Planning a trip to Chicago?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Brewster's Italian Café

Italian Restaurant$$$$
New Buffalo
Save
Share
8.6/10
63
ratings
  • Codi L.
    "Love their olive oil based pizza and tri-cheese tortilinni"(8 Tips)
    Corinne
    "And don't miss dessert and coffee... some of the best coffee around!"(7 Tips)
    Olga P.
    "Enjoyed Bellini with delicious crab cakes and rustic steak salad."(2 Tips)
    Dennis K.
    "best outdoor dining spaces"(3 Tips)
27 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • outdoor seating
  • crab cakes
  • rustic
  • cookies
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Gregory H.
    Gregory H.June 28, 2015
    Super friendly staff. The roasted red pepper florentine soup is delicious! They have indoor and outdoor seating, including a great sun room inside and flame heaters outside when it's cool.
  • David W.
    David WeathersbyNovember 10, 2014
    Nice intimate cafe in New Buffalo.
  • Devon N.
    Devon NicholsAugust 5, 2014
    "Dinner for 2" special: Amazeballs!!! 2-topping pizza PLUS any dinner entree with 2 soups or salads PLUS cookies and coffee for dessert = $35. WOW!
  • Lisa B.
    Lisa BrumbaughAugust 4, 2014
    Sea Bass was absolutely incredible!
  • Scott S.
    Scott SpiekJune 27, 2014
    Queens caprese salad.. Nuff said, get it
  • Sam B.
    Sam BearAugust 3, 2013
    Beware: the Roma tortellini pasta is HEAVY on garlic. Bring mints, Listerine, vampires, etc.
  • Rachel P.
    Rachel PlankJune 29, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    It's Chicagoan gridlock in the summer, but we'll worth the hassle. In the winter, cozy up with your honey, and get the Dinner for Two.
  • Olga P.
    Olga PadillaJune 6, 2013
    Enjoyed Bellini with delicious crab cakes and rustic steak salad. Amazing food and dining al fresco . Can't wait to go back .
  • Janis E.
    Janis EtzcornMarch 10, 2013
    Good food and service. We split the Queen Margherita antipasti and two topping pizza (sausage and mushrooms). Just right for a light dinner for the two of us. Pizza had great crust and good flavors.
  • Travis S.
    Travis StachlewitzNovember 18, 2012
    Amazing food and awesome service. I wouldn't hesitate to come back any time.
  • Codi L.
    Codi LandessOctober 15, 2012
    Love their olive oil based pizza and tri-cheese tortilinni
  • Nicolette H.
    Nicolette HowardOctober 4, 2012
    Dinner for two was an overwhelmingly great deal. Plus, the food was great! The apple cookie was to die for
  • Shannon M.
    Shannon MulcahySeptember 9, 2012
    Dinner for 2 is the way to go! You won't go hone hungry. Plus the pizza is like REAL Italian pizza!
  • Louis P.
    Louis PriceAugust 15, 2012
    Dinner for 2 is a great deal and so is the food. Patio in good weather just adds to the enjoyment.
  • John K.
    John KnightMarch 18, 2012
    The Chicken Florintine Soup is incredible.
  • Julie F.
    Julie FMarch 5, 2012
    Try the Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie
  • Julie F.
    Julie FMarch 5, 2012
    Try the Crab Cakes With Red Pepper Remoulade
  • Tim R.
    Tim RFebruary 29, 2012
    Excellent pizzas!
  • Kelly C.
    Kelly Coyle- ShikanyJanuary 28, 2012
    Great tiramisu. And the house dressing is terrific
  • Corinne
    CorinneNovember 8, 2011
    Great food, great service! Ashley rocks! And don't miss dessert and coffee... some of the best coffee around!
  • Kelly C.
    Kelly Coyle- ShikanyOctober 21, 2011
    White chocolate macadamian cookies--perfect finish! Also great tiramisu
  • Maribeth H.
    Maribeth HearnOctober 16, 2011
    Dara is great server. Get spinach artichoke dip. One of the best Italian meals I've had.
  • Pamela C.
    Pamela CarpenterAugust 7, 2011
    Call ahead to be seated faster!
  • Dennis K.
    Dennis KellermeierJune 11, 2011
    Brewster's has one of the best outdoor dining spaces that I have seen.
  • Mike M.
    Mike MilesMay 2, 2011
    Can't wait to go!!
  • Nicole Y.
    Nicole YoungAugust 21, 2010
    Great spot! Menu changes daily. Staff is excellent - friendly - and accomodating.
  • Michelle M.
    Michelle MillerJuly 31, 2010
    Dinner for two is amazing!!!
32 Photos

Related Searches

  • brewster's italian café new buffalo
  • brewster's italian café new buffalo photos
  • brewster's italian café new buffalo location
  • brewster's italian café new buffalo address
  • brewster's italian café new buffalo
  • brewster's italian cafe new buffalo
  • brewster's italian café new buffalo
  • brewsters new buffalo
  • brewsters italian cafe new buffalo
  • brewsters italian café new buffalo

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF