Cyril's Fish House

(Now Closed)
Bar, Seafood Restaurant, and Fish & Chips Shop$$$$
Amagansett
Save
Share
  • TV Food Maps
    "Check out Cyrils Fish House as seen on Drinking Made Easy"(6 Tips)
    The Corcoran Group
    "Their Lobster Roll is awesome!"(4 Tips)
    Men's Health Mag
    "Baily’s Banana Colada."(2 Tips)
    Ellie R.
    "Get the BBC and ask for an extra "floater" of rum."(2 Tips)
46 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • cyril
  • extra floater
  • outdoor seating
  • trendy
  • oysters
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Dens
    DensAugust 19, 2012
    Absolute shitshow in the summer, but stop by anyway for a BBC w/ a floater. I reversed engineered the recipe to: blender, can of piña colada, half can of baileys, half can of rum, 2 bananas, ice Boom!
  • Manda S.
    Manda ShettletonSeptember 3, 2012
    Order a BBC, a banana-y alcoholic drink. Underline alcohol. Seriously, if you get the extra floater, it's over. Good spot for ppl watching and day drinking. Cyril is probs holding court at a table.
  • Men's Health Mag
    Men's Health MagNovember 17, 2011
    This little shack on the side of the highway has fresh seafood and cold beer, and attracts people who don’t seem rushed about anything. Your best bet? Baily’s Banana Colada. It’s a Cyril specialty.
  • Roger E.
    Roger EhrenbergAugust 15, 2011
    Fun honky-tonk open-air bar between Montauk and Amagansett. Gotta try the "BBC with a floater." Don't ask - just try it. Read more
  • Shelley L.
    Shelley LapcevicSeptember 10, 2011
    Beware of the lobster roll for you fellow celery haters out there (though delish). Dog friendly patio is fantastic!
  • Adam M.
    Adam MuggenthalerAugust 7, 2010
    Ask if Davey D's in the house, he's always willing to share his keen insight on various topics over a cold BBC...
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupSeptember 30, 2014
    Known for their BBC drinks (Bailey's banana colada). Their Lobster Roll is awesome!
  • Victor M.
    Victor MazzeoJuly 17, 2010
    Have the Lobster Roll (the best in the Hamptons) and chase it with a famous BBC with "a topper".
  • Bill O.
    Bill O'LearyFebruary 13, 2015
    Legendary summer Saturday afternoon social meeting spot. Still going strong. Food not bad either, surprisingly.
  • Rumana S.
    Rumana SiddikyJuly 6, 2011
    BBC is the obvious choice but the food is actually quite good. Love their quesadilla!
  • Sundar A.
    Sundar ArganJuly 9, 2014
    No more than 2 BBC's with a floater, unless you want to wake up naked on the beach and not in the good way.
  • Jason K.
    Jason KaplerAugust 3, 2012
    Pay respect to Cyril with some Marlboro reds... and then drink as many BBCs as you can. They're money!
  • Edward S.
    Edward SeborJuly 30, 2015
    Day drinking Utopia... In a gravel driveway. Order a couple BBCs and blackout like you know you should
  • Diplomatico Rum
    Diplomatico RumJuly 23, 2012
    Sit back, relax and enjoy one of their many frozen drinks. Perhaps one with a little rum?
  • Suraj 🙇🏽
    Suraj 🙇🏽July 1, 2012
    BBCs are lethal and necessary. Watch out for lots of side-parts and Carly Rae Jepson
  • Three Jane
    Three JaneJuly 27, 2012
    After a day spent at Indian Wells, join everyone you've ever met at Cyril's for a BBC. 
  • Sasha S.
    Sasha SugarAugust 7, 2012
    Crab cake and stuffed mushrooms are Delicious!
  • Davey D.
    Davey DSeptember 6, 2010
    If Billy B and Seth are around tell 'em Davey_D says they owe you a drink...or five.
  • Ellie R.
    Ellie RountreeJuly 9, 2011
    Get the BBC and ask for an extra "floater" of rum.
  • TV Food Maps
    TV Food MapsSeptember 2, 2014
    Check out Cyrils Fish House as seen on Drinking Made Easy Read more
  • Tim H.
    Tim HealyAugust 24, 2011
    Flounder sandwich with Rum Punch. BBC for dessert!
  • David T.
    David ThalbergAugust 1, 2012
    Perfect for a quick bite as we head back to the City
  • Kate M.
    Kate McPhailAugust 13, 2011
    Order a BBC with a floater. On the floor...
  • Timothy W.
    Timothy WilliamsSeptember 8, 2012
    Try the BBC with a floater - yum!
  • Danielle G.
    Danielle GechtAugust 20, 2010
    Dog friendly patio. Great lobster roll and oysters
  • Tania L.
    Tania LucieMay 25, 2013
    BBC with a floater- delish!!!
  • Jillene B.
    Long line for the restroom. Plan accordingly!
  • Ally M.
    Ally MannAugust 4, 2015
    Two BBCs and you're good for the night.
  • khitam n.
    khitam nakhlehSeptember 1, 2012
    Over rated was so much better a few years ago!!!!
  • Jessica J.
    Jessica JohnsonSeptember 1, 2012
    Have to try the BBC. Best drink in the house
  • Daniel M.
    Daniel MorganJune 2, 2012
    Be sure to make out with a stranger.
  • Rosemary D.
    Rosemary DorsettAugust 24, 2013
    Terps take note: Starboard of the Northeast.
  • Melissa R.
    Melissa RossAugust 20, 2013
    Have the BBC with a floater at the bar
  • Devana B.
    Devana BhargavaMay 26, 2014
    Get the banana milkshake!
  • Michelle Joni L.
    Michelle Joni LapidosNovember 30, 2010
    Try the Lobster and Mussels
  • Ruggero M.
    Ruggero MassettiJune 20, 2013
    Try the Fritto Mist
  • Jon S.
    Jon SteinbergJune 27, 2010
    The floater is worth it
  • Nick C.
    Nick ContiJuly 9, 2012
    BBC with a floater!!! Holy shit!!
  • Frank c.
    Frank cAugust 13, 2014
    Saturdays outdoor drinking
  • Efrem
    EfremJune 18, 2011
    The lights are cool
  • Adam M.
    Adam MuggenthalerMay 28, 2010
    Watch out for Davey D...
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaSeptember 10, 2014
    So sad about Cyril's...
  • Julie F.
    Julie FabrizioJune 7, 2010
    BBC with a floater!
  • Savannah P.
    Savannah PetrickAugust 17, 2015
    clam chowder
  • lee t.
    lee tachmanJuly 17, 2010
    BBC with floater
  • Michael G.
    Michael GogelMay 29, 2010
    Have a BBC
204 Photos

Related Searches

  • cyril's fish house amagansett
  • cyril's fish house amagansett photos
  • cyril's fish house amagansett location
  • cyril's fish house amagansett address
  • cyril's fish house amagansett
  • cyril's amagansett
  • cyril's fish house amagansett
  • cyrills amagansett
  • cyrils amagansett
  • cyrils fish house amagansett
  • cyrlis fish house amagansett

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF