By far, the best pies in New York. Blueberry cream or strawberry rhubarb won't leave you disappointed.
Peach creme pies..
Their pies!! Omg!! Apple is my favorite!
Cookies best ever
Pies, pies, pies! Chocolate cream was heavenly! Be ready to wait on line for your pie when you get there (line will go fast though)
Get the pie. All the pie. In particular the raspberry and peach pie.
Their pies are so good. And they're stuffed with fruit!! You're definitely getting your money's worth.
Amazing blueberry cream pie and egg bread!!
Strawberry rhubarb pie and lots of fresh veggies 😍
Strawberry pie. Amazing. Have yet to try the strawberry cream pie but I hear it's to die for!
The BEST pies I have EVER had in my Life. Worth every single cent ! ONLY Briemere Pies !!!
Get the pies. All the pies.
Incredible pies. Don't forget the cookies and muffins either!
Not only great pies but awesome local produce too. Hellooooo heirloom tomato season
Day-old pies are half the price but just as delicious!
Cream pies are awesome!
THE best pies.
Paid $22 for a chocolate cream pie here, it was worth $88.
The chocolate cream pies are to die for!
The gold standard in pie! Be sure to try the blueberry muffins
Raspberry Cream Pie-hands down. Also love the pumpkin squares!
Must try pumpkin square and apple cider.
Chocolate chip cookies! The best!
Best custard pies on Earth, Especially the Peach Custard. Order ahead so you know they'll have your pie because they run out real fast
Everything is good. The pies, the cookies, the syrup...so yummy. Make sure to get there early in the warm seasons!
Pies made that day with the freshest ingredients. Large selection $16+ The best cherry pie I ever had. Highly recommended if you're in the neighborhood.
They close by six.
The coconut pie is really good!!!
If rhubarbs are in season, you NEED to try the rhubarb squares.
Everything here is ridiculous! EVERYTHING! You can't go wrong! I can't share with you my favorite because I need to be sure it's still here when I get here. LOVE this place!!!!!!
The best apple puffs on the planet!!!
Be prepared to wait: Long lines for the pies/jams.
They often have the second door open for pies and goodies, look for it and avoid the long lines
Fresh fruits cream pies are the best
Try the raspberry cream pie! Tip buy two because one won't make the ride back!
Blueberry pie is the best!
The apple cider is godly.
The chocolate cream pie and raspberry cream pies are the best you will ever have!
all about the blackberry apple pie.
Get there early and grab a pie!
Best pies ever!!
Pie!! Perfect stop during a day of wine tasting. Pumpkin squares are giggle inducing delicious
rhubarb pie is amazing.
Blueberry cream pie. Best in the buisness.
Try the raspberry cream and pumpkin pie!
Try the blueberry créme ... O M G!
The Apple Crisp pie is amazing, but wish they would bring back the Blueberry Crisp. Be sure to grab a bag of their chocolate chip cookies as well!
Strawberry rhubarb pie rules. Raspberry cream pie, if you don't have to travel, is a must. Jams are a bonus...