The tuna tartare was fantastic. The tartin on point. Great cocktails as well. A must go!
Went for restaurant week. Surprisingly disappointed. Black noodle entree was terrible. A soupy mess. Enoki mushrooms were stuck together and chewy on the bottom of the bowl. Usually a great place.
Went here for NYC's Restaurant Week. Didn't think there was anything exceptional about Gotham especially considering its price, but its assorted sorbets and signature Gotham cake save it.
Expensive. Good rack of lamb. Flourless chocolate cake mediocre.
Very good rack of lamb. Mediocre (dry) flourless chocolate cake but very good salted almond ice cream. Great service.
One of my fav. restaurants. Great fish main courses. Famous for their seafood salad and NY strip streak. All excellent. Highly recommend. : A
The drinks are amazing! The staff is amazing! And although you might be tempted to think you can get a steak anywhere, GET IT HERE!
Tuna tartare, seafood salad and the seared fois gras are amazing. Oh, that seared fois gras!Cauliflower was forgettable. Rack of lamb and pork chop were fine but didn't blow us away.
Incredible food, good lively atmosphere, not too stuffy. A more 'senior' crowd, but probably because they keep coming back. Definitely visit
Sit up top for an amazing experience and if you have an anniversary, call in advance as they do it right.
A classic, seat at the bar for a quick meal (reservation) but the menu is limited.
Very expensive but impeccable service and food. The seasonal menu is always top-notch but don't miss the tuna tartar or the steaks.
Excellent decor, service and overall experience
The foie gras is absolute buttery goodness.
Seafood Risotto, Five Spice Duck, and basically everything was fantastic!
Awarded one star (★) in the 2015 Michelin Guide for NYC restaurants.
foie gras with fig chutney & pistachios; Best thing I ever ate!
Amazing restaurant week lunch deal! Spectacular ambiance, service and food.
Love! Especially during Restaurant week, it was a great opportunity to try the resto at an affordable price. Definitely one of the best places I've been at in NYC so far!
No question go for the Prix Fixe. The duck is great. Pair with their Santenay Bourgogne
Chocolate cake is amazing as well as the crudo for appetizer! Will be back
Excellent service and food
The chocolate cake is mysteriously phenomenal
wild striped bass ceviche with the Gotham Burger or a roasted beet salad, with the spendiest options being a pan-seared halibut or beef short ribs.
Great cocktails, superb service and mouth watering dishes, really an all around fantastic place. Good for a business dinner or for a third date.
Very lovely place and great food. The custard with citrus and oats was awesome.
Good food with formal service but stuffy.
The chocolate cake was definitely amazing.! And meat lovers should try the short beef ribs, amazing..!!:)
Service, ambiance, food and wine are all delivered with lightness, thought and care.
Great traditional NYC spot with an affordable lunch pre fix. Very classy experience with delicious food.
The duck was amazingly delicious!
Unbelievably great service and food - tuna tartare, oysters, duck - make this standard a stellar choice time and again.
Had an unbelievable meal here for my birthday! Cannot wait to go back. One downside is the service: very slow
Don't miss the Tuna tartare, rack of lamb, and chocolate cake
Great miso marinate cod, and the steak was also amazing according to my boyfriend. Quite expensive (especially the wines).
Best tuna tartare and seafood salad I ever had! The food is amazing and the staff incredibly professional. Excellent wine list is a plus.
Book in advance and ask to be placed on one of the tables on the platform. That's where the regulars go - and for good reason. Lobster is wonderful and the steak is perfect. Do both!
Hard to go wrong with the tuna tartar.
Miso cod was extraordinary.
Ask the sommelier for help with the wine list. We loved the tuna tartare, dido red wine, miso cod, and veal (was a special), pictured below. Save room for the chocolate cake - it's worth it!
Fantastic strip steak.
Black Cod, the halibut, soft shell crab, and of course, the Gotham chocolate cake served with salted almond ice cream. Yum.
Best chocolate cake in the city. Fresh fish appetizers also amazing.