Big Gay Ice Cream Shop

Big Gay Ice Cream Shop

Ice Cream Shop and Dessert Shop$$$$
East Village, New York
Save
Share
9.0/10
1,785
ratings
407 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • salty pimp
  • ice cream
  • american globs
  • bea arthur
  • chocolate dip
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Ronnie P.
    SALTY PIMP IS LYFEEEEEEEE
  • Erin R.
    Erin Rath2 weeks ago
    This is, by far, the best softserve I've had during my two months in NYC. Definitely try the specialty mix with vanilla ice cream, Nilla wafers, and dulce de le che. Yummilicious!!!!!
  • PureWow
    PureWow2 weeks ago
    It's just not summer until you’ve had a salty pimp from Big Gay! Read more
  • Vee J.
    Vee JJuly 26
    Salty Pimp
  • Matt C.
    Gotta go for the American globs. The pretzel/ice cream combo is genius, and if you spring for a waffle cone lined with peanut butter... Yum.
  • Lea C.
    Salty pimp. Not the cheapest ice cream$.
  • Bob W.
    Bob WeiJuly 20
    salty pimp
  • Tabitha J.
    Monday Sundae!! Salty Pimp!! Can't go wrong.
  • HashtagNYU
    Try the Bea Arthur, Salty Pimp, or Cinnamax sandwich for a cold delight. You can also buy a t-shirt.
  • Terry F.
    Terry FJuly 6
    This Soft-Serve Ice Cream is The BEST I've EVER had and I'm coming back ever time I come home to my view place. I can't recommend this ice cream enough & my fiends I took to NY loved it as much as Me
  • Bedi
    BediJuly 1
    Amazingly tasty ice creams. Get an american globs and have a taste bud orgasm
  • Russell H.
    EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED. Ice cream was standard soft serve horendous, toppings were blehhh. Go to Morgensterns for some authentic homemade delicious
  • Michelle W.
    Ordering off menu sounds boss until they ring up American gangster and you realize you're spending over $8 on an ice cream
    Upvoted Jun 26
  • Petey P.
    Petey PJune 21
    Yum to EVERYTHING
  • Lauren C.
    American globs is an absolute must and the soft serve is heaven!! Sprinkles!!!
  • Paige C.
    Paige CJune 2
    Salty Pimp! It's amazing!
  • Leonardo A.
    Mermaid - Key Lime filling with custard! So delicious!!
  • Karl S.
    salty pimp!
  • Sara Y.
    Sara YApril 15
    Gimme dat mermaid.
  • Gisele S.
    Salty pimp . Quero voltar!
  • Angela K.
    I totally enjoyed it! My daughter was a little disappointed they only had chocolate and vanilla soft serve.
  • Joey T.
    Joey TMarch 20
    Try the sundae funday! The cone is lined with Nutella!
  • Funes
    FunesMarch 15
    Had the Salty Pimp and it was perfect combo of sweet and salty. Come for the name stay for the ice cream.
  • Sarah B.
    Sarah BrinkMarch 13
    I didn't think there was anything special about the ice cream and I do love soft serve. I think it's just more hype about the naming / toppings.
  • DoubleDeuce
    DoubleDeuceFebruary 20
    My dad is from Kansas. I can't get him to try this place. I'm from Kansas. I've almost tried the entire menu.
  • David M.
    David MilbergFebruary 18
    Sea salt one was amazing
  • Sheena
    SheenaFebruary 13
    Nutella lined vanilla cone!!
  • Hank C.
    Hank CoutureFebruary 5
    The Salty Pimp!!!
  • Andrew A.
    Andrew AdamsJanuary 23
    Salty pimp is a must
  • Jillian
    JillianDecember 29, 2015
    Used to be a big salty pimp advocate. Now I'm thinking the key lime pie cup is the real OG here.
  • Gauge A.
    Gauge AlfordDecember 28, 2015
    i like ice cream
  • Tyler L.
    Tyler LundDecember 5, 2015
    Big Gay Ice Cream certainly has flair to spare. The ice cream cones have interesting names and lots of options for toppings. The ice cream is soft serve and a bit boring by itself.
  • Linda C.
    Linda ChowNovember 25, 2015
    If you don't know what to get, go for the Salty Pimp. You won't be disappointed.
  • Howard W.
    Howard WalfishNovember 24, 2015
    You really can't go wrong with your order. Personal faves are the salty pimp, the gobbler, and the mermaid
  • the Lala
    the LalaNovember 13, 2015
    Classic vanilla cones get jacked up with spiced chocolate dip and injected with salted caramel. If you’re doing a dessert crawl, I’m going recommend you walk to the East Village location. Read more
  • Sydney M.
    Sydney MNovember 9, 2015
    Pumpkin soft serve
  • Louis M.
    Louis MattaOctober 18, 2015
    Awesome flavors and great staff
  • Chris M.
    Chris MearOctober 11, 2015
    The Salty Pimp is amazing.
  • Nathanael C.
    Nathanael ChoOctober 7, 2015
    The Bea Arthur is good if you're looking for something that isn't overwhelming but still tasty.
  • Sarah A.
    Sarah AtwoodSeptember 26, 2015
    The Bea Arthur is heaven in a cone
  • Margarita K.
    Margarita KrupSeptember 22, 2015
    American globs and salty pimp!
  • Renata T.
    Renata Tabosa MacedoSeptember 21, 2015
    Amazing ice cream
  • Jacqueline M.
    Jacqueline MaSeptember 18, 2015
    BIG PORTIONS luv the pretzel drizzled in chocolate
  • Afi Y.
    Afi Yellow-DukeSeptember 18, 2015
    They do really fun stuff with soft serve here. The horchata flavor is surprisingly great, and the Salty Pimp is delicious. Also don't worry if there's a line! It moves really fast.
  • Murphy N.
    Murphy NashSeptember 10, 2015
    The Salty Pimp is incredible and a force to be reckoned with!
  • D
    DSeptember 8, 2015
    Monday inn sundae...over priced and nothing special. Took the employee 10 mins to make my ice cream by the one I got it it was all melted! ...and I was their only customer in there at the time wth!
    Upvoted Jun 14
  • Peter L.
    Peter LadaAugust 31, 2015
    Meh. No amount of sprinkles make up for the mediocre soft serve base.
  • Vaidehi K.
    Vaidehi KAugust 29, 2015
    Salty pimp FTW.
  • Carol
    CarolAugust 25, 2015
    Great with friends, great with dates. One of my favorite ice cream shops! Salty Pimp is a must try. My go to is Bea Arthur😍
  • Anat
    AnatAugust 21, 2015
    Overpriced ice cream~ go for the sundae Monday!
1,893 Photos

Related Searches

  • big gay ice cream shop new york
  • big gay ice cream shop new york photos
  • big gay ice cream shop new york location
  • big gay ice cream shop new york address
  • big gay ice cream shop new york
  • big gay ice cream shop new york
  • big gay ice cream shop east village new york

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF