Our pies are not always round
Bleh. Pizza has gone way downhill. Tasteless and mediocre texture. bleh.
One og the beste pizzas I have had! Try the Italian or meatball!
If you are going to Co. do try the Popeye pizza. It is unmissable!
Specializing in pizza, they also have a good wine selection at a decent price. Menu offerings are very small though, so not a place for a broader range of Italian fare.
One of the best pizzerias in NY. On my personal top 10 list.
Homemade pizza with fresh ingredients. Very delicious. Get the meatballs and ricotta toast if you have a big enough group to share a lot of things. I have strict sauce standards for Italian food. ✔️➕
Crust was stellar but the sauce on the margherita was very bland and the spinach on the Popeye was overpowering
Delicious pizza and homemade sodas; try the pea and prosciutto pizza
One of our favorite spots; direct off the protected bike lane on Ninth Ave. The Popeye is not to be missed.
Housemade blood orange soda is delicious (like a light cream soda)
The Pizza Bianca appetizer withricotta is my favorite dish
A bit pricey (the artichoke salad isn't worth the price), but the mushroom pizza is delicious
After 2 years, still my favorite pizza (pie) place in the area. Inventive toppings, almost perfect dough. Can't go wrong with Mushroom Jalapeño. Brunch pies with eggs are great, as are the meatballs.
Love this place. Owner of Sullivan St Bakery opened this spot up across the street from one of my favorite Chinese food restaurants. Crust is expectedly unstoppable.
The Sausage & Leek pizza was so good!
Just get the pizza! The pies are big enough for two to share with an appetizer.
Great pizza! Be sure to get the pizza bianca appetizer with ricotta
Ham and cheese pizza!
pizzas are sized for one (but priced for 2). also, not many non-meat options.
Delicious pizza and a few great tap beers.
The sausage and mushroom pizza is my favourite ever pizza!
We know you're here for the pizza but start with the Watermelon Gazpacho!
This, my followers, is THE BIZ! Don't overlook the appetizers, or the salads, or the wine list. And add a pie. It's all delicious.
Shiitake pie is delicious (and vegan)!
Had the Gardiniera and loved it! Especially liked that it was a little spicy.
Stracciatella pizza. Do it.
Try their pizza pies and dessert w/a friend!
Pizza stracciatella was very good, great dough!
According to Adam: "Veal meatballs that you seriously want to pour all over your body and lick up every drop. So damn good."
My friend Adam says, "Veal meatballs... So damn good. They also have them on a pizza. Get both."
Good not great.
Like everyone else here, I really recommend the Stracciatella and Popeye pies! Absolutely love – so scrumptious. Oh, and get the Sake Sparkler to compliment.
Pizza Bianca w ricotta is a must. Also meatballs. Also olives. Also all the salads.
One of my favorite spots for pizza in the city. The ham and cheese pizza is my favorite!
Found Margherita pizza as Yum Yum.
Meatball pizza is delicious and hearty and the stracciatella is lighter if you aren't as hungry
Popeye pizza is good not great. The various toasts and spreads are where it's at.
The food and staff are amazing!!!!
Popeye Pizza all the way! Garlicky, crispy spinach goodness on a plate.
Not a great place if you want traditional pizza. But the ingredients are fresh and they have creative pizza choices!
Housemade ginger ale. First time, every time after this.
the meatballs are really good, and of course the pizzas
Co. undoubtedly offers one of the better pies you will find in NYC. We recommend the artichoke salad, the meatballs, and the shiitake pie, but it truly is all good.
What a rip. Give me big greasy cheap slice any day. Save your money.