Planning a trip to Tampa?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Eddie and Sam's Pizza

Pizza Place$$$$
Tampa
Save
Share
9.1/10
229
ratings
  • Nicholas G.
    "Truly the best NY style pizza in Tampa"(7 Tips)
    Marilyn C.
    "The pizza is the best in tampa bay!!"(4 Tips)
    Heather N.
    "Best NY Style pizza in Tampa."(9 Tips)
    Stan S.
    "lasagna pizza is so delicious"(6 Tips)
81 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • tampa bay
  • gelato
  • authentic
  • family-friendly
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Karen G.
    Karen GrahnMay 28, 2013
    the garlic knots are good, and big. the 20" can easily feed 4 people. I'm from NY, and it's easily with in my top 5 pizza places. If i lived closer i'd go back, (and gain a hellof alot of weight) :)
  • Karen G.
    Karen GrahnMay 28, 2013
    their garlic knots are big, and good. we got a Lasagna pizza got a 20in. it could've fed 4 people easily. a good place to go to. I'm from NY, it was amazing pizza.. :) I'd definitely go back :)
  • Ca B.
    Ca BaApril 6, 2015
    I like the white pizza (Bianca) and the veggie pizza, always have a hard time deciding between the two. Love stopping here for a quick slice or two or ordering a pie to go. Best pizza around
  • Camaron
    CamaronDecember 29, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    I'm from Long Island ,I consider myself a pizza purist. The water as simple as it sounds makes a huge difference.The simple atmosphere ,extraordinary pizza is a slice right out of the Big Apple!
  • Senaf D.
    Senaf Dillon-PickhardtJuly 14, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    What makes their Pizza the best New York Style is their water. They have water shipped from the New York Springs. That is what makes the dough so tasty and just right!!
  • Kathy L.
    Kathy LoveDecember 18, 2011
    Coming from a Brooklyn girl, this is the best pizza Tampa Bay has to offer. It 99% NY flavor! The garlic knots are massive and delicious...best part they're only 50 cents!
  • Sara L.
    Sara LehmanMay 25, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Get their special! 2 slices of cheese and a drink for $5.99. Such great pizza, nice space and always friendly staff. Best pizza in Tampa!
  • Heather N.
    You want real deal NY pizza...this is the place to come...the biggest pies and slices, you can't go wrong.
  • Raffaele R.
    Phenomenal pizza !! I grew up in the Bronx with 4 pizzerias in the neighborhood. Believe this is authentic NY pizza and better!
  • Vernon J.
    Vernon JonesJanuary 14
    Pizza was very good and garlic knots were very good. So the family and I will definitely be going back again soon! 👍👍👍
  • Nelson I.
    Nelson IrizarryDecember 21, 2014
    The pizza is the best. Im in Riverview we take a special trip just to go and stuff our faces.. The staff very friendly
  • Albert V.
    Albert VidalApril 20, 2013
    This place brings the heat! Easily the best pizza in Tampa. The garlic knots are unbelievable. So is everything else...
  • Heather N.
    Heather NelsonFebruary 13
    Best NY Style pizza in Tampa. This place is a treasure, I love NY style pizza. And their XL...it's HUGE!
  • Michael G.
    Michael GAugust 7, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    All the desserts are top notch including the chocolate peanut butter cream pie, gelato, and cannoli.
  • Drew C.
    Drew CoffmanMarch 20, 2015
    Grab a couple of slices of a classic like pepperoni and grab a soda from their Coke Freestyle machines.
  • Brotha K.
    Brotha K.September 1, 2013
    Cheese and pepperoni is the choice you should make. Garlic knots are big for price.
  • Kevin K.
    Kevin KrauterJanuary 30
    It's very good pizza and it's reasonable price. Kind of reminds me of a NY City type restaurant.
  • Kyle W.
    Kyle WinnegarOctober 3, 2013
    I'm from Queens originally, and this place is 100% authentic. Awesome slices.
  • Ceci T.
    Ceci TricoliNovember 3
    Lasagna slices are out of this world! Best pizza in all of Tampa Bay!
  • Albizu A.
    Albizu AcevedoApril 27, 2012
    One of the best NY Pizzerias in the Tampa Bay Area(toss up between them and Paci's)
  • Rob
    RobJune 15, 2013
    Oh my goodness! The Gelato is amazinggggggg. Strawberry Chip was delicious
  • Danielle P.
    Danielle PAugust 26, 2013
    Garlic knots are huge! And only pizza around Tampa that can compare to ny pizza
  • Kimberley A.
    Kimberley AsanteJuly 4, 2014
    Freaking amazing pizza.. Garlic knots were bigger than my face. Extremely satisfied!
  • ALex J.
    ALex JosephNovember 17, 2013
    Good pizza. Check in on yelp for a free cannoli.
  • Josh M.
    Josh MNovember 30, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Seriously good NY style pizza. Lots of choices and gelato in the same building! What's better?
  • Mike R.
    Mike R.April 18, 2013
    Been here 50+ times
    Great Pizza and Spag. & Meatballs. I don't just eat any spaghetti neither.
  • Marvin C.
    Marvin CoreaMarch 13
    Awesomely large slices of pizza!
  • Jrgts
    JrgtsNovember 2, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza by the slice in downtown Tampa.
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhApril 11, 2015
    They import New York water to make NY style pizza! A piece of home 😘😍
  • Heidi W.
    Heidi WebbOctober 12, 2014
    Whatever you want on your pizza.... They got it!
  • Lizzy G.
    Lizzy GravelleJune 6, 2014
    Got the tv by the television... And was watching tv... But really great pizza place!!!
  • Ryan C.
    Ryan CarrollJanuary 22, 2015
    Who gives a F where they import their water from!? Great Za!!!!
  • Stan S.
    Stan SmithAugust 14
    lasagna pizza is so delicious
  • Marilyn C.
    Marilyn CardonaFebruary 15, 2015
    The pizza is the best in tampa bay!!
  • Katie G.
    Katie GisonniNovember 26, 2015
    The white pizza here is AMAZING and the pieces are giant
  • Brandt C.
    Brandt CosgroveNovember 23, 2014
    Best Pizza in Tampa for me!
  • Luuvv B.
    Luuvv BuggMarch 16
    The pizza the staff and the garlic knots
  • Tom P.
    Tom PerriconeFebruary 24, 2014
    Amazing pizza! Best in Tampa!
  • David G.
    David GMay 29, 2011
    The Remodeled yes. But the Pizza is STILL the best outside of New York!
  • David C.
    David CohenJuly 19, 2014
    Awesome gelatin! Campfire and salted caramel are awesome!
  • Iliana Taleno And A.
    Best thin crust pizza we had in Tampa.
  • Tim I.
    Grab a quick slice, great pizza!
  • Steffanie C.
    Steffanie CliftonNovember 1, 2013
    Awesome. Awesome. Awesome. Gotta try this pizza!
  • Bob G.
    Bob GeorgeSeptember 20, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza always good and piping hot!!
  • Danny K.
    Danny KrutkoFebruary 5, 2015
    Worst customer service ever, from the employees to the manager himself. They completely lied to us about a pizza, which had to do with our serious allergies, and then did nothing to correct situation.
  • Heather K.
    Best pizza in Tampa hands down!
  • Lane P.
    Lane PelovskyJanuary 27, 2013
    Amazing Gelato
  • renee u.
    renee uihleinJanuary 1, 2012
    The meat stromboli, amazing!
  • Rob
    RobJune 15, 2013
    The Lasagna Pizza! Wow!
  • Nicholas G.
    Nicholas GizziFebruary 4, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Truly the best NY style pizza in Tampa
160 Photos

Related Searches

  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa
  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa photos
  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa location
  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa address
  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa
  • eddie & sam's ny pizza tampa
  • eddie & sams ny pizza tampa
  • eddie and sam's ny pizza tampa
  • eddie and sam's pizza tampa
  • eddie and sams new york pizza tampa
  • eddie and sams ny pizza tampa
  • eddie and sams pizza tampa
  • sam and eddies ny pizza tampa

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF