Eataly NYC

Gourmet Shop, Market, and Italian Restaurant · NoMad
200 5th Ave (at W 23rd St), New York, NY 10010, United States
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon–Sun
    • 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
Beer, Wine
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating:
Wheelchair Accessible:

Eataly is a dynamic marketplace with restaurants that was created in Torino, Italy by Oscar Farinetti in 2007. There are 26 Eataly stores in the world.


Based on 6,501 votes

People like this place

  • What you need to know
    Travel + Leisure
    "year-round rooftop beer garden with hearty bites from Mario Batali"(20 Tips)
    Brew York
    "home right by the elevator for Birreria."(17 Tips)
    Remco V.
    "The prime rib sandwiches are delicious, the rooftop bar is fun."(30 Tips)
    laura l.
    "Fresh pasta counter blissfully uncrowded at 1 on a Monday afternoon"(22 Tips)

From Eataly NYC


Enjoy a free glass of Prosecco on check in when ordering lunch at Manzo.

Log in to leave tips at this venue!
  • Recent
  • Popular

1,213 tips and reviews.

  • Filter by taste:
  • all tips and reviews
  • Italian food
  • gelato
  • wine
  • pizza
  • mario batali
  • seafood
  • pasta
  • espresso
  • sandwiches
  • rooftop
  • prime rib sandwich
  • birreria
  • café
  • paninis
  • ice cream
  • pastries
  • oysters
  • vegetarian food
  • lasagna
  • beer
  • caroline s.

    Buy your fancy Italian snacks and take them to go- it is always so crowded! Not worth sitting at a table with shoppers and tourists pushing up against you as you eat.

    caroline sistare · 13 hours ago
  • Aniruddh C.

    Venchi chocolate and pizza!

    Aniruddh Chaturvedi · 1 day ago
  • Justine B.

    aka Italian Heaven in New York. Like a traditional Italian Piazza hidden at the bottom of a New York building. Explore every little inch of this wonderland.

    Justine Bloome · 4 days ago
  • Lindsay Longobardi S.

    Fantastic selection of Italian treats!!! They really have everything!

  • Elizaveta T.

    Go straight to Italian sandwiches, avoid cakes. Take warm mozzarella panini with prosciutto. Possibly the best thing ever happened to me.

    Elizaveta T. · 6 days ago
  • annlou

    Make sure to be hungry and in good company when you go here...because there's so much you want to taste

    annlou · 6 days ago
  • Lauren M.

    Super fun Italian emporium. Tasty things galore! Get gelato 🍦

    Lauren Mac · 1 week ago
  • Gary H.

    Get the focaccia for lunch. The grilled eggplant is my favourite. If you want dessert, the gelato is a safe bet. A trip to NYC would be incomplete without a stop at Eataly, especially for foodies.

    Gary Hor · 1 week ago
  • Garry T.

    Prime rib sandwiches, don't forget the extra salt and oil.

    Garry Tan · 1 week ago
  • Erika S.

    One of my favorite places in NYC!

  • Brownstone Living NYC

    Great for date night, group hangs, family time.. Late nite dessert: Belgian Waffles w/Nutella and Sweet Cream to live for..

    Brownstone Living NYC · 2 weeks ago
  • James

    Great selection of Italian imported goods, albeit not cheap.

    James · 2 weeks ago
  • Tino

    Eataly. Definitely a place to eat.

    Tino · 2 weeks ago
  • Gabriel d.

    Great market, but the food is pretty normal.

    Gabriel d. A. L. · 3 weeks ago
  • Allison L.

    So. Much. Pasta.🍝

    Allison Loftus · 3 weeks ago
  • Silvia E.

    A must when in NYC, you can be here hours strolling through the shelves, looking at cooking books and eating ! Try the Pappardelle with lamb ragu, delish!

    Silvia Edgell · 3 weeks ago
  • Anissa

    Enjoy a selection of cheese and charcuterie with a glass of wine!

    Anissa · 3 weeks ago
  • Sam H.

    Amazing gelato.

    Sam H · 3 weeks ago
  • Amanda G.

    Lots of fun to wander around!

    Amanda Gobaud · October 26
  • Leisha M.

    Great grocery store with a ton of different restaurants to try!

    Leisha Magsisi · October 25
  • Pit P.

    Expensive kitchen stuff

    Pit Pitoca · October 21
  • Claudia F.

    Always great.

    Claudia Filth · October 13
  • Molly S.

    Great, if overwhelming. All your Italian food needs can be met here.

    Molly Stoddart · October 11
  • Ram C.

    Amazing place to shop and eat but line to Birreria is too long

    Ram Cherizli · October 11
  • CRUZiiiE

    Whether you stroll in casually to shop for wine or sit down for dinner- can't really go wrong here. Grab a gelato on your way out!

    CRUZiiiE · October 10
  • Get My Grub On! w.

    The ultimate on Italian shop / restaurant experience. It's all here.

  • S E.

    I ❤️ this place. I sneak over to this location every chance I get.

    S E · October 6
  • Suzi S.

    Fresh seafood

    Suzi Simão · October 3
  • Sophia Y.

    Everything here is great... Nothing bad to say besides the fact that it's a little crowded

    Sophia Y. · October 3
  • Bruno C.

    Buy a pizza 2 go and a nutella crepe. Sit on a sidewalk or park and eat. This is NYC.

    Bruno Cardoso · September 29
  • Gonzalo F.

    Gelato, Pizza, and Mozzarella like they do it in Italia! Must try.

    Gonzalo Fiorina · September 26
  • Lynora C.

    Wine,pizza and ice cream

    Lynora Chew · September 26
  • Zeynep Duru G.

    Awesome gelatos ever eaten

    Zeynep Duru Görmeli · September 22
  • Zeynep Duru G.

    Awesome gelatos ever eaten..

    Zeynep Duru Görmeli · September 22
  • Janice B.

    This place is truly magic, truly NYC, especially the crudo bar...

    Janice Bell · September 22
  • Charlotte S.

    Roast beef sandwich

    Charlotte Still · September 22
  • Kirill K.

    Wonderful place to spend an evening... Their gelato is a must!

    Kirill Kukuruza · September 21
  • Gabriel M.

    Its crowded

    Gabriel Marchezini · September 20
  • Tal M.

    If the line for ice cream is too long, go to the Nutella stand and get ice cream there.

    Tal Morse · September 17
  • Yan P.

    Look for La Rosticceria and get the prime rib sandwich or the daily special. You won't be disappointed.

    Yan P · September 15
  • Lisa R.

    Convenient place to meet friends but not too impressed by the food.

    Lisa Rayle · September 15
  • Jenn S.

    The fresh squid ink pasta is a must-try. 🍝

    Jenn Schwartz · September 13
  • Kaitlyn W.

    Wine, cheese, fresh pasta, real olive oil stacked to the sky! Too wonderful for words.

    Kaitlyn Watson · September 9
  • Melike Ç.

    Market area is the best in NYC however the restaurants are overrated

    Melike Çulcuoğlu · September 9
  • Saif D.

    Produce is at a great price

    Saif Dia · September 8
  • Felipe P.

    It's a nice place. No doubt about it. Great food, nice environment, BUT unnecessarily expensive. Try to arrive no later than 12pm to reduce waiting time. Have fun! 😉

    Felipe P. · September 7
  • Thomas P.

    Awesome market place and eatery for Italian food. Also, get one of the Nutella Crêpes.

    Thomas Pajor · September 6
  • Chris E.

    Everything is so good and wonderful.

    Chris Evans · August 31
  • JP P.

    This is an Italian food lovers paradise. It has everything and anything you could want. Definitely try the many restaurants, first come first serve and the gelato/coffee spot

    JP Park · August 27
  • Laura S.

    Wish I could try everything!

    Laura Shum · August 26

Related Searches

  • eataly nyc new york
  • eataly nyc new york photos
  • eataly nyc new york location
  • eataly nyc new york address
  • eataly nyc new york
  • eataly new york
  • eataly new york
  • eataly bakery new york
  • eataly new york new york
  • eataly nyc new york
  • eataly pasta & pizza to go new york
  • eataly pasta & pizza to go eataly new york
  • eataly pasta & pizza to go @ eataly new york
  • eataly pasta and pizza to go new york
  • eataly pasta and pizza to go @ eataly new york
  • eataly nyc nomad new york

Foursquare © 2015  Lovingly made in NYC & SF

Appears on 4,309 lists

See all »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.