If you'd like your sundae horizontal instead of vertical, the technical term here is to ask for it in a "banana boat". Then you can get to both flavors of ice cream, simultaneously.
The ice cream is amazing.
Food lackluster but the ice cream is legendary.
GOAT ice cream sundaes in the Bay.
The crab sandwich is my favorite
Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Sundae. 😋
Black and Tan... homemade carmel? Yes, please!
Excellent service and the best ice cream !!!
Are you kidding me?! DELISH! Make sure to go in on your birthday!!! 😉
Coffee Cookie Dream Milkshake and Cookie Connection are my go-to's!
Long line but hey.. As a youngster from this area it was all about hanging and still is .... Right.. I would sit at the counter to get fast service and have the sliders any day. no wait....
I visit this restaurant from time to time and the level of their service improves a lot. The staff are corteous and kind. I also love that the serving time is fast.
Everything is so good!
The lines are long but the waiting is worth it. Lots of favors from Strawberry cheesecake to Rocky road. Enjoy!
Try the Fenton's Club (via @Foodspotting)
If you are solely talking about quality of icecream, this place is just about average or below. Atmosphere is cool, but that's really it. Go to Lush Gelato instead.
Have your ice cream sundae served in a "boat" instead of a sundae dish so all flavors may be accessed without digging to the bottom of their generous helpings.
Creamy and rich ice cream!
Ice cream for dessert, or burgers, hot dogs.. This is the place. Very good.
Awesome ice cream, food, and atmosphere. Great for special occasions
The BEST place to get an ice cream stomach ache! They serve a mean French Dip au jus as well.
Mango sorbet is a delicious alternative to ice cream.
Forget the diet and try the chocolate icecream!
Fenton's not only a place for ice cream, but they have wonderful selection of breakfasts for reasonable prices. :-)
Seasonal ice creams !! Sundaes for the sit in dates. Great for kids!
Service is always good here. They hooked up the nuts so I didn't go nuts!
Good place to hangout with friends. Never seen such a large creamery establishment before
Get the brokeback brownie!
Mozzarella sticks are crazy
Portions are massive. Definitely share with three, maybe 4, people if you're getting a specialty.
Good diner food, but make sure you make some room for dessert. They're best known for their HUGE sundaes
The coffee cookie dream has the best coffee ice cream ever.
Solid sandwiches, clean place, A+ customer service. Only tried the regular vanilla ice cream (there's also vanilla bean) but it was really good. Bring $$$. Almost $5 for a single-scoop cone. Ouch!
Get the flight for ice cream to try three different flavors. Best deal of the menu, enough to serve two.
Have a classic chocolate milkshake.
Hot fudge sunday with banana nut ice cream
Splitting a sundae is a good idea. I usually split with one other friend if we're both hungry :)
The line was insane but moved quick. The location is legendary. We go for the dessert and the milk shakes are not to be missed.
Huge ice cream and the best taste!!!!! must come!
Banana Jr sundae!
Black and Tan sundae is the best! Swap out one of the flavors for Swiss milk chocolate ice cream to make it even better than the original
Coffee break cookie
The petite cup serving is more than enough for an adult. The single is way too much ice cream--even though you'll definitely eat it all because it is do delicious.
Food was okay but I came for the ice cream!
Try a sundae on a Sunday. Come early for breakfast and stay for some ice cream.
Best ice cream spot in the Bay Area. It's been around for over 100 years and never gets old.
Ice cream sundays