Gotta love a diner with typos on the menu.
The best thing you can do is drive down the street to Majestic. This was the absolute PITS. McDonald's is definitely a better alternative. Also, beware of the creepy cook/security guy there...creeeepy
Try their chick peas!
Avoid this place like the plague...food is not fresh, we received a stale bread basket, chew canned mushrooms over meatloaf.
Great atmosphere superior service every bit of food great presentation& taste :-) farmers omelette english muffin h2o fruit cup
Large capacity, classic family style diner... Love it!
I'm surprised by all the bad reviews. I've never had bad service or old food. This is my diner of choice in the area. Also, The Majestic is shit compared to Carle Place Diner.
Good food and a great waitress! Ask for Marina. She ia a great lady!
Despite the other reviews, we stayed. Breakfast was good and the waiter attentive. We actually teased that the coffee cup was bottomless.
Its fine nothing wrong I been coming here for a while
Service? Hard to find. Food? From sometime yesterday.
This place sucks. If you are gonna have such shitty late night service, don't stay open all night.
This place is awful! Shitty service, food was not fresh, even the soup was bad..and I don't work at majestic diner but the food is much better there..never coming here again!
I think all people giving bad reviews work at majestic lol... There's nothing wrong with carle place dinner...
Try the French Toast and ask for Rich
Great service. Ask for Rich. Came here 2 days in a row, not only did he remember my order after the first day, he also remembered that I don't like using my eggs fork for French toast.
Waiter service is non existent If you need anything better get up and get it yourself
A bit overpriced but yummy nonetheless. Great breakfast food!
Try the House Salad With Blue Cheese Dressing (via @Foodspotting)
I was satisfied with the service... Really good cole slaw too! Most diners I've been to have their cole slaw just dripping in mayo... Perfect consistency here and just the right amount of sweet.
The best damn turkey burger I have ever had.
Waited for 20 minutes, no waiter so we left
Place is alright. Make sure you ask your change back and receipt.
Hands down a dynamite diner! Richard knew my order by day 3. I could walk in and just get it. Love it!
Just saw a lovely cockroach next to our table. Left without paying the bill. Absolutely grotesque.
Can be hit or miss but the Greek salad with Chicken and French Dip are worth coming back for!
Classic LI diner
Try the Bahama Mama
Order all of their eggs and all of their bacon, son.
Bottomless coffee, breakfast anytime and the same waiters for more than 10 years. Comforting everytime I come back to visit NY.
This place sucks...and dont go on saturday overnights all the creepy cluh guys go there its an odd experience
Our waiter fails the Turing test. Definitely a robot.
This place used to be so good, back in the nineties. It's a shame to see what it has turned into. It's time for them to close up shop.
Ok,,,,so this ranks up there as one of the worst diners visited,,,,rivaling the horrible service at the Sayville Modern Diner. Do yourself a favor and drive down the road and get fast food instead.
Not the best option for diners. Horrible service & microwaved food doesn't cut it. Go to the Majestic, east on Old Country Road 1.4 miles.