For over 50 years Buttercooky Bakery has served Long Island residents fresh-baked cookies, pastries and cakes.
The rye bread is soooooo good if you go there you have to try is
Italian lace cookies in chocolate is the GOAT
NYGiants Wide Receiver Victor Cruz's game is pretty sweet on and off the field. Here he is sharing a treat from Buttercooky Bakery with his adorable daughter!
Unreal assortment of baked goods. Cakes cookies an pies. You can smell how wonderful everything will taste as soon as you walk in. Very clean very helpful staff.
Great place to fill that sweet tooth
Everything is great here. From the products to the service!!!
Its all good. But bakery cupcakes and pastries have gone way up in price everywhere
Best Bakery Ever
All of my favolite was here.
Lovely place, all the desserts are delicious and just got the orange mouse chocolate ganache birthday cake from here yesterday - absolutely delightful!
Seriously awesome linzer cookies.
This place is amazing... I just did a cake tasting for my wedding and everything was so delicious I had to rethink the cake and have multiple flavors...
Everything is so tasty!! Pick your poison!!
Strawberry short cake is light and amazing ❤❤❤
They spelled my name wrong. Potty is not the same as Patty.
Try the hazelnut chocolate mouse cake!! Omg
The cheese cake is the bomb!! 🎂🎂💦👅💦👅
Everything here is amazing !! Only red velvet I will eat on Long Island
Red velvet is amazballs
The rasberry cigars arw to die for
Manhasset location makes better cakes, cookies and pastry's.
my birthday cake, pistachio and raspberry mousse cake is to died for!
theres a moon cupcake, yea buddy
Lobster tail and cannolis are the bomb diggity.
Great bakery! Lines are always long but so worth it
Thanks for a great wedding cake! It was beautiful and tasted fantastic.
This place is thee BEST!! Their strawberry short cake is to die for!!!
They didn't honor the $5 00 off check I'm
Speak to Lorena, tell her I sent you.
Everything is my favorite here!
Everything is better with butter! Mocha cake is to die for. Gteat mini deserts.
Great whipped cream cakes for birthdays!
Pick up a cannoli cake for your birthday. While you're waiting, order yourself a cup of coffee.