffle Fries Deal is Awesome."(3 Tips)
    Dana H.
    "Bryant and Cordelia are great!"(2 Tips)
    Chelsey S.
    "The Lobster Arugula salad is definitely worth having!"(11 Tips)
    Caitlin C.
    "They serve bacon as a complimentary bar snack!"(2 Tips)
44 Tips and reviews
  • lobster
  • cordelia
  • cocktails
  • truffle fries
  • martinis
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • lynn w.
    Stay away! This is a pure tourist trap...the food is not fresh, the wait staff is horrible and the noise level prohibits a table conversation. It is highly overpriced!!
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Zealous W.
    Zealous WileySeptember 7, 2015
    You can't go wrong with the bone-in ribeye.
  • Stephen P.
    Stephen PeelerAugust 26, 2015
    The sea bass is awesome, order the brussels sprouts and asparagus to top off the meal. Potatoes augrautin won't disappoint either.
  • Stephen P.
    Stephen PeelerAugust 26, 2015
    The beet salad is delicious!
  • James K.
    James KiernanAugust 12, 2015
    The only time I've seen an establishment serve a bouquet of bacon as complimentary bar snacks. AMAZING!
  • Lindsay L.
    Lindsay LehmanJuly 17, 2015
    sit on the back deck!
  • Whitney F.
    Whitney FishmanJuly 4, 2015
    Don't come between 4-5 when they're turning over service it's epically slow. However the food is solid.
  • Mark G.
    Mark GraciaSeptember 21, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
    Good spot for cocktails and seafood on the water.
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaAugust 31, 2014
    Lunch was pretty good.. Lobster guac, watermelon/feta salad, lobster Mac n cheese, tuna and shrimp salad.. All pretty darn good
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaAugust 31, 2014
    A bit more age appropriate place to drink and dance in Edgartown. DJ was pretty good too. Danced the night away! 👯👯👯💃💃
  • Dan C.
    Dan CassarinoAugust 30, 2014
    Clam Chowder is a must!
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin CostelloAugust 25, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    They serve bacon as a complimentary bar snack!
  • Maggie L.
    Maggie LeVineJuly 7, 2014
    Good music, good food... But the music - so damn LOUD!!!
  • Brea E.
    Brea EllisMay 12, 2014
    Get the lobster Mac and cheese
  • Roshni S.
    Roshni SinghMay 8, 2014
    Great chocolate martini
  • Jon M.
    Jon MelamutAugust 24, 2013
    Free Bacon at the bar
  • Chelsey S.
    Chelsey SmallAugust 16, 2013
    The Lobster Arugula salad is definitely worth having! A generous amount of lobster and delicious strawberry vinaigrette, what more could you ask for? A perfect lunch! And great views from the deck.
  • John W.
    John WallaceAugust 13, 2013
    Skip the lobster roll. You taste more bread than lobster.
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Melanie W.
    Melanie WingfieldJuly 15, 2013
    King crab guacamole!!
  • Bear F.
    Bear FisherJuly 13, 2013
    Great spot with awesome views. Get the wedge and the rose champagne drink. Ymy.
  • Renée G.
    Renée GreeneApril 28, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    The live music starts in May. Don't miss it!!!
  • Carroll & Vincent R.
    Carroll & Vincent Real EstateApril 5, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    Tomato soup and sandwich awesome lunch
  • Shaun
    ShaunJuly 7, 2012
    Jamie at the front is a tool.
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Erin M.
    Erin MJune 27, 2012
    Try the sugar cane grilled shrimp, it's great!
  • Ashl(ee)
    Ashl(ee)June 13, 2012
    My Favorite!
    Downvoted Jul 22
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin CostelloJune 2, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Best late night scene in Edgartown when we visited in late May. Drinks and food were both excellent. Their lobster dishes are amazing!
  • Mark G.
    Mark GraciaJune 1, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    Good lobster and beers
  • Allyson E.
    Allyson EmhoffMay 28, 2012
    Management is pompous, self-involved and clearly unhelpful to their undertrained service staff. Decent place for cocktails and apps. Don't waste your money for dinner!
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Matt L.
    Matt LibbeyMay 27, 2012
    Maitre d is a douche...go to the shanty
  • Janis K.
    Janis KrumsNovember 11, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Make sure you know how much an add on is to your salad. Can be an expensive lesson otherwise($29 + full salad price). The waiter was not helpful. Won't go again.
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Erika B.
    Erika B.August 30, 2011
    Stay away. Worst service on the NE.
    Upvoted Jul 22
  • Greg P.
    Greg PappasAugust 26, 2011
    The Dom Perignon and Truffle Fries Deal is Awesome.
  • Claire B.
    Claire BarthelemyAugust 26, 2011
    Live music and some of the best people watching on the island - love it!
  • Danyel S.
    Danyel SmithAugust 16, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    the drink specials? eh. the seafood? OMG. too tasty for words. try the lobster cocktail (it's not a drink).
  • George D.
    George DuryeaAugust 11, 2011
    If you're deciding between anything and the tuna steak sandwich, get the tuna steak sandwich.
  • Dian D.
    Dian DulbergerJuly 28, 2011
    Delicious cantaloupe martini
  • Dana H.
    Dana HagendorfJuly 23, 2011
    Bryant and Cordelia are great! Food is excellent. Truffle fries a must.
  • Jim M.
    Jim MeskauskasJuly 9, 2011
    Awesome bloody mary's!
  • Buzz C.
    Buzz CovingtonJuly 9, 2011
    Lobster Reuben? Insane!
  • Damaris C.
    Damaris Clark-SpearMay 26, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for Ben or Cordelia! Reall
  • WhatsUpMartha
    WhatsUpMarthaDecember 21, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    Pretty mean Martinis coming out of this joint and enough good looking people to get the scene poppin - great food, but we prefer to hit the drink scene and the occasional Dance Party with Band or DJ! Read more
  • A.J.
    A.J.July 13, 2010
    "Side" of truffle fries easily feeds six people. Very good... and addictive!
  • Michael K.
    Michael KempnerJune 17, 2010
    Bar b Que Salmon is outstanding...also good raw bar
  • Danyel S.
    Danyel SmithJune 12, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    go late. go when they have live music. sit at the bar. drink the strong drinks. have fun.
142 Photos

Related Searches

  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown
  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown photos
  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown location
  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown address
  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown
  • atlantic fish and chop house edgartown
  • atlantic fish and steak house edgartown

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF