The decoration is amazing music alive
Pirate's punch is awesome!
The original Hemingway bar and much more fascinating and less commercialized than Sloppy Joe's.
Very laid back and not over crowded. Great history and very divey in all the right ways.
Nice history and a haunted women's bathroom...watch out for the famous punch...it'll sneak up on you.
Look at all the dollar bills and other fun thing posted to the walls!
What can I say?? You have to visit this historic bar!
Great people and service
I've been there! Back then though, we called it "Captain Phonies."
Look at the old pics of Tony & customers that are on wall around pool table. Great history.
A must visit in key west
All you need is a tremendous sex drive and a great ego. Brains don't mean shit.
Lovely ambience :) no food, strong drinks!!
You have to have the pirate's punch. Very refreshing and it really has booze in it.
Miss Capt Tony.
Have fun in the S & M room.. Great photo op ;)
Some places are a must see for the experience, this could be one.....
Jay is the best! ;)
My hubby is my hero as he got a quarter in the fish's mouth!
Try a Captain Tony's Amber while you are here! Discount on refills with the souvenir cup.
Check out the bras hanging over the bar.
Loved this bar. So much cool interesting history stored in here. Captain Tony is a legend. Great live music, great drinks = great memories. A must visit.
Drink excessively hear its accepted
The best bar in Key West. If you aren't here, you don't know Key West. Period.
Interesting place for a lot of history about Key West
With your back to the fish, try to fling a quarter in the fishes mouth.
These guys will charge your phone and make your drink. Awesome.
Gravestones in the bar, a tree growing right in the middle of everything, a legit skeleton behind the bar. Oh and Hemingway hung out here. Can't ask for a better dive bar. Thanks for the tour Jay!
Authentic dive bar of which Buffett sings. Although, too many Parrotheads now frequent, so I go around the corner to "The Green Parrott."
Try a Papa Dobles: two and a half jiggers of white Bacardi, juice of two fresh limes, juice of half a grapefruit and 6 drops of maraschino - it was the occasional drink of Hemingway's.
Love the Pirate's Punch! Rum, gin and tropics.
if you leave a business card you might get called lol. Happened to me!
Best music with Ben and Mike
Wicked! Lots of dusty bras, a tree growing in the middle of the bar, nice live music and a prosthetic leg hangs from the ceiling! Come leave your mark!
Oldest bar in Florida! Home of the original sloppy joe sandwich. Live music and lots of bras hanging around. In the heart of it all and rocks! Capt Tony captained the boat for Hemingway and friends.
Must try to toss change into fish mouth on sign.
Hemingways hangout!!! Must see, within crawling distance of the current sloppy joes!
Leave a business card on the wall!
Check out the Hanging tree and the tombstone in the pool table room. Watch out for ghosts!
Ask your bartender the stories behind some of the graves. And the skeleton hanging on the wall beside a register.
See Will, he's good. Tommy Gunn is a great bartender!
Check out the tree that grew in the middle of the bar. RIP Capt. Tony!
Beer refills are $3.75-just so it! Oh, & it's the main bar that Hemingway visited-never know what might inspire you.
That was the inspiration for Jimmy Buffett's song "Last Mango in Paris"
This is a KW staple full of history. Captain yee shall be missed.
A must-see for Buffett fans visiting Key West. Captain Tony Taracino was a close friend of Jimmy's and the inspiration for the song "Last Mango in Paris."
Great on a random Tuesday and Wednesday.