Gotham Pizza

Pizza Place$$$$
Chelsea, New York
Save
Share
7.4/10
72
ratings
  • Steve R.
    "The Margherita is my favorite slice"(3 Tips)
    Michelle P.
    "Thin crust pies"(2 Tips)
    Anastasia I.
    "... the neighborhood for delivery > Patsy's (now closed) >> Famous Ray's...."(3 Tips)
    Khoa L.
    "Great lunch special: 2 GIANT slices of regular pizza and a soda..."(2 Tips)
28 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • delivery
  • casual
  • good for a quick meal
  • great value
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsSeptember 23, 2013
    The pizza at Gotham Pizza is by no means great—a little greasy, the sauce is a little heavy-handed with dried herbs. What is great about it is the crust—rolled in a heavy coating of bread crumbs.
  • Anastasia I.
    Anastasia I.March 18
    Best pizza in the neighborhood for delivery > Patsy's (now closed) >> Famous Ray's. Crunchy crust & fresh ingredients. Order delivery all the time.
  • Khoa L.
    Khoa LeJuly 5, 2010
    Great lunch special: 2 GIANT slices of regular pizza and a soda for $5 even. Hard to top that in New York.
  • Stephen D.
    Stephen DeFigueroaApril 20, 2013
    Pizza was yummy but at 2.75 a slice it hurt to pay for it. Hate to say but If it was a Lee I would come back.
  • Kendra C.
    Kendra ClarkeOctober 3, 2011
    Gave pizza place to order delivery from. The margarita slice (or whole pie) is really the bee's knees.
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsJanuary 18, 2012
    A middle-of-the-road NY-style slice that's set apart by its unique breadcrumb coated crust. Read more
  • Michelle P.
    Michelle PaeJanuary 6, 2012
    My slice place. Thin crust pies, and a solid Grandma slice if you want something more hearty.
  • Gary B.
    Gary BennaimAugust 15, 2014
    What's not to like! Lunch special: 2 plain slices and a soda for $5 (incl. tax)...
  • marvin m.
    marvin mitchellSeptember 9, 2010
    +1 on crust and the special. Though the pizza place up the block has the same deal.
  • Shahrulmiza Z.
    Shahrulmiza ZakariaDecember 5, 2013
    Good for pizza lovers who want to try sthg a bit different from usual NY pizza.
  • Steven W.
    Steven WalkerJanuary 9, 2013
    The crust is awesome, real crunchy. I really like this thin pizza.
  • Steven K.
    The secret to why this is great pizza is the cornmeal coating on the bottom.
  • Justin E.
    Justin EntrupMay 29, 2014
    Come here when the pizza is fresh. Go elsewhere if its not fresh.
  • David M.
    David MinkinMarch 21, 2013
    The crust is perfect. This is a Grade A slice.
  • Ashley S.
    Ashley SorrondeguyJuly 1, 2012
    If I could give this place a rating, it would be Jeff Goldblums leather jacket in Jurassic Park.
  • Kirk E.
    Pizza slices flavorful. Use corn meal in the crust for some extra crunch.
  • Steve R.
    Steve RuraOctober 20, 2011
    The Margherita is my favorite slice
  • Clyde Erwin B.
    Clyde Erwin BarrettoApril 26, 2012
    Pizza with a little different take on their crust. Not bad.
  • Yoshi M.
    Yoshi ManaleOctober 9, 2010
    Crust is amazing, could eat everyday!
  • Jesse F.
    Jesse FriedlandAugust 22, 2011
    Better than Stella's pizza. My favorite around Chelsea.
  • Pierre
    PierreNovember 25, 2012
    Best margherita slice in Chelsea
  • Kate F.
    Kate FilmoreFebruary 16, 2011
    The Margarita pizza is really good.
  • angularism
    angularismApril 28, 2010
    This is the best "grandma pie" in Manhattan.
  • Simon A.
    Simon AbramsJanuary 17, 2015
    Grandma slices. Can't beat 'em.
  • Jesse N.
    Jesse NicholsApril 30, 2010
    +1 on the slice of grandma. Amazing
  • Jose R.
    Jose ReyesApril 3, 2013
    Great pizza!
  • Shannah T.
    Shannah TigheJuly 26, 2011
    Sooo delicious!!
  • Ashley S.
    Ashley SorrondeguyJuly 1, 2012
    ERMIGHERD! PERZZA!
40 Photos