Category icon

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant and Sushi Bar

Seafood Restaurant, Bar, and Sushi Restaurant$$$$
Marathon
Save
Share
8.5/10
95
ratings
  • Stars
    Ranked #4 for seafood restaurants in Marathon
  • Tips
    Mikki M.
    "Honey buns, filet, crab cake, sushi, ......."(2 Tips)
    Matthew H.
    "Great beers, good service, good food, good atmosphere."(3 Tips)
    Theresa M.
    "Mahi stuffed with crab with lobster sauce was amazing!"(3 Tips)
    Gidget J.
    "Love the two year sushi roll."(2 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon35 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • happy hour
  • surf & turf
  • key lime pie
  • casual
  • Caesar salad
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Walt P.
    Walt PaulsonJanuary 21, 2014
    We went "outdoors", which is covered and heated in winter. Why? Cause locals ain't used to temps below 65. Everything we tried was very good , and service by Sasha was excellent!
  • Mikki M.heart icon on user image
    Mikki MorenJanuary 17, 2015
    Everything I tasted was like a sparkler on the 4th of July inside my mouth! Honey buns, filet, crab cake, sushi, ....... So amazing!
  • David S.heart icon on user image
    David SzczublewskiSeptember 11, 2020
    My wife had the California Roll and said it was very good. I opted for the chicken cobb salad which was huge and delicious.
  • Amy C.heart icon on user image
    Amy CDecember 28, 2020
    The sushi is amazing! $7 menu. Key Lime pie with coconut so good. 35 cent wings. All during happy hour. Best place in Marathon!
  • Theresa M.heart icon on user image
    Theresa MurawskiJuly 4, 2016
    Mahi stuffed with crab with lobster sauce was amazing! Melissa was an AMAZING server. She went over the top to make us feel comfortable.
  • Tom J.heart icon on user image
    Tom JApril 28, 2017
    Tuna in radish "tacos" are excellent. The wahoo nigiri is also incredible.
  • Andrew S.heart icon on user image
    Andrew SchmidtApril 22, 2019
    Unassuming fish shack, but great food. Big menu. Solid bar. Patio and music.
  • Amy C.heart icon on user image
    Amy CDecember 28, 2020
    Can’t beat Happy Hour! Sushi, 35 cent wings, Caesar salad, fish tacos, key lime pie with coconut!
  • Theresa M.heart icon on user image
    Theresa MurawskiJuly 7, 2016
    Our second time this week before our departure and it was amazing once again! This time had Mahi stuffed w/ shrimp & scallops! 😍
  • Cindy C B.
    Cindy C BlakisOctober 15, 2018
    Try the Spicy Tuna Hot Dog or the Shrimp Rueben.
  • David D.
    David DewysockiNovember 26, 2015
    Got the snapper mazatlan!!! BOOM. Taste o the Island winner. Outstanding job castaway, great music too!
  • Gidget J.
    Gidget JacksonJuly 15, 2015
    Great food with a large variety of choices. Love the two year sushi roll.
  • Mindy N.
    Mindy NguyenJanuary 1, 2015
    Great ambience, excellent service (Bobby was our server). The tuna tataki was pretty delicious
  • William J.
    William JamarOctober 25, 2013
    Our first time, I thought the food was good and the staff friendly. Loved the Buffalo Shrimp appetizers.
  • Tom M.
    Tom McGruderMay 15, 2011
    Been in Florida 4 days, came here each and every one of them. Great atmosphere to chill in, great selection of beer to chill with, and damn good food. Come on by
  • Andrew M.heart icon on user image
    Andrew McLaughlinFebruary 15, 2015
    Lovely spot. Giant menu with lots of adventurous options. Hugely friendly staff.
  • Mark A.
    Mark AdamsAugust 30, 2013
    They take reservations so make one. Order the crab cake app. Mix with raspberita. Enjoy
  • Will C.heart icon on user image
    Will ConradSeptember 26, 2016
    Sushi. The food and drinks are always great.
  • Mike P.
    Mike PogueOctober 16, 2012
    I love sushi - and the surf and turf roll might honestly be one of my favs...
  • Ami H.
    Ami H.January 27
    Lobster enchiladas with poblano pepper sauce
  • Cindy C B.
    Cindy C BlakisOctober 15, 2018
    52 beers on tap & $3 breakfasts mimosas
  • Brian R.heart icon on user image
    Brian RutledgeAugust 1, 2013
    Food was mid grade at best. I did not have their sushi, however, watched a server leave fresh sushi in the window for over 30 min. Not my idea of fresh. will not be going back. Expected more for $200
  • Paul R.
    Paul RichardsFebruary 19, 2012
    33 kinds of beer on tap, including their own in-house red. Delicious!
  • Rich A.
    Rich AubeApril 13, 2013
    What do you get when you cross a rat and a pie? .... a pirate
  • Matthew H.
    Matthew HenryNovember 30, 2011
    Great restaurant. Great beers, good service, good food, good atmosphere.
  • Jessie
    JessieOctober 22, 2012
    Honey buns are great. Good food & service.
  • Smashley I.
    Smashley ImpsonMarch 23, 2012
    The beer sampler is great, especially if you are having trouble deciding.
  • ᴡ G.
    ᴡ GalloJanuary 2, 2012
    Try the conch burger! It's a baaad (very good) burger!
  • Natalie J.heart icon on user image
    Natalie JonesDecember 20, 2023
    Sushi was great
  • Nancy S.heart icon on user image
    Nancy SeligaMarch 30, 2019
    Chicken parm awesome
  • Nancy S.heart icon on user image
    Nancy SeligaMarch 29, 2019
    Server was obviously new but very sweet. Food was very generous portions but just ok
  • Jayson J.
    Jayson JudsonMarch 11, 2012
    Sushi is good and fresh
  • Myke B.
    Myke BatesNovember 25, 2011
    The Castaway burger will NOT dissapoint.
  • Jonathan H.
    Jonathan HeadAugust 13, 2011
    Good food. Nice people. Poor Poor service!!!
  • Александр Н.heart icon on user image
    Красивый интерьер. Уютно. Большой выбор блюд. Нереальные огромные устрицы. Демократичные цены. Стоит того, чтобы сюда заехать по дороге в Ки Вест.
Photos88 Photos

Related Searches

  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon photos •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon location •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon address •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon •
  • castaway restaurant marathon •
  • castaway restaurant waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon •
  • castaway restaurant waterfront restaurant and sushi barr marathon •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant & sushi bar marathon •
  • castaway waterfront restaurant and sushi bar marathon •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA