Planning a trip to Phoenix?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Casa Reynoso

Mexican Restaurant$$$$
Tempe
Save
Share
8.1/10
88
ratings
  • Ranked #5 for Mexican restaurants in Tempe
  • David D.
    "Try the Gollo burro, enchilada style, with green sauce."(3 Tips)
    Phoenix New Times
    "top 100 favorite dishes in 2011 by the Phoenix New Times!"(2 Tips)
    Natasha M.
    "The machaca tacos are to die for❤️"(2 Tips)
    Sher R.
    "Gallo burro enchilada style is a MUST!"(2 Tips)
31 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • Mexican food
  • gollo burro
  • enchiladas
  • new times
  • machaca
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Carlos L.
    Carlos LoydJanuary 21
    Red and Green chilli
  • Lauren B.
    Lauren BuedelJune 26, 2016
    Slow service, but the food is good
  • Natasha M.
    Natasha MateasMay 18, 2016
    The machaca tacos are to die for❤️
  • Sally H.
    Sally HugginsMarch 11, 2016
    Great family owned restaurant. Good food. Small so you may wait.
  • Amanda M.
    Amanda MeachumFebruary 15, 2016
    Chimichangas are delicious!
  • Jennifer A.
    Jennifer AndrewsFebruary 9, 2016
    Everything
  • Nick B.
    Nick BastianJanuary 7, 2016
    Awesome green Chile and awesome refried beans.
  • Betsy M.
    Betsy Murton-MendozaDecember 3, 2015
    seriously, get the Golla Burro enchilada style (red sauce)
  • Jay H.
    Jay HartwigJuly 29, 2015
    Closed for vacation. I'll be back.
  • Edward H.
    Edward HerreraJuly 27, 2015
    You can't go wrong with a bean burro. This is homemade Mexican food that still is made with love.
  • Cabe M.
    Cabe MartinezJuly 14, 2015
    I've been going to Casa Reynoso ever since I was a little kid. They restaurant is super good and you're guaranteed to love whatever you order. It's nice and cozy and it's run by a hospitable family.
  • Abby P.
    Abby PowskeyMay 28, 2015
    I've only tried the combination plates with enchiladas it was sooo good! Their food is Authentic and friendly service.
  • Gigi S.
    Gigi SingsMay 5, 2015
    F'ing awesome! Best Mexican food I've had since moving to Phoenix. Worth the 45 minute commute each way! Gollo burrito!! Fried ice cream. Machaca chimi!
  • randall c.
    randall chandlerJuly 17, 2013
    came here tonite and we will not be back.food was mediocre,portions for 8$ were small,salsa wasnt impressive.server wasn't very attentive and didnt now basic menu costs.has fair reviews online.
  • Jenn A.
    Jenn AragonFebruary 27, 2013
    I see pictures of empty plates and happy people... They must have gotten their drinks on time. We didn't. We left. Best of new times for food, but what about service?? Two thumbs down.
  • Dennis K.
    Dennis KFebruary 18, 2013
    Been here 100+ times
    Ask for the "extra hot" salsa. It's not that much spicier, and it has a different taste (but equally as yummy) than the regular salsa.
  • Emily B.
    Emily BAugust 6, 2012
    Get goyo burro. It's to die for!
  • Sher R.
    Gallo burro enchilada style is a MUST! It is all kinds of porky, cheesy deliciousness!
  • Rad T.
    Rad TorresMay 20, 2012
    The burros are delicious, but the tacos and enchiladas are nothing special.
  • Darcie
    DarcieApril 1, 2012
    Pretty good food, but not the same as the Globe location. Imo the Globe location was much better. Also the service here was really slow.
  • Robert M.
    Robert MilkDecember 24, 2011
    Gollo burro delicious. Small margarita is real small, but tasty. Cruz is fighting off everyone from his frozen ice cream.
  • Phoenix New Times
    Phoenix New TimesDecember 12, 2011
    Best of Phoenix 2011: Best Neighborhood Mexican Restaurant, Tempe. Have you tried their Pork Chile Verde, whose recipe has been passed down the generations?! Read more
  • BestOf
    BestOfDecember 9, 2011
    The Reynosos use the same recipes passed down from their Miami-Globe abuelitas, and the proof is in the pork chile verde. Read more
  • Doug B.
    Doug BolligOctober 16, 2011
    Best chile relleno in tempe
  • Gabe T.
    Gabe TrujilloAugust 18, 2011
    Been here 50+ times
    Don't leave without ordering a cheese crisp. They're fantastic!
  • Phoenix New Times
    Phoenix New TimesAugust 3, 2011
    You HAVE To get the Gollo burro! It was voted one of the top 100 favorite dishes in 2011 by the Phoenix New Times! Trust us... we know food!
  • Dennis K.
    Dennis KittrellJune 6, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Fantastic Mexican. Read more
  • Troy H.
    Troy HarrisAugust 7, 2010
    My favorite salsa in the valley. Get the nachos with jalapenos
  • Amanda H.
    Amanda HoltzenJune 13, 2010
    Good food, and not too expensive!
  • David D.
    David DaerDecember 9, 2009
    Been here 50+ times
    Try the Gollo burro, enchilada style, with green sauce. Read more
  • Alice D.
    Alice DaerDecember 2, 2009
    Been here 50+ times
    Best margarita I've had in the valley. Great family-owned hideaway in Tempe.
39 Photos