Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

Pizza Place and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Port Jefferson Station
Save
Share
8.7/10
97
ratings
  • Jodz C.
    "Pizza, calzones, salads top rated for many years."(8 Tips)
    James
    "Best Sicilian slice on Long Island."(4 Tips)
42 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • authentic
  • great value
  • lively
  • good for a quick meal
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Gail
    GailDecember 28, 2014
    This place has been around for longer than I care to mention (it will show my age). It is the best. Always has been. You don't mess with perfection!
  • James
    JamesJune 19, 2013
    Best Sicilian slice on Long Island. Salad is awesome as well (you can add chicken!).
  • James
    JamesSeptember 8, 2012
    Sicilian Slice, Buffalo Slice, and a salad (big enough for two). Can't go wrong with these choices.
  • Robert C.
    Robert CarrozzaDecember 15, 2014
    Awesome pizza, busy at times. But that only shows you that this place is good
  • Eva B.
    Eva BardunAugust 25, 2011
    This is my favorite place to get a quick slice. Try a regular salad with grilled chicken!
  • William Z.
    William ZezelicOctober 15, 2014
    Incredible meatballs..if you like branchanellis in hauppauge try this!
  • Brian P.
    Brian Pinard KD2KIQDecember 11, 2014
    Ask what the special is, you won't be disappointed!
  • Explore L.
    Explore Long IslandFebruary 20, 2013
    Our readers voted Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant into the "Readers' Pizza Hall of Fame" for Long Island! Read more
  • John M.
    John McIntoshAugust 14, 2014
    Awesome pizza, plain slices and Sicilian.
  • Jodz C.
    Jodz CasabananaSeptember 14, 2010
    Pizza, calzones, salads top rated for many years.
  • Stephen J.
    Stephen JulianoJanuary 8, 2013
    Sicilian pie is the way to go!
  • Sal F.
    Sal FigsJune 2, 2013
    Don't even aSk for a menu it's pointless pizza salad n a pinwheel ur set
  • John Y.
    John YeamansFebruary 22, 2013
    Someone told me to try the desert pie! I don't mind if I do lol
  • William Z.
    William ZezelicJune 20, 2014
    I travel here from setauket just for pizza..its that good!
  • Joe S.
    Joe SciarrinoJune 1, 2011
    Best Sicilian slice ever, period!
  • Brian P.
    Brian Pinard KD2KIQNovember 29, 2011
    Great NY style slices and pies!
  • Marisa C.
    Marisa CannonJanuary 21, 2014
    Great salad and Sicilian slices.
  • Gavin J.
    Gavin JohansenNovember 12, 2011
    Great pizza but bring cash no plastic
  • PhilipJames F.
    PhilipJames FotoAugust 23, 2011
    Outstanding Pizza. The Best!!!
  • Evie ♡ F.
    Evie ♡ FMarch 6, 2013
    White pizza the best I ever had mmmm
  • Frank N.
    Frank NegronJuly 16, 2010
    One of Long Islands best pies!
  • Colleen G.
    Colleen GrodotzkeJune 28, 2012
    Fave pizza place! So good
  • Jordan M.
    Jordan MichnoffMay 4, 2010
    Definitely eat here. Best pizza around.
  • Katelyn S.
    Katelyn SchlusslerFebruary 27, 2013
    Updating their registers may start taking credit cards? WHAT!!?
  • Stephanie B.
    Love the pizza Oh my geeze (:(:(:
  • Joe A.
    Joe A 🌴September 19, 2014
    Pizza and much more
  • Carol L.
    Carol LislevatnMay 9, 2012
    The best pizza around. Hands down!
  • Trevor
    TrevorApril 30, 2012
    Gotta love a place that is this busy and cash only.
  • Manny O.
    Manny OjedaSeptember 6, 2012
    Best Sicilian Pizza!!!
  • Ryan A.
    Ryan AnnunziatoDecember 2, 2011
    Best pizza hands down!!
  • Kat S.
    Kat SederquistJune 1, 2013
    Salad pizza is amazing.
  • Elizabeth W.
    Elizabeth WardNovember 23, 2011
    Salads are GREAT.
  • Nancy R.
    Nancy RoyAugust 7, 2014
    I love their pizza.
  • Kelsey P.
    Kelsey PlassSeptember 19, 2011
    the bald guy is a dirt bag! that's a fact
  • Peter S.
    Peter SchlusslerJune 10, 2013
    No credit cards...You know what that means for us tax payers
  • Peter S.
    Peter SchlusslerJune 11, 2013
    Nope no credit cards yet...thank you tax payer
  • Peter S.
    Peter SchlusslerFebruary 2, 2013
    Only takes cash!...hope it all gets reported as income!
  • Pete B.
    Pete BealeyFebruary 18, 2011
    Great eats
  • Oi R.
    Oi RogersFebruary 11, 2011
    Overated!!!!
  • Russ B.
    Russ BrownApril 4, 2015
    Best pizza I've ever had!
  • Russ B.
    Russ BrownApril 4, 2015
    Best pizza ever!
  • Matthew J.
    Matthew JosephMarch 1, 2012
    Best pizza ever!
29 Photos

Related Searches

  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station
  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station photos
  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station location
  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station address
  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station
  • colisseo port jefferson station
  • colosseo port jefferson station
  • colosseo pizza port jefferson station
  • colosseo pizza & restaurant port jefferson station
  • colosseo pizza and restaurant port jefferson station
  • colosseos port jefferson station

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF