Brennan & Carr

Sandwich Place, Soup Place, and American Restaurant$$$$
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
Save
Share
8.6/10
280
ratings
  • Go here. Experience the roast beef. It's worth it.
  • The experts at Eater and Village Voice recommend this place
    • Eater
    • Village Voice
  • Mike C.
    "Gargiulo burger = burger with roast beef on top awesome!!!"(9 Tips)
    Assunta C.
    "Will be coming back to try the roast beef sandwich!"(16 Tips)
    Julianne A.
    "amazing roast beef with cheese..."(5 Tips)
    Thomas K.
    "blueberry pie A+++++☆☆☆☆"(2 Tips)
102 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • roast beef
  • burgers
  • cheeseburgers
  • french fries
  • chowder
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Ed H.
    Hot Beef - fork and knife style!
  • Ylenia Z.
    Ylenia ZiniJanuary 24
    Huge plates with vegetables, fries and hamburger. Cheap and so American! 🇺🇸
  • Ben G.
    Ben GaspariniAugust 15, 2016
    Cool man v food spot w/the gargiulo burger.
  • Fernando A.
    Fernando AlcázarJuly 25, 2016
    Roast beef at its finest is right.
  • Eater
    EaterJuly 22, 2016
    The signature dish at this beloved Gravesend institution is a Kaiser roll full of a roast beef that's liberally doused in a thin, salty liquid known as "the broth." Read more
  • James R.
    James ReganApril 15, 2016
    KFJ = knife and fork job. Meat dipped then the sandwich is dipped, then the beef broth is poured over it. My favorite way to get it, don't forget to ask for onions as well.
  • Louie L.
    Louie LouieMarch 26, 2016
    You have to be your own judge. But the Roast Beef sandwich is king!
  • KaiMaliLani
    KaiMaliLaniMarch 23, 2016
    Roast beef was delish!! DOUBLE DIP it!! You will regret it if you don't!
  • Debbie M.
    Debbie MacMarch 6, 2016
    Pies for dessert were good. Roast beef was not as good as I expected.. I'll stick to Arby's.
  • Marina D.
    Marina DolgovaFebruary 14, 2016
    It's cash only
  • tolu
    toluJanuary 31, 2016
    great food, friendly staff but the onion rings weren't that good
  • Nana S.
    Nana SeidovaJanuary 18, 2016
    Great food and love the ppl who work here
  • leo k.
    leo kyivJanuary 8, 2016
    Nice place.
  • Melanie N.
    Melanie Natale BrownDecember 15, 2015
    Roast beef is great
  • Matty C.
    Matty CitoSeptember 14, 2015
    Double dipped. Eat it the counter
  • Carmen N.
    Carmen NAugust 29, 2015
    Old school and authentic. Roast beef, beef broth for dipping.
  • Jason
    JasonAugust 4, 2015
    Great roast beef sandwich
  • Lyudmila G.
    Lyudmila G.July 12, 2015
    Dmdle Dipped Roast Beef !!!
  • Jake C.
    Jake CohenJune 15, 2015
    Best beef in BK
  • Brian M.
    Brian MurrayJune 6, 2015
    Hot beef with cheese, double dipped, as close to heaven as you can get when you're hungry!
  • Michael N.
    Michael NagarJune 6, 2015
    Good but not worth the hype.
  • Bjørn L.
    Bjørn LateMay 3, 2015
    If this is is what Arby's is supposed to be, I now totally understand Arby's!
  • Village Voice
    Village VoiceApril 9, 2015
    Order a Gargiulo burger here. Credit goes to the Russo brothers of Coney Island's Gargiulo's, who first plunked a helping of roast beef onto their cheeseburgers before dipping them in jus.
  • Robert P.
    Robert PupkoApril 2, 2015
    Roast beef, double dipped.
  • alxxrt
    alxxrtMarch 8, 2015
    try the Garguilos #Burger
  • Greco L.
    Greco LegaspiMarch 1, 2015
    Awesome roast beef sandwich
  • Kristina M.
    Kristina MFebruary 16, 2015
    Roast beef, broth on the side! Avoid the soggy bun
  • Thomas K.
    Thomas KellyNovember 11, 2014
    Roast Beef Roast beef and Roast beef, also burgers and Hot dogs and fries Try the blueberry pie A+++++☆☆☆☆☆
  • Jason T.
    Jason TanzerNovember 4, 2014
    Roast Beef Sandwich with Sautéed Onions and melted cheese
  • Mike L.
    Mike LicariOctober 4, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Everything
  • TV Food Maps
    TV Food MapsAugust 26, 2014
    Check out Brennan Read more
  • Mubarak A.
    Mubarak AhmedAugust 7, 2014
    Roast Beef sandwich dipped twice!
  • Craig B.
    Craig BlockJuly 30, 2014
    Great food & service. Highly recommend the roast beef burger!
  • Kelly K.
    Kelly KelleyJuly 18, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Put a couple of onion rings on your beef sandwich.
  • Erik C.
    Erik CintronJune 22, 2014
    Old simple joint, with a 1 page menu. There famous for there roast beef which the whole sandwich is dipped in a broth. Amazing! It was mixed of families & locals. Great prices. Has parking & 2$ buds!
  • Sophia P.
    Sophia PorterMay 28, 2014
    It has a cute little to go bar by the B3 bus.
  • Petra T.
    Petra TseMay 9, 2014
    Always ask to have the bread soak in the broth for the roast beef sandwich :-) yummmm
  • Sophia P.
    Sophia PorterApril 26, 2014
    The to-go station in front of the bus stop: suuuuuper convenient!
  • Joseph C.
    Joseph CaputoApril 11, 2014
    Avoid sitting at the table in the far right corner nearest the emergency exit and the trash disposal slot.
  • Erica K.
    Erica KirshApril 6, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
    Beef with cheese double dipped
  • R F.
    R FigApril 4, 2014
    Roast beef sandwich. Thats what they are known for. Yes it was a very good sandwich
  • Stacy C.
    Stacy CybulskaMarch 10, 2014
    They changed companies that they use to purchase their rolls. Not the same. :(
  • Kev S.
    Kev SkinnyDecember 17, 2013
    I give respect when respects due. I can see how this was popular 100 yrs ago. For modern day...mediocre. I had a better beef dip at quiznos. Badabing badaboom. Roasted.
  • Chrissy B.
    Chrissy BNovember 3, 2013
    Simply the best roast beef sandwich I've EVER had. Beats Roll N Roaster any day!
  • Carolina P.
    Carolina PokidayloOctober 6, 2013
    To the guy that sees Brennan & Carr through his living room window - close your shades! Good god man.
  • Mike C.
    Mike CombatOctober 4, 2013
    Gargiulo burger = burger with roast beef on top awesome!!!
  • Mike C.
    Mike ChauSeptember 14, 2013
    Try the Gargiulo Burger - Amazing. Maybe a little soggy with that dip though.
  • Mike C.
    Mike ChauSeptember 14, 2013
    Try the Roast Beef Sandwich - Awesome
  • Christopher M.
    Christopher McAteeSeptember 10, 2013
    Classic roast beef. Awesome!
  • Erica H S.
    Erica H SchwartzAugust 8, 2013
    Fifteen dollars
  • Paul D.
    Paul DunnAugust 5, 2013
    Try the Roast Beef "double dip"
  • Paul D.
    Paul DunnAugust 5, 2013
    Try the French Fries
  • Paul D.
    Paul DunnAugust 5, 2013
    Try the Onion Rings
  • amNewYork
    amNewYorkJuly 21, 2013
    Around for 75 years, the cash-only establishment is known for its roast beef sandwiches, with both bread and beef double-dipped in a salty broth, and patrons praise the onion rings.
  • Assunta C.
    Assunta CatalanoJuly 12, 2013
    Soooo good! First time there, had the most delicious cheeseburger ever! Will be coming back to try the roast beef sandwich!
  • Josephine Z.
    Josephine ZhuMay 31, 2013
    Go for the Blueberry pie, ask for it piping' hot. You know you want to. :)
  • Andre M.
    Andre MaheMay 25, 2013
    Awesom gotta have my fix of roast beef
  • Jonathan L.
    Jonathan L.May 23, 2013
    Don't waste getting the cheese on the sandwich, it doesn't add any flavor.
  • John G.
    John GerenaApril 29, 2013
    Always double dip ! Nom nom nom
  • Catherine R.
    Catherine RitortoApril 9, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    this place has not changed except it got better Not like it was ever bad This place reminds you of home and really great food a simple menu This place should be on the show diners drive ins and dives
  • David K.
    David KaplanApril 1, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the Roast Beef "double dip"
  • Kris N.
    Kris N.March 21, 2013
    The menu is on the wall by the AC unit.
  • Louis Philip R.
    Louis Philip Rotkowitz, MD, FAAFPMarch 12, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    The Waiter Chris - AKA - "The Greek Kid" is the best; Foud was amazing tonight; well down and done dipped. Excellent Fries and Union Rings!
  • Shane N.
    Shane N.February 19, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    The Gargiulo burger will never steer you wrong.
  • Kirk T.
    Kirk ThousandDecember 4, 2012
    The beef needs more seasoning
  • Victor H.
    Victor HerreraNovember 18, 2012
    Gargiulo Burger dipped with cheese and onions... Mouth watering combination, a must do on any NYC culinary tour!
  • David K.
    David KaplanJuly 14, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the Roast Beef "double dip" - Very hot, very soggy, very, very good.
  • Josh L.
    Josh LangstonJune 30, 2012
    Try the Roast Beef Sandwich
  • Jason 6.
    Jason 64128May 31, 2012
    Established 1938. Owned by family of early employees. Tudor-style building with aged brick and wood-paneled interior. Known for its thin-sliced roast beef, served on a Kaiser roll with pan drippings.
  • Lee D.
    Lee DavidApril 16, 2012
    this place sucks ass roll n roastr is way way way better
  • JAO B.
    JAO BurgosMarch 15, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Chicken wings are insane! Try the burger platter if you're really hungry, and feel no guilt :)
  • David K.
    David KaplanMarch 4, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the Roast Beef "double dip" - Savory and artery-clogging food at its apex
  • Charles E.
    Charles EdgeJanuary 22, 2012
    Best roast beef in Brooklyn!
  • Benjamin H.
    Benjamin HaasJanuary 8, 2012
    Beef & cheese double dip and a pint of beer. Lunch of champions.
  • amoolia
    amooliaDecember 17, 2011
    Good, simple hot beef sandwiches but to make the trip out here worth it get the Gargiulo Burger. Cheesy beefy goodness.
  • Heather
    HeatherNovember 13, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Love this place! Delicious fast and always chilled crowd no matter how busy it is
  • Daniel R.
    Daniel RosinskyOctober 27, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    I can see Brennan & Carr from my living room window......maybe that's why I'm so huge!
  • Gene A.
    Gene AndersenSeptember 20, 2011
    Been here 50+ times
    Have the Gargiulo Burger, it's a combo of cheeseburger and roast beef. Tell them to leave off the fried onions.
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsAugust 24, 2011
    Roast Beef: Try the dipped version w/o cheese to get the unadulterated flavor of the beefy stock. The flavor was fantastic and the beef was sliced paper-thin and very tender. Read more
  • Richard K.
    Richard KichenamaAugust 15, 2011
    Most awesome waffles Read more
  • Terrence C.
    Terrence CummiskeyJuly 31, 2011
    Food is good but the sandwiches are small. I went with the double dip, getting it with cheese and side of broth is a must. French Fries are nothing special.
  • lucyfer
    lucyferJuly 10, 2011
    Roast Beef Sandwich + Cheese + Grilled Onions + Cup of Beef Broth (for dipping) = Awesome!
  • Karla Samantha
    Karla SamanthaMay 5, 2011
    Best onion rings ever!
  • jacqueliinee
    jacqueliineeApril 4, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    came all over the place after one bite .
  • jacqueliinee
    jacqueliineeApril 4, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    I don't even like roast beef but I'll travel all the way from long island to get a beef and chee double dip from this place any day !
  • Andy S.
    Andy SinghMarch 31, 2011
    You have to try this place if your around! Amazing roast beef sandwich!!
  • Timothy R.
    Timothy ReedMarch 12, 2011
    Don't need to ask then to dip yr sandwich. It's dipped by default.
  • Dishling NYC
    Dishling NYCJanuary 30, 2011
    The Roast Beef Sandwich is the 2nd most popular in NYC (behind This Little Piggy Had Roast Beef on 1st ave in Manhattan).
  • Michael Z.
    Michael ZahraDecember 12, 2010
    I can't imagine what the world would be like without the comfort of B&C..
  • Travel Channel
    Travel ChannelDecember 6, 2010
    Why did it take me so long to have one of the legendary Gargiulo Burger? Nothing goes better with beef than mo’ beef. – Adam Richman, Man v. Food Read more
  • Donald S.
    Donald SOctober 29, 2010
    All I've had here was the roast beef. I really don't know what all fuss is about. It was VERY dry and bland. Not to mention pricier than Rollnroasters (which is 10x better). Go to RnR for a real sand.
  • Michael C.
    Michael C.September 14, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Be adventurous. Eat in and ask for a "KFJ". Keep a napkin handy! Rollin Roaster has nothin on these guys.
  • Joe D.
    Joe DeCanioJune 30, 2010
    Great Food. Best Roast Beef in the City. Beef with Cheese Dipped or Double Dipped - you cant go wrong. If you are hungry get the Gargiulo.
  • Bauzen
    BauzenJune 9, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    Got the double-dipped roast beef sandwich. Meat was soft and melts in your mouth. It's the perfect sandwich, but next time, I'm going to ask for it with cheese. Also gotta try the burger eventually.
  • Adam S.
    Adam SherlipJune 7, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    Double dip beef with cheese!
  • JAO B.
    JAO BurgosMay 29, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    A+ roast beef and cheeseburgers!
  • David M.
    David MApril 30, 2010
    Everything there is great, get the Beef Broth on the side of the Roast Beef ;-)
  • Jasmyne
    JasmyneApril 27, 2010
    Amazing fries!!!
  • Carlo C.
    Carlo CostanzoMarch 27, 2010
    Get your cheeseburger dipped! You qont regret it!
  • Julianne A.
    Julianne ArcarioMarch 16, 2010
    I grew up eating here.. most amazing roast beef with cheese... good chicken fingers too!
252 Photos

Related Searches

  • brennan & carr brooklyn
  • brennan & carr brooklyn photos
  • brennan & carr brooklyn location
  • brennan & carr brooklyn address
  • brennan & carr brooklyn
  • brennan & carr brooklyn
  • brennan and carr brooklyn
  • brennan and carr restaurant brooklyn
  • brennon and carr brooklyn
  • brennan & carr sheepshead bay brooklyn

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF