Grandma slices. Can't beat 'em.
What's not to like! Lunch special: 2 plain slices and a soda for $5 (incl. tax)...
Come here when the pizza is fresh. Go elsewhere if its not fresh.
Good for pizza lovers who want to try sthg a bit different from usual NY pizza.
The pizza at Gotham Pizza is by no means great—a little greasy, the sauce is a little heavy-handed with dried herbs. What is great about it is the crust—rolled in a heavy coating of bread crumbs.
Pizza was yummy but at 2.75 a slice it hurt to pay for it. Hate to say but If it was a Lee I would come back.
The crust is perfect. This is a Grade A slice.
The crust is awesome, real crunchy. I really like this thin pizza.
Best margherita slice in Chelsea
If I could give this place a rating, it would be Jeff Goldblums leather jacket in Jurassic Park.
Pizza with a little different take on their crust. Not bad.
My slice place. Thin crust pies, and a solid Grandma slice if you want something more hearty.
The Margherita is my favorite slice
Gave pizza place to order delivery from. The margarita slice (or whole pie) is really the bee's knees.
Better than Stella's pizza. My favorite around Chelsea.
The Margarita pizza is really good.
Crust is amazing, could eat everyday!
+1 on crust and the special. Though the pizza place up the block has the same deal.
Great lunch special: 2 GIANT slices of regular pizza and a soda for $5 even. Hard to top that in New York.
+1 on the slice of grandma. Amazing
This is the best "grandma pie" in Manhattan.