Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante

Italian Restaurant and Pizza Place$$$$
  • Kiran B.
    "Amazing french fried eggplant and pizza!!"(4 Tips)
    Jennfer M.
    "Best thin crust pizza in town."(6 Tips)
    "One of the best sausage pizzas you can find."(2 Tips)
    Nicolás J.
    "Very good chicken parmigiana."(2 Tips)
44 Tips and reviews
  • pizza
  • eggplant
  • chicken parmigiana
  • family-friendly
  • french fries
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Josh S.
    Josh StraubAugust 3, 2014
    This place gets EXTREMELY busy at peak times, the benches outside will all be full of people waiting to be seated. So beware & be prepared for that. But it's because the thin crust pizza's that good!
  • Summer
    SummerDecember 20, 2012
    The calamari is a major skip! But, like everyone says a simple pizza is great! Order a larger size than you want, left overs in the oven are awesome! :)
  • Deborah M.
    Deborah MohrApril 21, 2014
    Balestreri's has the best pizza and eggplant! People line up outside the door to get it. There is not another pizza like like it and every time I am back in town I make it a point to stop in!
  • Shane B.
    Shane BlakeleyJanuary 19, 2013
    Great pizza, and huge portions. A medium is an extra large at most other places.
  • Nicolás J.
    Nicolás JiménezNovember 27, 2011
    Very good chicken parmigiana. Also try the clam chowder instead of salad if that's what they're serving.
  • Liza P.
    Liza PurdyNovember 5, 2011
    Best pizza ever! Awesome eggplant, great garlic bread! Watch out for a short, chubby, curly-haired lady server--she's a raging bitch.
    NYC KIDDecember 29, 2013
    Good food and Jessica is the best waitress! Super funny and sweet!
  • Leslie Q.
    Leslie QuadeFebruary 28, 2015
    Eggplant is a must-have! Great pizza and pasta too. Love this place!
  • Tom P.
    Tom P.August 14, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    A true Wauwatosa landmark, known for excellent thin crust style pizza. The garlic bread and spaghetti is very good too.
  • Emily N.
    Emily NicloyNovember 16, 2011
    I can't decide what's better, the cheesy garlic bread or the pizza. So you have to try both. Never a disappointment. Have been going their for over 30 years.
  • MyCommunityNOW
    MyCommunityNOWNovember 23, 2012
    Not in the mood for thin-crust pizza? Try the chicken Parmesan, a signature dish (via @GrabaBiteNOW). Read more
  • Jennfer M.
    Jennfer MichelOctober 5, 2015
    Best thin crust pizza in town. Eggplant to die for!
  • Joe M.
    Joe M.December 28, 2010
    I usually like a lot of toppings on my pizza, but their plain, sausage pizza is the best.
  • Elizabeth G.
    Elizabeth GSeptember 28, 2015
    Love the pizza, egg plant fries, and cheesy bread
  • Rick S.
    Rick SincereSeptember 22, 2011
    This is a half order of the fried eggplant! Delicious!
  • Lynnett H.
    Lynnett HarveySeptember 15, 2013 Also the fried eggplant is delish!
  • Kari
    KariJanuary 18, 2014
    All the food is good. The desserts are yummy!!
  • Russ N.
    Russ NicloyNovember 16, 2011
    Perfect garlic bread. And the pizza is even better!
  • Shanice H.
    Shanice HemphillJune 28, 2016
    Love the think crust sausage & pepperoni pizza.
  • Richard O.
    Richard OBrienMay 13, 2013
    Very very very good! Everything
  • Tim V.
    Tim V.November 18, 2012
    My All Time Favorite Pizza Place.
  • Nick L.
    Nick LyonsOctober 16, 2011
    My preference of the two, simple and delish.
  • Andy
    AndyDecember 20, 2014
    Thin crust pizza. Nice n greasy for ya
  • Kyle K.
    Kyle KasprzakMarch 27, 2016
    Pizza is ok. It's greasy and the sauce is bland. Meatballs were good but again the sauce was rather bland. Parmesan can only compensate so much for bland sauce.
    FEASTBEAST.COMMarch 23, 2011
    One of the best sausage pizzas you can find.
  • Kiran B.
    Kiran B.June 11, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Amazing french fried eggplant and pizza!!
  • Ron S.
    Ron SigalMarch 22, 2015
    Best thin crust pizza ever
  • Ashley G.
    Ashley GemeinhardtAugust 16, 2012
    Get the eggplant strips.
  • Marc G.
    Marc GundersonAugust 15, 2017
    Great thin crust pizza.
  • Karen B.
    Karen BarbiereDecember 3, 2010
    Zaffiro's pizza is better. Go for the pasta
  • Rick S.
    Rick SincereSeptember 22, 2011
    Fried eggplant worth the price
  • Katrina T.
    Katrina TaliaferroJuly 7, 2017
    Great food and service!
  • Shawn H.
    Shawn HollowayJanuary 5, 2016
    Love 'The Works' pizza.
  • Liza P.
    Liza PurdyOctober 1, 2011
    Amazing bread and pizza!
  • Lauren J.
    Lauren JMarch 11, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Great pizza
  • Karin T.
    Karin TylerApril 5, 2014
    Sauce needs flavor!
  • Nina K.
    Nina KrausMarch 26, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Great egg plant!
  • Brian M.
    Brian MuelrathAugust 25, 2013
    Best pizza ever
  • Sarah B.
    Sarah Brantman-BlankeAugust 12, 2013
  • Brandon W.
    Brandon W.July 9, 2011
    Best pizza around
  • DJ C.
    DJ CTZAugust 13, 2011
    Best Pizza in Town #Always!
  • Lori R.
    Lori RieglerJune 23, 2011
    best pizza Read more
  • Jamaar M.
    Jamaar McKayApril 15, 2013
    Best pizza & garlic bread !
  • Jim F.
    Jim FoyDecember 12, 2009
    Fantastic pizza!
58 Photos

Related Searches

  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee photos
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee location
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee address
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee
  • balestreris milwaukee
  • balisteri's italian/american ristorante milwaukee
  • balisteris italianamerican ristorante milwaukee
  • balistreiri's tosa milwaukee
  • balistreiris tosa milwaukee
  • balistreri's milwaukee
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante milwaukee
  • balistreri's italian american ristorante, located at milwaukee
  • balistreri's italian risorante milwaukee
  • balistreri's italian ristorante milwaukee

Foursquare © 2018  Lovingly made in NYC & SF