City Cakes

City Cakes

Cupcake Shop, Bakery, and Dessert Shop$$$$
Chelsea, New York
Save
Share
8.5/10
95
ratings
  • Mike N.
    "Half pound cookies!"(3 Tips)
    Margot G.
    "The chocolate spice cookies are the best cookies imaginable!"(2 Tips)
    Jennifer C.
    "Salted Caramel cupcake!!! Amazing!"(2 Tips)
    Leah G.
    "their red velvet cookie"(2 Tips)
40 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • cookies
  • cupcakes
  • levain
  • cake
  • authentic
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Anthony P.
    Cash only and they bake fresh daily so options may be low come end of day.
    Upvoted Jun 10
  • Melissa
    MelissaMay 11
    Chocolate chip half pounders are heaven.
    Upvoted Jun 10
  • Justin F.
    These cookies will change your life. Classic chocolate chip cookie is divine. Triple chocolate spice is to be avoided, but oatmeal raisin is surprisingly delish.
    Upvoted Jun 10
  • Lillian C.
    HALF POUND cookies!
    Upvoted Jun 10
  • Gretta H.
    Best cupcakes I've ever tried. Insanely delicious, almost obscenely huge half pound chocolate chip cookie.
  • Mike N.
    Mike NickersonFebruary 6
    Half pound cookies! Heavenly.
  • Jennifer C.
    Jennifer CSeptember 13, 2015
    Salted Caramel cupcake!!! Amazing!
  • Anthony P.
    Anthony PopeoJuly 27, 2015
    Come earlier in the day for more options. Their 1/2 lbs cookies are awesome.
  • Liz D.
    Liz DellJuly 12, 2015
    The 1/2 lb cookies are no joke. Different from Levain, these are more like traditional cookies, but ginormous. Love the oatmeal and snickerdoodle. Also, buy 10, get 1 free!
  • Leah G.
    Leah GeogheganJune 26, 2015
    I just devoured their red velvet cookie, it's stuffed with melted heavenly cream cheese. A must try
  • Gabriela G.
    Gabriela GrossmannMay 24, 2015
    Great but my favorites are at Levain Bakery
  • Diane E.
    Diane EsonFebruary 5, 2015
    Their salted caramel cupcake gives me life!!!!! The best sin I've ever indulged in.
  • Winson W.
    Winson WongFebruary 4, 2015
    Red velvet with cream cheese cookie! Snicker doodle is really good too. $3.50 for a really big cookie! It's soft and chewy.
  • Jillian
    JillianDecember 25, 2014
    Best Looking 2015 Cupcakes of 2014
  • Francis U.
    Francis UdlerNovember 19, 2014
    OMG!! One pound cookies. Had red velvet cookie with a frosting interior!!
  • Roniel T.
    Roniel TesslerNovember 6, 2014
    Best cupcakes in the city
  • Elle K.
    Elle KwonAugust 17, 2014
    Cupcakes taste so moist and cookies are to die for!
  • esther
    estherAugust 14, 2014
    Reeses pieces cookie is bae
  • Alberto S.
    Alberto SimonMarch 19, 2014
    The ginger one is exquisite!
  • Sarah P.
    Sarah PleitezOctober 22, 2013
    Love the new flavors of this month! Oktoberfest (yes like the beer) and Pumpkin Spice! Definitely worth breaking the diet for! And they have a buy 3 or more get 1 free deal everyday!
  • Meredith M.
    Meredith MJune 29, 2013
    You might as well go to a Wal-mart bakery, y'all, cause you'll get the same dry cake and greasy icing as this place, sadly. :(
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin ClementsFebruary 10, 2013
    There's no denying that the cakes they make are gorgeous. But we tried a basic cookie and it didn't particularly impress compared to other spots.
  • Cupcake Crusaders
    Cupcake CrusadersNovember 6, 2012
    Unfortunately our Guest Crusader didn't have a good experience, but we believe in second chances!
  • Tarun
    TarunApril 20, 2012
    You can't see the place from across the street as it is in the lower level. Just walk close to the address and you can see it
  • Eric S.
    Eric S.April 1, 2012
    The best place for cupcakes in the city! Friendlier than Billy's and tastes better too!
  • Jasmine S.
    Jasmine SerranoJanuary 23, 2012
    This place blows Billy's out of the water!!!! So so so deliciously amazing treats! Thanks Mark!!
  • GourmetLive
    GourmetLiveOctober 11, 2011
    Food Bloggers John & Elana Iaciofane say, “City Cakes has hands down the best cakes. Noteworthy are the pumpkin spice and the Key lime, with flavorful icing that is substantial and not too sweet.”
  • Tamara B.
    Tamara BennettSeptember 28, 2011
    Try the Amaretto Cupcake with Sinful Buttercream Icing.
  • Julian A.
    Julian AndrewsAugust 13, 2011
    Get the half-pound cookies. It takes two days to finish one!
  • !:gem:!
    !:gem:!July 7, 2011
    Cookies and cupcakes are stale and lack any sense of excitement. Go around the block to Lulu instead.
  • Margot G.
    Margot GJune 5, 2011
    It is a dangerously delicious place, as you may not want to go anywhere else for cupcakes again. The red velvet cupcakes are wonderful!
  • Margot G.
    Margot GJune 5, 2011
    The chocolate spice cookies are the best cookies imaginable! It dangerous tol
  • Cristal P.
    Cristal PMay 18, 2011
    Their cupcakes are extremely exquisite and unbelievably yummy. Im def. A BIG FAN I try to buy their cupcakes at least every week. YUM
  • Erica G.
    Erica GorochowApril 10, 2011
    Best cookie in manhattan. I promise you this.
  • Dev
    DevMarch 20, 2011
    Right now cupcakes buy 3 get 1 free
  • Amanda
    AmandaMarch 4, 2011
    Their cookies are HUGE and delicious !
  • Marc S.
    Marc StellrechtFebruary 21, 2011
    Buy 3 cupcakes get 1 free at City Cakes!
  • Gilt City
    Gilt CityDecember 3, 2010
    City Cakes are whimsically designed, skillfully executed, and sinfully delicious desserts that rival works of art in beauty and creative flair. We're dreaming of cream cheese frosting...
  • galfromdownunder
    galfromdownunderAugust 21, 2010
    This is the most outstanding giant gooey chocolate cookie in the city. It should be called the giant molten chocolate blowout
  • Ed M.
    Ed MarshallJune 23, 2010
    The BEST place for cupcakes leave magnolia for the clueless tourists
255 Photos

Related Searches

  • city cakes new york
  • city cakes new york photos
  • city cakes new york location
  • city cakes new york address
  • city cakes new york
  • city cakes new york
  • citycakes new york
  • city cakes chelsea new york

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF