Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

(Now Closed)
BBQ Joint and Sports Bar$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
97 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • John P.
    John PaterakisDecember 31, 2015
    Serious pork, and some serious drinks! Approach with caution.
  • Angelica
    AngelicaDecember 28, 2015
    Wings are simply the best in NYC. Good quality chicken, rub flavor is perfection and not over saucy and the blue cheese dip is chunky the only place I have ever been to get both good wings and sauce.
  • Lisa F.
    Lisa FinnOctober 26, 2015
    Skip the food and go straight for the Swamp Water cocktail served up with ten straws in a literal fishbowl, then drunkenly fight your friends over who gets to keep the toy alligator that comes on top.
  • Bella F.
    Bella FonteOctober 18, 2015
    Coming from a real southern.. We don't put butter on hush puppies..
  • Karsten M.
    Karsten McVayJuly 22, 2015
    A great place to hang with the guys
  • Richard L.
    Richard LueJuly 4, 2015
    Rib combo plate is the best!
  • Lia M.
    Lia MoreggiJune 15, 2015
    Who doesn't love a place that has ski ball
  • Yadira G.
    Yadira GoodingApril 10, 2015
    Pulled pork sandwich is AMAZING!!!
  • Seton
    SetonMarch 19, 2015
    You can't go wrong with brother jimmys, but this one had very limited space. The rest of my experience was good as usual though.
  • Amanda T.
    Amanda TheilerFebruary 27, 2015
    35 Cent Wings Saturdays from 12PM - 4PM
  • Ali A.
    Ali AndersonJanuary 2, 2015
    fishbowls, pulled pork, and PBR. Guaranteed for a fun night watching sports.
  • Ellease R.
    Ellease RoseJanuary 1, 2015
    Food is actually quite solid. Consistently enjoy myself when here for drinks. Good pub/drinks/comfort food option.
  • Lisa L.
    Lisa LSeptember 8, 2014
    Fried chicken and fried chicken sandwich ftw!!!
  • Lou C.
    Lou CuestaAugust 13, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Delicious brisket.
  • Lucia P.
    Lucia PalmieriAugust 2, 2014
    Horrible. I got delivery and the north ribs were reminiscent of a Chinese buffet. I asked for extra pickles and no gravy on the potatoes, they didn't do either. The Mac and cheese was crap. YUCK!
  • Raja H.
    Raja HMay 2, 2014
    (As of May 2014) $16 for all you can eat hot wings and rib tips w/ crappy beer for two hours
  • Jon E.
    Jon EnglishmanApril 1, 2014
    Food average. Potato salad was good though
  • Jonathan R.
    Jonathan RiskFebruary 26, 2014
    Don't let the mayor call the shots on Bingo Tuesdays... 😠
  • Elisabeth S.
    Elisabeth SandovalJuly 27, 2013
    Love this place! Came here all the time. Great staff. Fun people. Def an upper east side gem.
  • Kate L.
    Kate LJuly 10, 2013
    Great bluegrass/country cover band here on Tuesday nights. Fun band members and they take requests.
  • Chris D.
    Chris DanielsJune 9, 2013
    Mrtyle Beach Margarita.. leggooo
  • Shawnie
    ShawnieMay 27, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Do not order the Nag's Head Veggie
  • Jessie W.
    Jessie WMay 16, 2013
    Fishbowl...that's all I have to say.
  • Amanda T.
    Amanda TamborinoMay 8, 2013
    Shannon is amazing!!!!
  • Ron R.
    Ron RosciaMay 2, 2013
    Sweet Baby Tyler & Sober Molly are glorious!
  • Marianne B.
    Marianne BuntApril 22, 2013
    The food was truly amazing and the staff was really nice, but most of all, those COCKTAILS incl. a crocodile toy that can be used as a shot glass, you have to improvise a little, but it's worth it!
  • Robin S.
    Robin SpindelDecember 18, 2012
    Kids eat free - how often do you see that in Manhattan?
  • Andrew L.
    Andrew LugavereNovember 26, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    The pigs pick is so bomb diggity, and the hostess is always hot.
  • Deborah J.
    Deborah JoyceNovember 3, 2012
    The menu today was SEVERELY limited (no ribs, only brisket and chicken) and they don't tell you until after you've sat there for 20 mins & ordered drinks. We paid for our drinks & left.
  • Alyssa M.
    Alyssa McLaughlinSeptember 16, 2012
    The EXACT opposite of good BBQ? Brother Jimmy's. Yuck.
  • Stefanie
    StefanieSeptember 12, 2012
    Frickles and/or fried green tomatoes. Heaven on a plate.
  • George
    GeorgeAugust 13, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Monday nights Is the way to go
  • Adam L.
    Adam LobelJuly 1, 2012
    The fries are terrible, BBQ is good though
  • Michelle C.
    Michelle CucuccioJune 30, 2012
    Loved that my party's table was given away 5 mins before arrival
  • Shawnie
    ShawnieJune 11, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Use the photo booth!
  • Shawnie
    ShawnieMay 30, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Live cover band Tuesday nights.
  • Uciz F.
    Uciz FujiMay 19, 2012
    good place
  • Amanda G.
    Amanda GrubeMay 1, 2012
    You HAVE to get the swamp water!!!!
  • Jonathan H.
    Jonathan HApril 30, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for the manager Mikey DQ and challenge him to a 1 on 1 lacrosse game.
  • Mimi E.
    Mimi EtherApril 29, 2012
    You gotta get the fishbowl and do karaoke!
  • Daniel P.
    Daniel PintoApril 14, 2012
    A must visit...
  • MVQ
    MVQMarch 31, 2012
    Great for nc sports viewing
  • TMO L.
    TMO Loves FootballMarch 18, 2012
    Brad Esarey is the mayor of this place. He doesn't have Foursquare, but he knows everyone! Keep your eyes open
  • Elizabeth P.
    Elizabeth PearsonMarch 7, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    3 Guys 1 Cup on Tuesday nights!! Best band!
  • Chris P.
    Chris PriceFebruary 28, 2012
    Wings are as good as they ever were. Which is awesome.
  • Shawnie
    ShawnieFebruary 4, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Order the spinach and artichoke nacho dip and a fish bowl.
  • Mike W.
    Mike WimsattJanuary 14, 2012
    Wf pw brotherjimmys
  • Charles E.
    Charles EdgeJanuary 14, 2012
    Pulled pork sandwich. Don't spoil it by adding or removing anything. It's awesome!
  • LeRae H.
    LeRae HuntfordDecember 31, 2011
    Drew is the greatest ever!!!
  • New Era Pinstripe Bowl
    New Era Pinstripe BowlDecember 7, 2011
    $2 Bud/Bud Light Drafts, $3 House drinks & $10 Swamp Waters during Pinstripe Bowl Week, Dec. 26-30
304 Photos

Related Searches

  • brother jimmy's bbq new york
  • brother jimmy's bbq new york photos
  • brother jimmy's bbq new york location
  • brother jimmy's bbq new york address
  • brother jimmy's bbq new york
  • brother jimmy's new york
  • brother jimmy's (2nd ave) new york
  • brother jimmy's (e. 77th) new york
  • brother jimmy's - e. 77th new york
  • brother jimmy's - the original new york
  • brother jimmy's bar-b-que new york
  • brother jimmy's bbq new york
  • brother jimmy's bbq - east side new york
  • brother jimmy's original new york
  • brother jimmys new york
  • brother jimmy's bbq upper east side new york

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF