Blue Heaven

American Restaurant, Breakfast Spot, and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$
Key West
  • Hande A.
    "Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!!"(26 Tips)
    Jenna P.
    "Try the pork medallion and the key lime pie."(67 Tips)
    "Best key lime pie I've had and Banana Heaven is absolute perfection."(7 Tips)
    Kat N.
    "The yellowtail snapper was amazing!! Great monitors also!!!'"(7 Tips)
335 Tips and reviews
  • key lime pie
  • breakfast food
  • lobster
  • brunch food
  • lively
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Food Network
    Food NetworkOctober 2, 2014
    Blue Heaven Restaurant inspired Jimmy Buffett to write the song “Blue Heaven Rendezvous.” Whether you’re here for musical inspiration or not, the Caribbean cuisine is worth staying for. Read more
  • Kelli T.
    Kelli TolockaOctober 19, 2014
    We loved this place so much we came back three times! Get the key lime pie...I don't even like it and I thought it was delicious! Chicken salad for kind is a great option for a non fish lover!
  • Amanda
    AmandaJanuary 2, 2015
    Omg! So good! AWESOME SETTING & atmosphere. The BLT Benedict is to die for. Shrimp and grits are great as well. Their key lime pie rocks! Mimosas and bloodys are good too. They use fresh squeezed oj.
  • Jeff E.
    Jeff EscalanteJuly 8, 2013
    Without a doubt one of the best restaurants I've been to ever. Beautiful atmosphere and food. Banana bread is incredible, definitely go for the key lime pie as well. Photo is "after" on the pie : )
  • Toni N.
    Toni NapolitanoMarch 2, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Best breakfast on the Island! Be prepared to wait at least an hour but well worth it. Use the time to browse next door at Besame Mucho or hang at the bar & catch some live music.
  • Timothy B.
    Timothy BrewerApril 9, 2013
    Great FOOD & SERVICE. Loved the Key Lime pie. Awesome Benedicts. Blueberry with pecan Pancakes are excellent. And for Key West the prices are reasonable. Plus they often have live entertainment.
  • Julia G.
    Julia GMay 6, 2015
    The atmosphere is relaxing. The food is pricey but worth every penny. The yellowtail snapper is delicious. The cocktails are refreshing as well. Try the Mango Fantango
  • Mercedes S.
    One of my favorite spots in Key West! The food is delicious and the ambiance is great! I recommend it to everyone who has the opportunity to go!
  • Sharon B.
    Loved the Breakfast Tostadas and Lobster BLT. Hour and a half wait on a Sunday morning but with Mimosas Bloody Mary's great music and people it flew right by.
  • Jordan G.
    Jordan GrosecloseNovember 20, 2014
    Best breakfast in Key West! Whatever you order (breakfast..heck, lunch also) you should ask for a side of the famous Key Lime Hollandaise. Spectacular. They are known for their various egg benedicts.
  • Izabela M.
    Izabela MJanuary 22
    Great atmosphere with decent live music. Super long dining wait times. If all you're after is key lime pie and/or drinks, grab a seat at the bar.
  • Heather
    HeatherJuly 31, 2012
    lobster omlette was the best thing i have ever eatten! in my opinion the best restaurant in key west.......Home made bread, relaxing enviroment and friendly wait staff!
  • Oriana S.
    Oriana SequeraAugust 29, 2014
    I got the egg Benedict's with Lobster and Avocado and were delicious!!! Great for breakfast. They also have live music. Nice and relaxed ambiance.
  • bill b.
    bill biskupFebruary 21, 2015
    Had the local lobster special. Made the same as their yellow tail snapper, it was amazing. The cappalenni was great. Their Key Lime pie is good though its meringue, I prefer whipped cream.
  • Marcel P.
    Marcel P.November 23, 2014
    amazing place. lobster benedict is delicious, blueberry pancakes taste like heaven, omelettes are awesome and the staff is fun and super friendly
  • Nina S.
    Nina SundarNovember 5, 2014
    Very great food and service! Friendly atmosphere! My fav breakfast spot in key west! I ordered lobster blt on the homemade white bread. Tried the homemade banana bread so soft & sweet!!!
  • Kathy E.
    Kathy EvansMay 25, 2015
    If you want a casual (and shady) outdoor cafe, this is the place to go! Get there early and be sure to try the mahi mahi ! Caprese salad was yummy but overpriced, good selection of wines.
  • Rachel S.
    Rachel SwendsrudMarch 27, 2014
    The best food i had the whole week on vacation. All the deserts melted in your mouth. The key lime pie actually was the best we tried. And the Yellowtail dinner was incredible.
  • Steve H.
    Steve HannemanDecember 14, 2012
    This should be a required stop when visiting Key West. Ate here a couple of times this week. Lobster benedict, yellowtail snapper, key lime pie, mimosas, mojitos and banana heaven were all fantastic.!
  • courtney c.
    courtney choateFebruary 21
    Very busy on a Saturday morning. Banana bread was delicious, though my omelette and the dropped eggs appeared rushed in the kitchen. Service was great and fun atmosphere.
  • Renee B.
    Renee BogaczMarch 30, 2013
    My very favorite place on the entire planet! Try the eggs Benedict with lime hollandaise sauce, Key West pink shrimp, and grilled asparagus. This place is (Blue) Heaven on Earth!
  • Charlie B.
    Charlie BuscemiOctober 20, 2012
    the most amazing breakfast. The Lobster Benedict is to die for. The blueberry pancakes are foodgasmic, careful though...the blueberries are so juicy they'll squirt and make you squirt.
  • Zach Aarons
    Zach AaronsJanuary 21, 2012
    I would give four petals for the desserts: banana bread and key lime pie, and two petals for the main dishes: yellowtail snapper and shrimp. The atmosphere is relaxed. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • David G.
    David GilesJanuary 22, 2012
    Wait is usually long, but definitely worth it! Everyone congregates on one side of the bar - go to the back side for shorter service lines and open seating in a garden setting. Great Bloody Mary's!
  • Hande A.
    Hande AksoySeptember 4
    Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!! You won't regret!! Super lovely place, nice garden..
  • Mary Frances
    Mary FrancesMay 30, 2013
    Vegetarian Alert: Best grilled cheese I've had with tomato, arugula, and avocado. They also have vegetarian black bean soup and platter with tofu on the lunch menu.
  • Daniel J.
    Daniel JonesMarch 25
    The white cheddar shrimp and grits was incredible! We had a 2 hour wait, but it was well worth it. We just sat at the bar having some mimosas :)
  • Leo O.
    Leo OliveiraApril 30, 2013
    Amazing place to chill, get brunch and play ping-pong! Order Lobster-Shrimp Benedict and their ridiculous Key-Lime Pie
  • Kathryn
    KathrynAugust 6, 2012
    Great place for breakfast! Outdoors under the trees. Chickens running around make it fun. Lobster Benedict and the shrimp and grits...yum! Must go when in Key West!
  • Jill
    JillAugust 23, 2013
    Brunch with the roosters!! Lobster Benedict ~ dont ask the $ just get it!!! ;) key lime pie ~ no matter how full you are just get it ~ you can always share! MUST experience while in Key West!!
  • Stacey R.
    Stacey RussMay 21, 2011
    Get there early for breakfast. (Crowded with extended wait times by 10am) Breakfast and atmosphere is something you won't want to miss while in Key West. Neat little gift shop & homemade bread.
  • Alice Eunjin
    Alice EunjinDecember 3, 2015
    Great food! Esp the lobster eggs Benedict, side pancakes and side ham! But be prepared for a wait
  • Brian U.
    Brian UnverzagtJanuary 30, 2015
    2nd best key lime pie I've had food is wonderful cool music but be ready to reservations
  • Demetri T.
    Demetri TsigssJuly 16, 2015
    The lemon meringue key lime pie is quite good...if you like it that way. Breakfast is great. We especially enjoyed the very moist banana bread.
  • Steve J.
    Steve JohnsonSeptember 10, 2013
    Great prices. The pancakes are huge and very good. If you plan to eat them, don't order anything else. Great service and cool even on a hot day.
  • Amy S.
    Amy SullivanJanuary 9, 2015
    Always a couples hours wait. I don't know if it's worth it. I've always gone next door to the French place which has amazing food.
  • Stout D.
    Stout DivaJuly 21, 2015
    The pork tenderloin is amazing, one of the best meals I have ever had, a definite must!!!
  • Jenna P.
    Jenna PapakalosJuly 30, 2012
    OMFG! Every plate will be empty. Food is amazing! Try the pork medallion and the key lime pie. Just outstanding.
  • Dmitry P.
    Desserts: Lime Pie and Banana Heaven were good. As for the main dishes, only yellowtail was good enough and all the 3 others (chicken, pasta, BBQ shrimps) were not exiting at all. Ordinary place
  • Stacey H.
    Stacey HerronMarch 26, 2013
    My mostly vegetarian child requested a steak (featured on the kids menu) and loved it. Came with corn bread, potatoes, green beans and corn.
  • Jessica B.
    The snapper and scallops are both unbelievable. Best meal I've ever had in key west hands down. The key lime pie is sure not to disappoint
  • Shirley L.
    Shirley LauSeptember 3
    Lobster Benedict and key lime pie!! Pancake portions are huge, should've shared one instead of two ;)
  • Ben S.
    Ben SpiesMay 10
    Best place I've been to for mimosas and breakfast in key west. Omelette are great. Make a reservation or wait at least an hour.
  • Joseph L.
    Joseph LJune 30
    The vibe is super cool and fun. The food was mediocre. I had to send back my lobster benedict, the lobster was inedible rubber. The blueberry pancakes were delicious though.
  • Courtney
    CourtneyMay 26, 2015
    Yummy brunch. Add avocado to the lobster Benedict! Get a blueberry pancake!
  • Dori G.
    Dori GehlingDecember 6, 2010
    Our breakfast was outstanding...everyone was happy. The character of the place was great. We got there early enough to miss the line but I can't imagine thinking less of it if I had to wait.
  • Karin B.
    Karin BäcklundJanuary 7, 2014
    Great southern american food! The Key lime pie is big enough for sharing.
  • Ashley M.
    Ashley M.December 21, 2012
    I wasn't blown away by the breakfast food, just as good as our hotel (La Te Da)... But the outdoor seating provides a really nice atmosphere.
  • Patrick K.
    Patrick KeaneDecember 1, 2010
    Start with a key west lemonade, have Scallop special appetizer, jerk chicken, pork loin, or snapper special for dinner & finish it off with the dessert in the world! Banana Heaven!
  • Monica V.
    Monica VAugust 26
    Market price - ask first. Unless money is no object, it will be a pricey meal so be prepared. But really good food! Bloody Marys underwhelmed though.
1,398 Photos

Related Searches

  • blue heaven key west
  • blue heaven key west photos
  • blue heaven key west location
  • blue heaven key west address
  • blue heaven key west
  • blue heaven key west
  • blue heaven bordello key west
  • blue heaven restaurant key west
  • my blue heaven key west
  • rickys blue heaven key west

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF