Black Shack Burger

(Now Closed)
Burger Joint$$$$
Murray Hill, New York
Save
Share
  • Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and Village Voice
    • Serious Eats
    • Village Voice
124 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • hades i.
    Place is closed now.
  • Taylor K.
    It wasn't bad. You can find better in the city, but if you need juicy burger in the neighborhood to fill you up, this is it. Well maybe, this is the first time I ate food in Murray Hill.
  • Mike L.
    Mike L.June 17
    The burgers are excellent. Get a double with bacon and cheddar cheese.
  • Chez O.
    Chez OngApril 7
    Had the Hole Mole Turkey Burger. Best turkey burger I've had so far in New York.
  • Isa
    IsaMarch 7
    Very cute burger joint with good burgers and a creamy vanilla milkshake. However, it didn't sweep me off my feet. Clean, solid, but no wow-effect.
  • Casa S.
    Casa SassoFebruary 28
    Fast and good
  • Anthony C.
    Anthony ChoulouteNovember 29, 2016
    The Western Burger is my personal favorite here.
  • rich m.
    rich masioNovember 28, 2016
    Perfectly cooked average tasting char broiled 1/4lb burger on a soft bun but the sweet potato fries are the star.
  • WillMcD
    WillMcDSeptember 16, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Burgers and the Black & White milkshakes are the best
  • Shannon D.
    Shannon DonnellyAugust 29, 2016
    Tastes like a freshly grilled burger, with a good beer selection! Fries are great
  • Katie B.
    Katie Berger FolmarAugust 9, 2016
    Burgers, fries and shakes all great ! And a nice beer selection
  • pAx
    pAxJune 10, 2016
    black & white shake is totally AWESOME!!!!
  • Chris K.
    Chris KempApril 29, 2016
    Overpriced burgers. But they do taste good and I appreciate the fried onion topping.
  • Christina C.
    Christina ChinMarch 14, 2016
    Service was good, but the black shack burger was just ok, nothing special. Sweet potato fries were on point.
  • Mike D.
    Mike DavisDecember 28, 2015
    Black and white shake!
  • Amy R.
    Amy RobertsonNovember 23, 2015
    The plain burger is nothing special but the steakhouse is quite delicious and filling. It always takes longer than I expect to get food, especially fried
  • Daniel R.
    Daniel RotherySeptember 20, 2015
    Cajun fries are excellent, good burgers in terms of size, meat quality and freshness. Good discovery.
  • Billy K.
    Billy KeenlyAugust 30, 2015
    The Steakhouse Burger with creamed spinach and crunchy onions is amazing.
  • Shikha V.
    Shikha VermaAugust 26, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    😍😍 western chicken burger
  • Thomas P.
    Thomas PajorAugust 25, 2015
    Great fast food burger. Come here instead of Shake Shack, it’s so much better.
  • Casey E.
    Casey EstesAugust 14, 2015
    The steakhouse burger is great
  • Leo C.
    Leo CAugust 1, 2015
    shack turkey burger with sweet potato fries!!! #tasty
  • George L.
    George LeeJuly 10, 2015
    Fried onion and spinach burger. Cajun fries are salty but have a good kick
  • Camellia S.
    Camellia SultanJune 22, 2015
    Worst ice tea and lemonade the burgers ( black shack and stake ) were very disappointing 👎👎👎
  • Andy M.
    Andy MartensJune 16, 2015
    Cajun fries as probably the best fries in the neighborhood. I'd recommend the steakhouse burger.
  • David S.
    David SchorrJune 4, 2015
    Must try for the Murray Hill crowd.
  • Marta G.
    Marta GrzeszczykMay 30, 2015
    Nice place. Burgers were ok! I liked the sweet fries 👍
  • drew t.
    drew tarvinMay 25, 2015
    It's not as good as Shake Shack but still respectable burgers.
  • Tom H.
    Tom HalleranMay 17, 2015
    A better than average burger in this dive meets hip joint.
  • Brian C.
    Brian ClarkMay 8, 2015
    Burgers. They're good.
  • Emma Q.
    Emma QueryApril 14, 2015
    Sometimes vegetarian options are sad, but the tofu burger was amazing! Great cozy atmosphere, even though the staff was a little surly. Would eat here again.
  • James P.
    James PhippsApril 13, 2015
    Bosco Chocolate Soda on the fountain drink fountain! 😋
  • Rachel B.
    Rachel B.March 18, 2015
    If you're a burger connoisseur get the steakhouse burger. Its armed with garlic creamed spinach, horseradish sauce and crispy onions! Its so good!
  • Brian C.
    Brian ChaseMarch 17, 2015
    The western burger is the way to go. Onion rings, pickles and BBQ sauce along with a perfectly flavored beef patty make one great burger.
  • Meg F.
    Meg FarmerMarch 10, 2015
    Shockingly tasty burger. But still doesn't beat shake shack. Highlight: The peanut butter chocolate milkshake.
  • Marcela S.
    Marcela SarmientoFebruary 27, 2015
    Love the black shack burger & sweet potato fries! The buns could be warmer but there is something about the taste of the burger that gets me every time. Black Shack over Shake Shack any day of the wk!
  • Karl S.
    Karl SchafferFebruary 8, 2015
    black shack with cheddar and bacon. has to have bacon.
  • Jan-Erik S.
    Jan-Erik SamuelsenFebruary 6, 2015
    Had a Black Shack Burger with bacon amd cheddar cheese. If you're in NY and want a burger, go here. It taste amazing and they have a tiny, but awesome collection of beer.
  • Ricky S.
    Ricky SherrillJanuary 18, 2015
    Be sure to try the Cajun Fries. Their lemonade & iced tea makes a great "Arnold Palmer"
  • Linnie D.
    Linnie DJanuary 15, 2015
    Hoping it tastes as good as it smells.
  • 67thave
    67thaveJanuary 10, 2015
    Great burgers and fun staff.
  • Bob H.
    Bob HumeDecember 23, 2014
    Burgers and shakes !! Yum
  • Mike W.
    Mike WaterhouseNovember 22, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    This hidden gem is arguably the best burger joint in the city. The burgers are perfectly sized & have great flavor. The cajun fries are quite delicious, too. A bonus: BSB has a decent beer selection.
  • Abner A.
    Abner AcevesNovember 8, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Double Black Shack Burger with Cheese, and if you're feeling aggressive go for the Oreo Shake. Unreal.
  • Andrew C.
    Andrew CerdaNovember 4, 2014
    Order the cajun fries!
  • Match T.
    Match ThisflyOctober 18, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    The Black Shack Burger is just enough. Great balance, but the grilled bun with the burnt edges make you feel like anything in life is possible. #littlethings
  • Patrick
    PatrickOctober 14, 2014
    The burgers and shakes are the best in the city.
  • Andrew G.
    Andrew GattoOctober 4, 2014
    Onion rings are amazing here. Blackshack burger and fries are also great. Maybe my favorite burger in NYC.
  • Rewan P.
    Rewan PartiAugust 27, 2014
    Their Cajun fries are crisp and perfectly seasoned. Do not expect large quantity as five guys!
  • Cori L.
    Cori LinvilleAugust 21, 2014
    Good burgers, they have beef, turkey, and tofu burgers!
  • Elizabeth F.
    Elizabeth FAugust 12, 2014
    I ordered delivery and it took over an hour. The food was pretty good, but they forgot to send any condiments or napkins.
  • Chris C.
    Chris CrookerAugust 5, 2014
    Wow. Awesome burgers. Onion straws are great too.
  • harryh
    harryhJuly 29, 2014
    No Coke. No Pepsi. RC Cola!
  • Kristen D.
    Kristen DrewesJune 3, 2014
    Definitely nowhere close to the "best", let alone good burger...
  • David W.
    David WangMay 28, 2014
    Have to try the steakhouse burger here!
  • Joel S.
    Joel SavitzkyMay 3, 2014
    If you need a veggie alternative, the Mozzarella Sandwich has house-made Mozzarella, avocados and fried onions – delicious stuff!
  • Roanna K.
    Roanna K.April 29, 2014
    The steakhouse burger with bacon is a gourmand experience for <$10! Creamed spinach, crispy onions, and horseradish, mmm. Just make sure you get extra napkins ;)
  • Stephen G.
    Stephen GussMarch 30, 2014
    don't go here because the food doesn't taste good
  • James G.
    James GreenMarch 26, 2014
    They serve some of the best sweet potato fries I've had. The steakhouse burger is awesome and there's an interesting selection of beer by the can.
  • Sandra R.
    Sandra RFebruary 8, 2014
    Sweet potato fires are crispy and perfect!
  • Frantisek S.
    Frantisek StepanekDecember 28, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Best veggie burger in the World!
  • Michael J.
    Michael JaccarinoDecember 20, 2013
    By far the best burger in NY!!!!
  • Matthew K.
    Matthew KennedyDecember 18, 2013
    An amazing place to get a burger in NYC. Well ran and the ambiance inside is authentically warm.
  • Markku A.
    Markku AnttilaDecember 9, 2013
    The best burgers in a looong time. Go for the Black Shack Burger with bacon and cheese and you won't be disappointed. You just might wanna order two because the size aint that big but the taste is!
  • Sam C.
    Sam ChengNovember 23, 2013
    Good burger over price beer and the portions are small
  • Rudy G.
    Rudy G.September 20, 2013
    It was ok. I have had better. Ambiance is not great, too dark. Might be better for late night.
  • Santiago Y.
    Santiago YusteSeptember 14, 2013
    :-) good place to enjoy
  • Deb 👑 T.
    Deb 👑 TAugust 21, 2013
    Nice place. Nice waiters. Free refill for the drinks. Very tasty burgers and not too big. The fries are a little too salty but good.
  • polm p.
    polm photoAugust 17, 2013
    There burgers are great and there customer service is great
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsJuly 29, 2013
    When at its best, the burger is a tastier, handmade dead-ringer for a Burger King Whopper.
  • Javed A.
    Javed AkhtarMay 3, 2013
    Western tofu is awesome. Gonna try western chicken next time for sure
  • Gregory W.
    Gregory WrightApril 22, 2013
    Not impressed with these burgers. Look and taste like pre-made frozen patties.
  • Trevor C.
    Trevor ClarkeFebruary 2, 2013
    Food is delicious here and the service is great! Friendly and helpful, I'll definitely be coming back.
  • Village Voice
    Village VoiceJanuary 25, 2013
    Black Shack Burger (& 50+ other eateries) will be sampling their fare at our 2013 Choice Eats tasting event on 3/19 - can't wait! http://ow.ly/h6OAc
  • julie s.
    julie sempleDecember 24, 2012
    Gr8 food Amazing service but NEED MUSIC - listening to the employee shit gets kinda nasty!!! Gr8 burgers!!! NEED MUSIC!!
  • Alex
    AlexOctober 5, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Happy smiley staff and great burgers. The Steakhouse Burger (no bacon) is awesome.
  • Mike M.
    Mike MorenoSeptember 20, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Come after 1:30pm to beat the main lunch time crowd
  • Joe C.
    Joe ConteSeptember 10, 2012
    Chocolate Soda, enough said.
  • David S.
    David SAugust 31, 2012
    This place is a creeper. Try the grilled chicken western sandwich w cheddar and bacon. Wow!
  • Joelle V.
    Joelle VelascoJuly 30, 2012
    The Black Shack burger is probably the best burger I've ever had. So good.
  • JiP🇺🇸🇩🇪 🏄
    JiP🇺🇸🇩🇪 🏄July 28, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    2 cheese burgers and Cajun fries... fuck yea
  • LivingLocaLNYC N.
    LivingLocaLNYC NYCJuly 27, 2012
    The shakes are the boooomb!! Specially a really cold one in summer time is like deesert after ur burger creation!
  • Velly Y.
    Velly YusrilJuly 12, 2012
    Chocolate soda woohoo!!!
  • Aimee K.
    Aimee KibbeJune 30, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    Chicken Ceasar Sandwhich w/ bacon & avocado. Do it.
  • adMarketplace.com
    adMarketplace.comJune 21, 2012
    "With a simple menu on an old-school board, this inexpensive hole in the wall is perfect for a delicious, inexpensive, greasy meal. Get a milkshake on your way out." - Alex, Communications Manager
  • Raj N.
    Raj NFebruary 24, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    A solidly built tasty burger and a cool place to chill
  • M. Silver Associates
    M. Silver AssociatesFebruary 2, 2012
    Those skinny Pat La Frieda patties and the secret "Shack Sauce" prove that with quality ingredients fast food doesn't have to be a $10 bag of greasy sawdust.. Every New Yorker knows. Try the burgers!
  • Niral P.
    Niral PatelDecember 16, 2011
    The double burger is insane. The IPA's are pretty legit also.
  • Chophel N.
    Chophel NamgyalDecember 14, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Pretty good burger made to order! Sweet potato fries decent! RC cola fountain sodas are nice! Radio head album playing v nice!
  • Stephen F.
    Stephen FerryDecember 11, 2011
    Burgers are great. The kitchen must be overwhelmed, we waited 30 minutes for fries and never received them.
  • Gary A.
    Gary AlonyNovember 27, 2011
    The burgers are great! Event food for vegetarians. Try the tofu sandwich.
  • Stephanie A.
    Stephanie AielloNovember 22, 2011
    Not so good
  • Kurt C.
    Kurt CarstensenAugust 10, 2011
    Been here 50+ times
    Best burger and shake ever.
  • Randall N.
    Randall NovalJuly 18, 2011
    meh, far better burgers most everywhere else. Read more
  • Peak9ine
    Peak9ineJuly 11, 2011
    Anything Western.
  • Samuel G.
    Samuel GozlanJuly 5, 2011
    Good burgers! Read more
  • Nick F.
    Nick FodenJune 15, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    ERIN get a shake and fries too. For old times sake!
  • Mike D.
    Mike DalessioJune 6, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Jonesing for milkshake and Cajun fries. BOOM.
  • Lisa K.
    Lisa KelseyMay 10, 2011
    fries are reeeeeaaallllly salty--but still good. Black Shack Burger perfect as is.
  • Jada M.
    Jada MApril 22, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Never cared for Caesar Salad until I tried theirs. Fresh, delicious, and the dressing is awesome. Top with chicken and love it even more!
  • Fernanda A.
    Fernanda AraujoDecember 16, 2016
    Hambúrguer saboroso!
  • Javi F.
    Javi FerezMay 21, 2016
    Esta muy bien, buenas hamburguesas y bien de precio.
  • w0lfr4m
    w0lfr4mNovember 30, 2015
    Recomiendo probar la hamburguesa especial cajún (ojo, ¡es picante!).
  • Marcello Pereira
    Marcello PereiraDecember 28, 2014
    Nossa que demais 🍴🍴lugar limpo ! Preço justo !
  • Leandro M.
    Leandro MarinoNovember 15, 2014
    Western Burger 😍😍😍
  • Mic H.
    Mic HiAugust 9, 2014
    いわゆるバーガー屋。旨い。
183 Photos

Related Searches

  • black shack burger new york
  • black shack burger new york photos
  • black shack burger new york location
  • black shack burger new york address
  • black shack burger new york
  • black burger new york
  • black car new york
  • black shack new york
  • black shack burger new york
  • black shack burger a burger joint new york
  • black shack burger: a burger joint new york
  • black shack burger murray hill new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF