(Now Closed)
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
55 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Eater
    EaterFebruary 7, 2014
    The chefs recently served dishes like hamachi crudo, Maine sea urchin with soba, cod with smoked bacon and beets, pork belly with roasted fruit, beef ribeye, and duck with black kale. Read more
  • J Crowley
    J CrowleyDecember 15, 2013
    One of the best restaurants in Carroll Gardens. Loved the spaghetti Nero as app. Endive salad is great side share. Lamb ribs = yum. For cocktails: Meyer lemon smash (bourbon) or Earl Swizzle (rum).
  • Mark S.
    Mark SabecApril 29, 2014
    Easily the best, most inventive restaurant I've been to in the last year. Every bite is packed with different textures and flavors. Lamb tortellini and cod are delicious. Get the lemon thyme cake!
  • Aarti S.
    Aarti ShenoyJanuary 18, 2015
    Brilliant little nook on Carroll Street. The brunch menu was selective but heavenly. The best part, the chef made us a 'chocolate surprise' even though they don't serve dessert for brunch! Loved it!
  • Eater
    EaterAugust 14, 2014
    From Ryan Sutton's 2 star review: "Cod in an aioli-thickened fish fumet, a culinary ode to the color off-white, is as meaty and buttery as blanquette de veau." Read more
  • Brian M.
    Brian MasefieldNovember 10, 2014
    The tasting menu was incredible (and they can substitute items for vegetarian/pescaterian). Their Creme brûlée is one of the best desserts I've had in a very long time. Go!
  • Nancy S.
    Nancy SchusterMarch 8, 2014
    Jump in a cab, do not walk. Have the tasting menu and I liked sitting at the bar. Matthew, the mixologist, made a melange of cocktails that weren't even on the menu. Reco high!!!
  • Leo K.
    Leo KimMay 10, 2014
    Wonderful restaurant, great service. Good enough to make Manhattanites trek to Brooklyn. Try the tasting menu, and feel free to make substitutions!
  • Wilson Z.
    Wilson ZhouAugust 8, 2014
    Peach en Papillote comes out steaming hot, with the peaches wrapped in parchment paper and swimming in brown butter. Bonus: There are pistachios sprinkled on top.
  • Armando
    ArmandoAugust 29, 2014
    On the menu find eggs benedict, shrimp étouffée, and a few holdovers from the dinner menu, like lamb ribs with eggplant, peanut, and mint.
  • Kathleen D.
    Kathleen DuganMay 31, 2015
    We wanted to love this place so much. It's in our hood. However, it took 1.5 hours until we received our entrees. The food was fantastic, but we felt pretty forgotten. Maybe it was a fluke?
  • Elaine L.
    Elaine LinSeptember 28, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best brunch in the neighborhood. Every dish was perfect and service top notch. On the pricey side but totally worth it.
  • Cameron K.
    Cameron KoczonNovember 15, 2016
    The pasta is unbelievable. Menu changes regularly and everything is always delicious. Best restaurant in the neighborhood.
    CITY GRITAugust 9, 2014
    We can’t choose a favorite from the Raw dishes – we love them all. But an ace dinner order = Summer Squash + Lobster + Lamb Ribs! The Orange Julius cocktail is the perfect dessert!
  • Nick B.
    Nick BurtoOctober 9, 2014
    Service was incredible, food & wine excellent, the setting could be better considering how good the other two were. Inside too cold & noisy, outside too quiet and awkward, need some background music.
  • Saif D.
    Saif DiaSeptember 13, 2015
    Quaint neighborhood feel, with incredible food to pair. Get the 7 course tasting menu if you want an experience.
  • Bettina B.
    Bettina BanayanDecember 27, 2013
    Super attentive service which I love. Suggestions: uni and soba, Nero pasta. Must haves: lamb ribs- unreal
  • A W.
    A WriterSeptember 9, 2015
    Foursquare's 8.8 rating is a travesty for cooking (and service) of this calibre. Up there with La Vara (and Battersby - same chefs).
  • Tiffany S.
    Tiffany SDecember 20, 2014
    The chicken for two!!! It comes in 3 delicious courses, the best bang for your buck!
