Eataly

Eataly NYC

Gourmet Shop, Market, and Italian Restaurant
200 5th Ave (at W 23rd St), New York, NY 10010, United States
Hours:
Closed until 10:00 AM (Show more)
  • Mon–Sun
    • 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
Reservations:
Yes
Drinks:
Beer, Wine
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi:
Free
Outdoor Seating:
Yes

Eataly is a dynamic marketplace with restaurants that was created in Torino, Italy by Oscar Farinetti in 2007. There are 26 Eataly stores in the world.

9.5/10

Based on 5,143 votes

People like this place

Total Visitors
75,508
Total Visits
138,509
Save
Share
  • What you need to know
    NYU Restaurateur C.
    Yet another Mario Batali masterpiece - the man is unstoppable!(16 Tips)
    Andrea D.
    head upstairs to Birreria for a brewsk and cheese plate.(15 Tips)
    Sean W.
    The Prime Rib Sandwich covered in olive oil.(28 Tips)
    laura l.
    Fresh pasta counter blissfully uncrowded at 1 on a Monday afternoon(20 Tips)

From Eataly NYC

Special

Enjoy a free glass of Prosecco on check in when ordering lunch at Manzo.

Log in to leave tips at this venue!
Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular

1,104 tips. Filter by taste:

  • all tips
  • gelato
  • wine
  • pizza
  • mario batali
  • Italian food
  • espresso
  • pasta
  • sandwiches
  • seafood
  • rooftop
  • birreria
  • prime rib sandwich
  • paninis
  • pastries
  • oysters
  • beer
  • cheese
  • vegetarian food
  • café
  • ravioli
  • Debora C.

    Muito bom com bastante diversidade. O atendimento é complicado

    Debora Cavalheiro · 1 day ago
    Save
  • Thiago R.

    O Lugar da Nutella, que todos amam.

    Thiago Rodriguez · 6 days ago
    Save
  • Leda Cristine M.

    Pastas, queijos, etc

    Save
  • Glory

    Ritrovare l'Italia nella grande mela!

    Glory · 1 week ago
    Save
  • Rosa K.

    Gelato, assorted cheese & salami, seafood, al dente pasta

    Rosa K · 1 week ago
    Save
  • LeAnna C.

    Hazelnut gelato is so much yum on hot days! Worth the splurge!

    LeAnna Christiansen · 1 week ago
    Save
  • Sarah F.

    Amazing fresh seafood.

    Sarah Fields · 1 week ago
    Save
  • Munchies

    Watch hip-hop artist Action Bronson get a tour of Eataly from chef Mario Batali, where they sampled salumi and formaggi, made pizzas, and dined on a delicous stuffed fried quail. Read more

    Munchies · 1 week ago
    Save
  • Erkan K.

    First Eataly in the world. Very delicious food. Too many different choices. And good Italian wines...

    Erkan Kacikoc · 2 weeks ago
    Save
  • Connect4 Wine - Tom H.

    Antipasto plate of cheeses and cured meets. Excellent with the rose.

    Save
  • Angelina Z.

    the rooftop bar is the best

    Angelina Zeppieri · 2 weeks ago
    Save
  • Alex SJ

    They have everything you might want. Although the wine section next door was not as large as I hoped.

    Alex SJ · 2 weeks ago
    Save
  • DaniBraga

    Coma tudo que puder!

    DaniBraga · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Marcelo D.

    O La Pasta é incrível!

    Save
  • Ru L.

    The fish bar was so fresh. A bit pricy but totally worth it.

    Ru Lu · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Giovana C.

    O ravioli de ricota com molho de limão e pistache na parte das pizzas/massas é divino! Fora a quantidade de temperos e molhos para levar... Excelente!

    Giovana Caron · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Rosa K.

    Gelato, coffee, pasta, ham & cheese tray, seafood

    Rosa K · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Patricia S.

    Lugar imperdível para quem aprecia uma boa comida italiana. E se estiver com saudades de um bom expresso por aqui tem!!! Prove o tiramissu que é delicioso

    Patricia S. · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Paula S.

    Simply awesome!

    Paula Schafer · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Michele P.

    If God was Italian this would be Heaven

    Michele Piccaro · 3 weeks ago
    Save
  • Debora D.

    Qualidade e variedade.

    Debora Do Carmo · April 19
    Save
  • Rafael Z.

    Nothing special with the prime ribs sandwich. =\

    Rafael Ziggy · April 16
    Save
  • Kubilay C.

    great Italian restaurant..

    Kubilay Cirrik · April 16
    Save
  • Sean W.

    The Prime Rib Sandwich covered in olive oil. #Addicted #NYC

    Sean Weber · April 15
    Save
  • Dave C.

    Super weird, but you can't take food from one of the mini restaurants and eat it in one of the other mini restaurants. So figure out where and what you would most like to eat.

    Dave Cummings · April 15
    Save
  • Stephen S.

    Way overpriced: Chocolate for $35 a pound, cheese for $28 a pound, lamb for $40 a pound, etc.

    Stephen Schimpf · April 15
    Save
  • Karan T.

    Great place to get good coffee, gelato, wine, cheese and meats!

    Karan Tamhane · April 15
    Save
  • Mary M.

    much smaller than the eataly in Rome, but a nice thing to have in NYC! lots of Italian grocery items. a bit pricey at times, but a very fun store.

    Mary Motta · April 14
    Save
  • Brandon D.

    Shockingly cheapest red is best on the menu at rooftop beer bar or so my Pinot loving wife says

    Brandon Dudley · April 11
    Save
  • M V.

    Finally a REAL Italian in the city. love it

    M V · April 10
    Save
  • Tom C.

    Best prime rib sandwich I've ever had! Simply fresh bread, EVOO, a sprinkle of sea salt, and of course, delicious PR.

    Tom Cragin · April 10
    Save
  • Grumpy Llama L.

    Gnocchi a la Romana

    Grumpy Llama Llama · April 10
    Save
  • Ben

    The pizza is reasonably priced and delicious. Get some sort of espresso as well.

    Ben · April 9
    Save
  • Maria R. P.

    Cool place. Excellent pasta.

    Maria R. Paiz · April 7
    Save
  • Charlotte S.

    Wow, it's wonderland for foodies! I thoroughly enjoyed perusing the shelves and bought some lovely oil and vinegar. Must return to sample the many in house dining options. All looks divine.

    Charlotte Scarf · April 7
    Save
  • Marco S.

    Foodies paradise. Vegetables, Cheese, Fruit, Fish, Meat...basically everything. Get a table in the middle and order all of the things!

    Marco Sousa · April 6
    Save
  • Vivian V.

    Awesome place to explore.

    Vivian Vo · April 6
    Save
  • Raquel O.

    Grandioso mercado interior con motivo Italia

    Save
  • Miguel R.

    Though I cannot argue this place has good quality products, it is doomed to be one of two things: a tourist trap or a public restroom

    Miguel Robledo · April 5
    Save
  • Martha

    amazing stuff. intoxicating.

    Martha · April 5
    Save
  • Melay M.

    Everything is good you must give it a try to every station

    Melay M · April 4
    Save
  • Melissa R.

    It's wild here! Go to the charcuterie area yum

    Melissa Reohr · April 4
    Save
  • Cecilia F.

    Just go there. Heaven.

    Cecilia Frankel · April 2
    Save
  • Richie C.

    Pricey, but the best jams here if you're into 90s r&b 😭❤️

    Richie Chen · March 30
    Save
  • summer d.

    Absolutely amazing experience! Tried gelato, espresso, wine, and chocolates.. All were so authentic and delicious. A feast for the all of the senses.

    summer daidone · March 29
    Save
  • Bruno B.

    Take a moment to study everything this place has before coming here. It's way bigger than it looks like and can get pretty confusing. Awesome place tough.

    Bruno Bottega · March 29
    Save
  • Victoria W.

    Salamis, cheese, bakery, fish

    Victoria Wooster · March 28
    Save
  • Rica C.

    If you want to reminisce about Italy... This is pretty much the place... Close to it.

    Rica Corazon · March 28
    Save
  • Andres

    Great variety of cooking articles, ingredients and food. All in the italian mood of course

    Andres · March 28
    Save
  • Khalil i.

    Great selection of fresh produce

    Khalil ibitefood · March 28
    Save

Appears on 3,972 lists

See all »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.