People tend to check in during these times:
Amazing staff, and even better ice cream! The raspberry cheesecake ice cream mixed with the cookies and cream (as suggested by the staff) was to die for! Tastes like and Oreo crusted cheesecake.
Excellent homemade ice creams! Try the salted chocolate caramel pretzel (I forget exactly what it's called but it's damn good).
Salted Carmel pretzel ice cream
Real deal ice cream. Try the coffee/espresso/ice cream shake and stay awake for days.
Their vanilla chip ice cream is a nice try.
Mostly unimpressed with their ice cream flavors but the Cubby Crunch is a great original.
Ice cream is delightful. Can get busy. Outdoor seats are available to sit and enjoy.
Unique shop with quality ice cream. Try the brownie sundae
My fave!!! They deliver!!!
Ice cream and malts are delicious!!
have their red wine ice cream! LOVE LOVE IT! this is the best place for homemade ice cream!
Get a scoop of the Cubby Crunch. You won't be disappointed.
The best ice cream!!! They run out of flavors often in the summer and on the weekends, so try to come at an off time if you're looking for something specific
Cubby Crunch = Vanilla ice cream, chocolate chips, toffee, Oreo, and rainbow sprinkles
Tried the Signature sunset and lake view bar hopper. They were ok. Go to pacuigo's gelato down the street instead!
It's who you know, free double scoop waffle cone:)
Get the Daley addiction. Damn good.
Great old-school Ice Cream shop with unique Chicago-themed flavors that should all be sampled! The line can be long - but it moves fast!
Great Peanut Chip Ice Cream:)
Basically the greatest. Signature Sunset is not to be missed.
Cubby crunch. Yummy!
The chai latte is delicious for when it's chilly outside.
The pumpkin ice cream is SO freakin' delicious!!!!!
Pretty righteous pumpkin pie sundae
Great ice cream and awesome employees!
The milkshakes are so thick that you can hardly get them up through a straw--so delicious!
Their ice cream is the best in the City, but their Wi-Fi splash screen will drive you nuts! It even comes up on my iPhone when I turn off Wi-Fi in my settings.
Great ice cream spot!!!
Peanut butter chip is the best flavor BY FAR. Unique homemade ice cream
Delicious unique ice cream! Try their seasonal ice cream!
CUBBY CRUNCH. Fandom of Chicago Cubs not required (thank goodness).
The Italian ice is a big hit for summer. Red raspberry or strawberry lemonade. Both are delicious!
Not worth being ignored.
One of a handful of always available flavors at this ice cream shop, Signature Sunset is a genius combination of Merlot ice cream and dark chocolate chips.
PB&J shake is great!
Cubbie Crunch is AMAZING!
Absolutely no advantage to being the Mayor.
White chocolate peanut butter ice cream is amazing, and a perk of being slower in the winter...they'll give you as many samples as you want!
I prefer Cubby Crunch or Mint Chip, but you really can't go wrong with anything. Plus they have board games!
Whichever flavor you choose, get an Oreo dipped waffle cone with it.
Pumpkin Pie Sundae. Just eat it.
Shakes & Smoothies for $2.99 on Thursdays. Spencer made me the BEST smoothie of my life!
Bobtail Ice Cream Company is nominated for Best Ice Cream Shop in our Hipsqueak Awards, vote now at timeoutchicagokids.com/awards!
Cookies and Cream for the Occupiers!
Tue/Thu half off milkshakes
You'll never find another ice cream flavor as good and as classy as the Signature Sunset: merlot ice cream with dark chocolate chips. Amazing!