  • Marina L.
    Marina LApril 8, 2015
    Quality food, what a refreshing find in Carroll Garden! Poached cod is light and delicious
  • Amanda S.
    Amanda SchneiderApril 7, 2015
    Amazing tasting menu and cocktail. Try the black bass and the Stay Gold cocktail!
  • Maria S.
    Maria SolnechnajaAugust 31, 2015
    The best food. Chef is the God! All the experience is incredible. Delicious!
  • Akshay P.
    Akshay PatilSeptember 30, 2014
    It's pricey, but the food and service do not disappoint. Indoor ambiance is the weakest link here, so sit outside if weather permits.
  • Melody G.
    Melody GambinoOctober 16, 2014
    The bites they give you between courses are amazing and better than what's on the menu
  • ZZubin
    ZZubinJanuary 18, 2015
    Brunch: Bloody Mary, biscuit n eggs, salmon or oyster app. Skip the sausage
  • Erin S.
    Erin Schulte CollierSeptember 11, 2016
    The crispy breakfast potatoes are sinfully delicious, don't miss them.
  • Premshree P.
    Premshree PillaiFebruary 7, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    The Vietnamese inflected fall-off-the-bone lamb ribs are a delight.
  • loran j.
    loran jonakMay 1, 2015
    Quiet place with friendly service and very tasty menu choices
  • Gideon O.
    Gideon OlshanskySeptember 22, 2015
    Order anything. One of the best restaurants in the neighborhood.
  • Maria W.
    Maria WApril 16, 2014
    Squid ink tagliatelle and the Mackerel were amazing
  • Irena C.
    Irena CMarch 2, 2014
    The cauliflower appetizer is great, especially if you like vinegar.
  • Tim J.
    Tim JulienSeptember 15, 2014
    The outdoor seating is really great
  • WillMcD
    WillMcDJuly 13, 2014
    one of the best meals we've had in Brooklyn
  • David M.
    David McGillivrayFebruary 4, 2015
    Relaxed atmosphere, phenomenal food, amazing service.
  • Alexandra L.
    Alexandra LeiteJune 3, 2015
    Where Gourmet Brooklyn couples and friends eat when they are no loner hipsters.
  • Jaim
    JaimMay 15, 2016
    Paella, fried zucchini, broiled oysters, burrata
  • Janice M.
    Janice M.January 11, 2014
    Nero squid ink pasta may just be better than Al Di La's version
  • Amy F.
    Amy FullerApril 22, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Get the tasting menu. 5 or 7 courses. Incredible.
  • Jaim
    JaimMay 15, 2016
    Paella, fried zucchini, burrata, broiled oysters
  • Tanya M.
    Tanya MenendezJuly 27, 2014
    Solid food. Oysters and ravioli were good.
  • Barb B.
    Barb B.August 22, 2015
    Tasting menu, bread, cocktails, duck, lamb...everything!
  • Giulio d.
    Giulio del BufaloApril 17, 2015
    Amazing food. Highly recommend the spontaneous tasting menu.
  • Bitches Who Brunch
    Bitches Who BrunchOctober 15, 2015
    The Bitches say: A. A sophisticated, but no-frills Brooklyn brunch. Read more
  • Joe G.
    Joe GallagherDecember 7, 2013
    You want the lamb ribs. Trust me.
  • Fueled Collective
    Fueled CollectiveSeptember 23, 2013
    Make sure to keep an eye on this place. A larger version of Smith Street shoe box.
  • Noelle V.
    Noelle Via BordaJune 15, 2014
    Not a huge fan for those of the veg persuasion. Service was great, though.
  • Anita K.
    Anita KeireJune 4, 2016
    Oysters with rhubarb, and salty olive oil!
  • Frederic B.
    Frederic BonnOctober 31, 2014
    Always an amazing dining experience.
  • Meeshell
    MeeshellJanuary 19, 2014
    Lamb ribs all the wAy! (Skip caviar)
  • Michelle S.
    Michelle ShkediMarch 29, 2014
    Amazing! Try the risotto
52 Photos