Blue Highway: a pizzeria

Blue Highway Pizza

Pizza Place and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Newberry
Save
Share
8.4/10
68
ratings
  • Ahmed S.
    "Whether it's the Greek pizza or chicken piadine, it's delicious."(4 Tips)
    Cathleen R.
    "Blue Highway salad and Hummchetta are to die for.....'nuff said."(2 Tips)
    Delia K.
    "The corn bisque and the bbq chicken pizza was amazing!"(4 Tips)
    Brittany H.
    "somewhat small in Tioga"(2 Tips)
30 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • piadine
  • good for dates
  • great value
  • healthy food
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Peggy D.
    Peggy DorvilJanuary 31
    Name it and it's good; everything is made from scratch , but I'm a huge fan of their mouth-watering spinach and brie flatbread; includes bacon and a delicious balsamic glaze
  • Cathleen R.
    Cathleen RodgersAugust 17, 2015
    Blue Highway salad and Hummchetta are to die for.....'nuff said.
  • Lauren N.
    Lauren NicoleJune 21, 2015
    Homemade potato chips are the bomb! Pizza Lombardi is oily but probably just the nature of the prosciutto. BBQ Chicken Pizza is tasty. Nice atmosphere, but can be slow at times. Ask for Danni.
    Upvoted 2 weeks ago
  • Brittany H.
    Brittany HicksonApril 11, 2015
    Pizza is delicious. The place is somewhat small in Tioga, but it is definitely worth that wait.
  • Nelson
    NelsonFebruary 16, 2015
    The food is good but prices are a bit high. Then again you are in town of Tioga. Should serve garlic rolls or similar with purchase. Service is a bit slow but steady. Not the best in town but not bad.
  • Delia K.
    Delia KJune 21, 2014
    The corn bisque and the bbq chicken pizza was amazing! :)
  • Ben J.
    Ben JilekMay 31, 2014
    Get the specials each night
  • Ahmed S.
    Ahmed SamirMarch 14, 2014
    Whether it's the Greek pizza or chicken piadine, it's delicious. The Tuscan fries are also excellent.
  • Mackenzie C.
    Mackenzie CarterJune 7, 2013
    Best Pizza ever, I love the environment my favorite is Buffalo Chicken Sicilian! Best Pizza place around!
  • Bill R.
    Bill RadunovichMay 12, 2013
    We had the gnocchi special tonight - it was one of the best Italian dishes we've ever had. That includes Little Italy in NY, and Big Italy in . . . Italy! Very delicious!
  • Jordan F.
    Jordan FineApril 25, 2013
    BBQ Chicken Pizza. THAT'S WHAT'S UP!
  • Kristina
    KristinaDecember 16, 2012
    Try the weekly specials, they are always good!
  • Melanie
    MelanieNovember 3, 2012
    Get the roasted beet salad !!! Please make this a permanent addition to the menu.
  • Bill R.
    Bill RadunovichOctober 23, 2012
    The Blue Highway salad is my favorite (salad). The candied pecans really make it!
  • Emily O.
    Emily O'HearnSeptember 21, 2012
    I love their mints!
  • Megan H.
    Megan HumphreyJuly 9, 2012
    Gave it two tries and won't be back. Bit into sand on my last carry-out order of the vegetable calzone, washing vegetables for any restaurant is a must!
  • Mikayla K.
    Mikayla KustinJanuary 22, 2012
    I don't recommend coming here if you are flexible. They are not. Food is fine but don't expect them to help you with special requests.
  • Allen V.
    Allen VinsonJanuary 14, 2012
    Just got here but our waitress is great, she seems to really know the menu and what you may or may not like, great service
  • Mackenzie C.
    Mackenzie CarterDecember 2, 2011
    Buffalo Chicken is the best pizza here. My Favorite...
  • Roberta N.
    Roberta NoronhaNovember 29, 2011
    Make ur own pizza! Try pesto w/ fontina, gorgonzola, fresh mozzarella, basil & tomatoes! A must have!
  • Heather S.
    Heather SarkisSeptember 4, 2011
    Yea! So glad they have gluten-free pizza!
  • Kathleen S.
    Kathleen SeideAugust 1, 2011
    I love the Turkey Piadine! Fold it over and eat it like a sandwich.
  • Barbara P.
    Barbara ParedesJune 21, 2011
    BBQ Chicken pizza is amazing!!!!!
  • Kathleen S.
    Kathleen SeideJune 1, 2011
    Turkey Piadine is amazing. It is kinda like a salad in a flat bread, except that adding the toasty warm flatbread bring so much goodness to it that it becomes, well, amazing : )
  • Teddybear
    TeddybearMay 15, 2011
    Great Piadine! Yum! Good wings and unique pizza toppings
  • Kasey B.
    Kasey BieleckiApril 14, 2011
    The calamari appetizer leaves something to be desired. It was very bland and extremely tough. The pizza however is always good.
  • Mackenzie C.
    Mackenzie CarterMarch 4, 2011
    Buffalo chicken is amazing!!!
  • Vivek S.
    Vivek SurtiFebruary 9, 2011
    Awesome pizza, Awesome crust! Love the Greek pizza!
  • Michael W.
    Michael WatsonJanuary 16, 2011
    Love the BBQ Chicken!
  • E P.
    E PSeptember 24, 2010
    Delicious pizza!
41 Photos