If you don't know what to get, go for the Salty Pimp. You won't be disappointed.
You really can't go wrong with your order. Personal faves are the salty pimp, the gobbler, and the mermaid
Pumpkin soft serve
Awesome flavors and great staff
The Salty Pimp is amazing.
The Bea Arthur is good if you're looking for something that isn't overwhelming but still tasty.
The Bea Arthur is heaven in a cone
American globs and salty pimp!
Amazing ice cream
BIG PORTIONS luv the pretzel drizzled in chocolate
They do really fun stuff with soft serve here. The horchata flavor is surprisingly great, and the Salty Pimp is delicious. Also don't worry if there's a line! It moves really fast.
The Salty Pimp is incredible and a force to be reckoned with!
Monday inn sundae...over priced and nothing special. Took the employee 10 mins to make my ice cream by the one I got it it was all melted! ...and I was their only customer in there at the time wth!
Meh. No amount of sprinkles make up for the mediocre soft serve base.
Salty pimp FTW.
Great with friends, great with dates. One of my favorite ice cream shops! Salty Pimp is a must try. My go to is Bea Arthur😍
Overpriced ice cream~ go for the sundae Monday!
Monday Sundae & Salty Pimp! Don't worry about the line; the shop isn't big enough to fit everyone waiting to be served. Their ice cream is worth the wait!
It's a good day when deciding between the Salty Pimp, Monday Sundae, American Globs, and Nutella Shake is the hardest decision of my day.
The Monday Sundae (NUTELLA!) or the American Gangster are the way to go!
Those ice creams are great, but be ready for it!
The salty pimp is worth the lines.
Get the Salty Pimp
The salty pimp might seem like the obvious go to but the bea arthur is choice
Get the violet beauregarde this month, the mermaid any other time.
The salty pimp is amazing!
The Salty Pimp
The Salty Pimp is awesome!!
Salty pimp foreverrrrrrr
Salty Pimp is amazing, but you already knew that. Look out for the Cinnamon Toast Crunch daily special when it's available!
Monday sundae is delicious
Their ice cream with caramel &sea salt is so good. Get a loyalty card and get 1 ice cream free when you've had 10. Get 50% off if u buy the t-shirt they wear in the shop - have to wear it to qualify
Really amazing love the big pimp and bea Arthur
The salty pimp. Get it in a dish for a drip-free experience.
Stop looking at the wall. You want Salty Pimp believe me.
Great soft-serve. Try the salty pimp
Try the Salty Pimp or American Globs.
Good cones but a lil pricy
Amazing ice cream!
Don't believe the hype. Just like a McDonald's cone + lots of stuff on top.
There's a reason that all of the reviews mention the Salty Pimp. Get it and be glad you did.
SALTY PIMP SALTY PIMP SALTY PIMP
Get ANYTHING and you won't be disappointed. Well, except in the fact that you don't have room to get EVERYTHING.
A bit of a queue but the ice cream was ridiculously delicious.
Long line in front of the door, if you want to taste NY ice cream you can trt
Very friendly staff
Salty pimp, the tip is the best part!