Besides pie (black bottom oat!)...the scones are always a stand out
Their strawberry balsamic pie is simply delectable. Was never even a pie person till I tried this place!
that salted caramel apple pie though…
Black bottom oatmeal pie
The pies here are so amazing, I make the trek all the way from NJ to have some of their pies, on the occasion when I stay at Shelter island I make the extra effort to visit the other location!
While this is good pie, it's not 9.4 pie. We might have pie grade inflation
The matcha mint latte is mm mm good
Alot of people think the pies are great. I think they are ok. Not to crazy about the pumpkin pie and not to crazy about the coffee.
matcha custard pie. swoon 😍
A hidden gem in the lobby of the library, get a slice of anything but especially the salted caramel apple.
I had to get a copy of their cook book for my collection. The Salted Caramel Apple Pie was glorious. Might have to re-visit once more on this trip, to try another pie.
Cortado is so yum
Slices went up to $5.75. Was always underpriced at $5.
Get a slice of savory for your meal and a slice of sweet for dessert
Best pie I had in NY!
Never settle for a single slice. One should be Salty Honey, the other a seasonal fruit.
Don't forget to get a coffee with your slice
The pie crust is reminiscent to a croissant in its perfect flakiness. Try the nectarine if they have it!
Pair your nectarine pie with some vanilla ice cream, it's fire
Heavenly-buttery crust. Some of the best pies I've ever had. Stumptown coffee is always a win.
So freaking delish. Try the black bottom oat and the peach pies!
Seasonal item: matcha custard! Yum.
Holy moly! The salted caramel apple was a hit! Take a pie to a potluck and you'll be the hero!
I like both the buttermilk pie and the salted apple pie that I tried.
The caramel apple pie is to die for!
Worth the schlep to Third Avenue.
The salted caramel apple pie was pretty good, but wish the caramel and salt flavors were stronger. Pre-order and pickup was super easy and convenient!
Amazing pie nuf said
Great pies, though the price is a little steep. Located just south of the Whole Foods.
Strawberry streusel pie is incredible. Apple rhubarb was something I never had before and I dug it. Literally can't go wrong with any menu choice you make.
Really love their blackbottom oatmeal pie! But let's be honest, all their pies are delicious.
Love this place!! Pies are so outstandingly delicious, the hardest part is picking just one slice out of their tasty options. Nom.
All. The. Pies. Get a few different slices to share. The seasonal flavors are always unique and worth a try. It's all about that butter crust. Their other confectionery treats are delicious as well!
Pie so good you'll want to stand on the tables and sing about it. Ask the staff for their recommendations, they've never let me down. Free refills on the ~$2 coffee
"This is where pies go when they die." HEAVEN on a plate.
The pie menu changes quite often, but stick around until your clothes smell like pie. I repeat: until your clothes smell like pie.
Pie you guys. Pie.
Most excellent crust.
Lemon and caramel apple pies (winter seasonal selection) are sensational. My mouth is crying out of happiness as we speak. 👌👌
One of my fav places for pie and coffee in all of Brooklyn!
Pie and coffee. Buttermilk Chess.
Very cute little place that smells amazing, has great coffee, and some of the best pie I've ever had. Salted Caramel Apple is a classic, pumpkin and lemon pies were great too.
The chocolate pecan pie was life-changing.
These pies are amazing. Keep coming back for the new and seasonal.
Best pies ever.
Place is very relaxing and MUCH bigger than it looks on pics. Slices are pretty huge. Nice laid back staff.
Delicious salted apple pie. Iced coffee rocked too, and the service was super friendly, helpful, and quick :)
The salted caramel apple pie has become a staple in my diet.