Colonia Dairy Maid

Ice Cream Shop$$$$
  • Annamarie M.
    "Ice cream cakes are excellent and way cheaper than Carvel."(2 Tips)
    Patti 🙋
    "Best Rocky Road and love the pretzel cones."(2 Tips)
    Hamburger H.
    "Milkshakes on point!"(4 Tips)
    Nadine C.
    "Cake batter ice cream is awesome!"(2 Tips)
36 Tips and reviews
  • ice cream
  • carvel
  • pretzel cone
  • family-friendly
  • milkshakes
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • William F.
    William FranklinJune 16, 2014
    Best ice cream around I'll pass Carvel and Dairy Queen and I live 2 towns away best soft ice cream prices are very reasonable
  • Breeanna T.
    Breeanna TaipinaAugust 24, 2015
    I just got a medium cup with hard ice cream and the flavors were cookie dough Smore's and cake batter it was really good you should really try it that combination
  • James S.
    James SimsAugust 14, 2015
    Ask for the pretzel cone. Also, come when the Great Dane rescue group visits!
  • Tom M.
    Tom M.August 24, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Best ice cream in town-- a must visit, year round
  • Ann O.
    Ann OroJune 24, 2014
    It is worth the wait even if the line seems really long. It is a cash only establishment.
  • Victoria
    VictoriaAugust 7, 2014
    The ice cream takes so good and is way better then generic super store ice cream. Basically like homemade.
  • Annamarie M.
    Worth any waiting time. Ice cream cakes are excellent and way cheaper than Carvel.
  • Dan L.
    Dan LawsonAugust 6, 2014
    You haven't lived until you've put your time in on the parking lot line. Best ice cream around.
  • Gauri C.
    Gauri ChitnavisDecember 3, 2014
    Mango flavor is my favorite I enjoyed orange pineapple too!!
  • Patti 🙋
    Patti 🙋April 28, 2013
    Best Rocky Road and love the pretzel cones.
  • Michael R.
    Michael RomeroJuly 13, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the Red Velvet or the Blueberry if they have it.
  • Dan S.
    Dan SohaydaMay 7, 2017
    They only take cash but there's a small ATM in there
  • Dave
    DaveJune 14, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Great ice cream and Italian ice. Wonderful staff
  • Tyler M.
    Tyler MortensenJune 25, 2015
    So many flavors! Best ice cream around!
  • Dia s.
    Dia smithMay 30, 2014
    The ice cream here is boss aka excellent aka fire aka mad!
  • Kate L.
    Kate LaSalaMay 23, 2010
    Perfect for a summer night, if you don't mind the long line!
  • Lisa M.
    Lisa Maloney 💋July 22, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Best coconut ice cream everrrrr!!!
  • Christine P.
    Christine PastorApril 28, 2012
    Best Ice Cream spots in New Jersey Mag!
  • Margaret D.
    Margaret DziegielewskiApril 13, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    I love the pineapple ice.
  • Amanda T.
    Amanda TorresAugust 2, 2010
    So yummy! Good ice cream & cheaper than other places!
  • Cheryl A.
    Cheryl AbarayAugust 23, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
  • Daniel L.
    Daniel LagstromJuly 16, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    Be prepared for a line out the door. Very much worth the wait.
  • Harold C.
    Harold CabezasJune 21, 2011
    Best Ice Cream In The Area...No One's Even Close! Read more
  • Nadine C.
    Nadine ChaykaJuly 13, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Cake batter ice cream is awesome!
  • Joseph L.
    Joseph LakatosMay 30, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    act like an ass they get you out fast
  • 🌸Karen🌸 .
    🌸Karen🌸 🌺Smidt🌺August 13, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Best ice cream around !!!
  • John B.
    John BrushSeptember 4, 2013
    Best ice cream around!
  • 🌸Karen🌸 .
    🌸Karen🌸 🌺Smidt🌺September 18, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Pumpkin ice cream is delicious
  • Nick M.
    Nick MojicaJuly 6, 2015
    Try the milkshakes
  • Yvette G.
    Yvette GioveMarch 24, 2010
    The peanut butter sauce is amazing on anything!
  • Aimee R.
    Aimee RothOctober 25, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    It was so so good yum
  • Maria C.
    Maria CorradoMay 19, 2017
    Home made.
  • Hamburger H.
    Hamburger HelperJune 25, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    Milkshakes on point!
  • Melissa O.
    Melissa OlundMay 1, 2011
    Worth the warm weather line.
  • Hamburger H.
    Hamburger HelperSeptember 27, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Killer shakes.
  • Ariela B.
    Ariela BurnettMarch 17, 2013
    Terrible shake. First and last time here. Very icy and not smooth
56 Photos