The garlic bread is ridiculous. SO GOOD!!
The lunch special is a must! Insane amounts of food for $15-$20. Dinner portion servings for half the price.
Ask for the snow crab legs. that should only be the reason your there.
Come early, there is always a long line.
LUNCH. SPECIAL IS ALWAYS. GREAT. ALWAYS LEAVE FULL. WITH NO ROOM FOR THE FREE DESERT.
Rocking! This spot is worth the trip! Pit red lobster to shame!!
Soft shell crab well season
Great lunch deals! Had the mussels and snow crabs and both were amazing! Great service as well!
Not ideal for vegetarians, but an OK penne vodka and some pretty amazing garlic bread. It's worth the trip for the experience, alone. It's quite the establishment. Come patient, long lines always!
Garlic bread is awesome n the red snapper. Be sure to leave a tip
Great food and service this will keep me coming back. Bread was awesome...
A feast is really enough for four people(four men) Order an appetizer to share and you have a great bang for your buck! My recommendation is order the steamers with garlic.
the food was great. surprised at how good the graham cracker crusted cheesecake was. definitely get with strawberries!
Best place for seafood on the Island. Native owned! Support local business!
REAL garlic bread keeps on coming - so good. Ask for anything broiled for a garlic butter crust mmm. Crab Lover's Dream = Heaven.
Get a pitcher of the sangria
Great value for the seafood. Attentive and efficient service.
Get the special, loads of lobster and it's the best!!!
Don't worry the wait staff are familiar with ginger ale
Best Lobster and Crab Legs cobo and Oyster Sopu
Ask for Billy C . Best waiter in the place ! He is friendly , courteous , fast and you'll be sure to leave with a smile !
Been here a few times & it's the best seafood spot in City Island. The garlic bread, crab legs, lobster & shrimps are to die for & the drinks are always on point. They make official Nutcrackers!! :D.
One of the best seafood restaurants in City Island. Try the broiled shrimps and scallops - SLAMMIN'!!! and don't get me started on the drinks... love their mojitos!
Clams and lobster are big enough to share for 2! Great place
Crab legs. Oh yeah. Thanks Dutch for the loan.
the Feasts for Two are a tad smaller than Sammy's - but MUCH fresher/tastier and $30 less... the rice served underneath the shellfish is much softer and tastier as well.
Incredible seafood, my favorite place on the Island.
come ready hungry, and the platters for 2 actually feed 3... the crab is great
Get the crab
Awesome, reasonably priced, great enviorment! Get the lunch special Broiled Seafood Platter! Great Mixed drinks for the ladies!
The platters for 2 are huuge -- great for sharing between 3-4 ppl...i loved being able to sample different seafood rather than having to choose btwn all the yummy entrees. cooked well, very tasty
Ask for a Henny-Colada
The baltimore style spicy crabs are hella good and not really spicy at all. A+ on the garlic bread
The baltimore style spicy crabs are hella good and not really spicy at all. A+ on the garlic bread.
My absolute favorite restaurant for crab. Go early as they don't take reservations!